That translates to a decrease from about 14 percent to around 1 percent of farms in America. And no one can blame incompetence or disinterest as the primary reasons for disappearing black-owned farms. Instead, discrimination by the United States Government is at least a large part of the reason many of these farms failed.Even a jury said so by ruling against the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and for black farmers who filed a groundbreaking class-action lawsuit against the government in 1999. The result of the Pigford lawsuit established that the USDA practiced racial discrimination by denying loans to black farmers who in turn were forced into foreclosure. The USDA was far more liberal in granting loans to white farmers. ...
And the remedy seemed like a good one.
Black farmers who demonstrated even minimal evidence of discriminatory treatment at the hands of the USDA between 1981 and 1996 would be entitled to a cash payment of $50,000, debt forgiveness (and potentially more money in specific instances), and preferential treatment on future loans.
Unfortunately, problems distributing the money cropped up right away. And critics say that the settlement has not helped many of the black farmers who brought the suit. The Daily Yonder lays it out this way:
"At that point, the successful class action suit began to frazzle. The Department was hardly aggressive in processing discrimination claims. After extensions of deadlines due to insufficient notice to black farmers, the end results were still shocking: 81,000 out of 94,000 black farmers filing for restitution were rejected. Under a court-ordered extension of the time limits for eligibility, nearly 66,000 farmers were reviewed, but only 2,131 assisted. Not only have black farmers received little of the estimated $3 to 4 billion value of the settlement, but patterns of insufficient support to minority farmers appear to continue. Statistics show that the subsidy gap between black farmers and white farmers is widening post-Pigford."
But help may be on the way. Barack Obama has been a steadfast supporter of black farmers and thanks to the farm bill passed in May, more than 70,000 potential claimants could receive as much as $3 billion. That's much more than what was allotted in the original agreement in 1999.
Black farmers who demonstrated even minimal evidence of discriminatory treatment at the hands of the USDA between 1981 and 1996 would be entitled to a cash payment of $50,000, debt forgiveness (and potentially more money in specific instances), and preferential treatment on future loans.
Comments: (7)
Add a comment
By: Villager on 7/03/2008 1:25PM
Thank you very much for bringing us to date on this issue. We forget about the Black farmers here in America as we focus on issues in Haiti, Darfur or Tibet...
peace, Villager
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Eddie Griffin on 7/03/2008 7:13PM
Fascinating struggle. Obama is right in the thick of the fight.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Fendy A. on 7/04/2008 10:20AM
Great topic, I was happy to stumble upon it online because I don’t have access to information like that living in MA. It is difficult to find relevant black news articles in Boston's mainstream newspapers. Readers, I encourage you to take the opportunity to teach others; if each one actually teaches one we'll help raise these farmers out of bankruptcy... maybe a few years from now we'll read of how well the black farmers are doing in America. We’ll look back saying, “ I was a part of that”. It gives me great hope knowing that Obama is involved and can bring forth change.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: msladydeborah on 7/05/2008 9:38AM
This is information that we need to be aware of because the black farmers have lost so much land since the original filing.
I would urge people to look into the history of this struggle between black farmers and the USDA. It certainly reveals how race plays into the events that occurred.
Great post!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Biggie on 7/22/2008 10:09PM
Margo McKay appointment to senior government positions was based on her political ties, which outweighed her job qualifications. Therefore, no improvements have been made to the Department of Agriculture Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights. Which held true when Vernon Parker held the position. It would be much better to return the position of Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights to the career civil service employees.
Clyde Thompson previous Associate Secretary for Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights is a known sexual harasser. Mr. Thompson has been transferred around USDA like the plague. For now he is assigned to Rural Development
Currently, Sherrie Hinton Henry is the Associate Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights. Ms Hinton-Henry was on leave and upon her return home discovered a FEDEX package on her doorstep. She told all of her smoking, and drinking buddies she used profanity towards Thomas C. Dorr, Under Secretary for Rural Development and he transferred her to Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights. It’s rumored she is being investigated for falsifying documents on her brother’s death and collected money from the military.
Clyde Thompson referred Michael Watts previous Director of Civil Rights for Food and Nutrition Service to Margo McKay to fill the Deputy Director for Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights positions. Nancy Montanez Johner, Under Secretary for Food, Nutrition and Consumer Services wanted to get rid of Mr. Watts for not doing or knowing his job.
The Assistant Secretary for Civil is nothing but a drop off for undesirables. Forest Service didn’t want Clyde Thompson, Rural Development didn’t want Sherie Hinton-Henry, and Food, Nutrition and Consumer Services definitely didn’t want Michael Watts.
Margo McKay and her management staff have been ineffective. Margo McKay as political appointees, and her career managers have not created a good working relationship between the federal employees.
The majority of the managers under Margo McKay supervision are not qualified for their position.
Margo McKay legacy will be lies, corruption and scandals. She will be known for establishing a close relationship with Department Administration Human Capital and through that relationship she has destroyed more families than any other political or career SES without cause. Margo McKay and her management staff are home grown terrorist.
Margo McKay came on board the agency and attempted to give the agency more of an Asian theme. As African Americans we never want to just be African Americans. Any ethnicity other than African Americans we claim.
In less than six months the Department of Agriculture Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights will have a new face. Perhaps a short-lived career management changes for the entire McKay entourage.
The only way the agency can get off the ground is to place the agency into receivership.
Thanks to Vernon Parker, and especially you Margo McKay for your misguided leadership.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Deborah Hinton-Jackson on 7/30/2008 8:37AM
I think this is great, farmers like my husband have struggled to maintain their property and faced many
moments of discouragement as they watch their counterpart (white farm friend prosper).
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: mary thompson on 8/04/2008 9:09PM
I had my name in the pot for the sue years ago. But I never heard anything
Reply to this Comment | Report This