In a time when America just can't seem to put a lid on its unrelenting racial issues, Golfweek thought they had the solution, breathing new life into the widely publicized noose cases that died out over the holidays.The magazine's cover was in reference to the Golf Channel's Kelly Tilghman's comment that young golfer's should "lynch Tiger Woods in a back alley," as a way to stop his dominance. Tilghman was suspended by two weeks and has issued two apologies to Tiger Woods, who brushed it off as a "non-issue."
"Was it an arresting image? Yes, it was," Golfweek editor Dave Seanor told USA Today. "We chose it because it was an image we thought would draw attention to an issue we thought deserved some intelligent dialogue."
Intelligent dialogue is one thing, but when you knowingly feature such a polarizing symbol on the cover of your magazine, just to sell copies, that's irresponsible. The Jena six controversy sparked a domino effect revealing a litany of idiots 'rediscovering' the noose as across America, hanging them everywhere from offices to teacher's lounges.
Sadly, there have been so many noose incidents, that DiversityInc.com has been able to populate a national "noosewatch."
Despite the fact that the magazine's parent company has made a swift move to replace the editor of the magazine, the bigger issue is that the editors of a national publication thought it would a good idea to even put nooses on the cover in the first place.
"We apologize for creating this graphic cover that received extreme negative reaction from consumers, subscribers and advertisers across the country," Turnstile Publishing Co. president William P. Kupper Jr. said. "We were trying to convey the controversial issues with a strong and provocative graphic image. It is now obvious that the overall reaction to our cover deeply offended many people. For that, we are deeply apologetic," according to to the Associated Press.
Hmm, that's apology number? Black America seems to be losing count of people making these public faux-pas' and then recanting only after realizing that they said or did something inappropriate.
It's a forgone conclusion that a serious dialogue on race needs to take place in golf as well as America, but a noose on a golf magazine probably isn't the best starting point.


Comments: (109)
Add a comment
By: Russell R. on 1/21/2008 5:09PM
Whats wrong with the noose? I think everyone should own at least one!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Cara on 1/22/2008 12:09AM
Nooses have been a method of killing for thousands of years. We have the Salem Witch Trials, pirates, thieves and many others who have been killed in this manner. We hear "holocaust" we think of the Jews, we hear "lynch" and we're supposed to think of black slaves only? Unfortunately, torture is universal as well as methods to carry it out. Golf magazine should stick to writing about golf. Whoever decided that certain words "belong" to certain groups, certainly does seem to have a lot of power. This is a free country and we should feel free to speak freely. I applaud Tiger Woods for brushing off the remark - although whatshername ought to be counseled for even suggesting a violence in the name of a sport, no matter what method.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: THE PROPHET on 1/21/2008 8:50PM
"MOSES CAME DOWN TO EGYPT LAND LET MY PEOPLE GO"
PHAROH PLAYED BY GOVERMENT
MOSES PLAYED BY MARTIN LUTHER KING
WILDERNESS PEOPLE PLAYED BY BLACKAMERICA
THIS PLAY RATED LOSS
DR. KING STOOD FOR SO MUCH MORE THAN WHAT WE SEE IN AMERICA TO DAY. HE WAS THE PROPHET SENT BY GOD TO FREE PEOPLE ENSLAVED IN THERE MIND. WHITE AMERICA AND BLACK AMERICA WERE ENGAGE IN A SLAVERY THAT WAS MORE PYCHOLOGICAL THAN PHSYICAL.
DR.MARTIN LUTHER KING WAS NOT THERE WHEN THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATON WAS SIGN,HE HAD TO READ
ABOUT OLD ABE.
GOD MADE CHOICE TO SEND THE SPIRIT OF MOSES BECAUSE HE NEW WE FACED A DIFFERENT KIND OF SLAVERY AND IT WAS EMBEDDED IN OUR MIND.YES AMERICA FREE YOUR MIND AND THE REST WILL FOLLOW, OR TO THE MORE SPIRITUAL BE YE TRANSFORM BY THE RENEWING OF YOU MIND.
THE PHYSICAL WILL ALLWAYS BE ENSLAVED IF THE MIND IS NOT FREE.
READ THE WORD SLAVERY HAS BEEN WITH US THROUGH OUT HISTORY AND IT WAS A SPIRIT THAT WAS PERPETUATED BY A THOUGH THAT OPERATED IN THE FLESH.
DR. KING KNEW WHAT THE TRUTH WAS TO DESTROY THE SPIRIT OF RACISM AND ESTABLISH THE SPIRIT OF GODS LOVE.
1.LOVE THE LORD THY GOD
2.LOVE YE ONE ANOTHER AS YE LOVE YOUSELF
DR. KING I WOULD LIKE TO CELEBRATE YOUR SPIRIT FOR GOD HAS TRULY FORTFIED IT WITH THE POWER IF THE HOLY GHOST.
WHAT PART WILL YOU PLAY IN THIS GOVERMENT WILL YOU LET THE PEOPLE GO OR WILL YOU CONTINUE TO DENY GOD WILL.
WHITE AMERICA WILL YOU CONTINUE TO STRIVE FOR A RASCIST AND SEPERATE AMERICA.
BLACK AMERICA WE HAVE BECOME OUR OWN WORST ENEMY DENIED THE POWER OF THE GOD WHO BROUGHT OUT ,AND HAVE BECOME COMFORTABLE WITH THE WILDERNESS MENTALLY.
THE LOVE YOU SEEK THAT DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING TALKS
ABOUT CAN ONLY COM FROM JESUS WHO GAVE HIS LIFE THAT WE SHALL ALL BE FREE. I WANT TO MEET DR. KING ON THE MONTAIN WILL YOU BE THERE.
THE PROPHET
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: angela on 1/21/2008 6:46PM
Before everything became politically correct, a noose or the KKK on the cover of a mag was the reason to get people to read the article and to see what was going on, now we allow the media to be the first to tell us (black or white) what offends or does not offend us. As people we must decide what as an individual deems wrong not what the media continually blasts in our face and then tell us its wrong.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Harry Asmen on 1/21/2008 8:20PM
ITS JUST A ROPE !
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: WALKER on 1/22/2008 1:48AM
I look at this as joke notthing ever going to chance in this country. These kinds things will cont. to happend and there notthing anyone can do about it! we will talk about for while then it will die like every thing else. As people we came a long away now it seem we head backward and not forward we was number 2 in this counrty now number 3 with the death young black man at it highest ever, jail full black men. Baby have baby...unempolyment high. CAN SOMEONE TELL ME HOW WE TO FIX THIS ! STOP POINT DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT PLEASE JUST TELL WHAT TO DO ?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: julian on 1/22/2008 2:46AM
I did not read the article but I did read the interview with the editor that got fired. The cover I believe was meant to wake people up get a dialog going about race relations in the golf world. It is not to sell magazines as my father is an avid reader of that publication and it is 95 percent subscription and is not on news stands. Do I think he could have done it another way, yes. But we as black people need to talk more about finding ways to combat racism through getting involved instead of crying foul every five minutes. You want to change things write a check to the golf school for young blacks down in Atlanta. And who created that school? A white guy, now ain't that a bitch. On the holiday of the great Dr. Martin Luther King we now more than ever need to live in his legacy and get out there and make a difference. If your not part of the solution your part of the problem.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Harry on 1/22/2008 9:19AM
In a way this "noose" phenomenon is a Godsend. Now it is out in the open open; so verile Black disdain from Blacks to Whites from low places to high places in all walks of life. America now we must talk. MLK happened for a reason besides. I do believe this hatred is seething/festering/smoldering. If not tended to now someday soon their could be a race war; predicted so many times for so many decades. Wow, it is mind blowing what we are facing. Editors, excutives,jurists scholars caught in this circus of the macabre. Finally, it is never a joke to glorify the hanging noose. The history books say it has been less than 60 years since lynching/hanging of Black folks in America was the order of the day. Finally, let's stop the madness. The healing becomes everyone's responsibility. I don't feel doomed and I do not want to see blood raining bucketsful from the skies. God help us all. Thanks for listiening, signed a proud Black American named Harry.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Shani on 1/28/2008 12:58AM
This is ridiculous and the author of this article should learn when to wage a war.
Golfweek's article was about the lynching comment made by the Golf Channel. The graphic image was relevant to the article, and I don't think they picked the noose to stir up controversy saying it was "right" but to show that even prejudice exists in the world of Golf and the readers of Golfweek have to face that.
It is a sad day when Black people (and yes, I am one) are so sensitive to an image that was made to make people think, that they call for the head of someone who was technically on "our" side.
The noose wasn't used to SELL magazines. It was used to shock the readers of Golfweek, who I can guarantee are mostly white, into some type of action or uneasiness. Seeing a noose doesn't make a white person want to buy a magazine, but knowing that the noose was talked about in reference to their favorite golfer may make them want to call for the real person, the Golf Channel commentator, to get fired.
Words are loaded weapons, and you are aiming at the wrong target.
Reply to this Comment | Report This