When Black Voices first asked me to consider writing a Katrina piece anchored to the third anniversary of the catastrophe, I initially said, "no." I said "no" because I've been talking with some Houston natives recently and listened to their complaints about how they felt crime had spiked, that it was connected to some of the Katrina victims, and had impacted their neighborhoods. Oh I know it's the few that ruin it for everyone, but still I just wasn't feeling the urgent sense of compassion and empathy I once felt for those caught in the storm.
Leave it to cinema to transport me out of my misplaced nonchalance. "Trouble the Water," which won the Grand Jury Prize at Sundance, is a soul tugging excursion into what it's like to be submerged in water, in grief, in sadness and to emerge if not triumphant, then whole. Mostly.
From Indiewire.com:
In the film, the filmmakers (who worked with Michael Moore on "Bowling for Columbine" and "Fahrenheit 9/11") team up with native New Orleans filmmaker and musician Kimberly Rivers and her husband to create an account of the effects of Katrina has had on the city's population. "'Trouble the Water' makes unapologetically clear that Hurricane Katrina rages on as an unnatural disaster of governmental and journalistic failure," writes Sundance's Shari Frilot of the film in the '08 Sundance catalog. "What is also truly amazing is that the levee protecting Kimberly's humanity against this devastating storm remains firmly grounded in her deep-rooted love for New Orleans, her family, and her art, and her enduring faith in her fellow human beings."I thought I knew everything about Katrina, but with every chronicle, with every expose, I learn about how city, state and Federal government failed to protect the people who had the least means and defense against an unprecedented natural disaster.

More Katrina Coverage
+ Katrina Aftermath, Three Years Later
+ Interview: Mayor Nagin Calls New Orleans "Tale of Two Cities"
+ Nervous New Orleans Eyes Killer Storm
+ Katrina Memorial Taking Shape


Comments: (7)
Add a comment
By: Steve on 8/29/2008 8:23AM
What language are those people speaking? Of course when you move 1,000 of unemployeed people, probably most don't want to work, into another city, it will be ripe picking for them!
The federal government should not rebuild in areas that are below sea level. This event was natures way of wiping the slate clean, now man can start over and do it right.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: tonya on 8/30/2008 5:27AM
Wether the city of New Orleans was built correctly or not, this is home. Obviously Steve has no roots(I am 4th generation)in what will always be "home" for me. Steve, you should not comment on a place that is presently back 60% in capacity,that you obviously have no personal knowledge of, and to say the hurricane got rid of all the bad people is idiotic. In other words Steve, shut up.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: mzztlove on 8/30/2008 5:25AM
WHO WOULD OF THOUGHT THAT 3YRS AFTER KATRINA I WOULD BE SITTING HERE IN THE POTENTIAL PATH OF HURRICANE GUSTAVO .. A 1000 + MILES AWAY FROM A PLACE I ONCED CALLED HOME A MOVE THAT TOOK ME FROM WATCHING TO NOW WAITING.. YET HISTORY BEARS NO REPEATING.. NOTHING IS IMPOSSIBLE BUT ALL THINGS POSSIBLE GOD IS STILL IN CONTROL.. SO PRAY FOR ALL NOT JUST A FEW, AND KNOW THAT WHATEVER WAY THE WINDS OF TIME BLOW.. THE CHANGE IS ON THE HORIZON.. FROM THE SUNSHINE STATE OF FLORIDA IN THE PANHANDLE.. WE REACH ACROSS AMERICA NOT THE DAY OF OR THE DAY AFTER.. WE ASK FOR CONTINUED PRAYER OF AMERICA BECAUSE IT MAY NOT BE A HURRICANE THAT CAUSES YOU TO PRAY.. THE WORLD IS NOT SAFE THE PEOPLE WE NEED TODAY ARE SOME OF THE SAME PEOPLE WE MAY NEED TO FEAR TOMORROW..
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: brendaRogers on 8/31/2008 8:27PM
Please everyone leave! Please everyone be safe! I also beleive The federal government should not rebuild in areas that are below sea level. Its sad but true. God bless all in the path !
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Yolanda on 9/02/2008 11:33PM
So if they don't rebuild there they should not rebuild the wealthy neighborhoods (CA) that suffer from mud slides and forrest fires. Those American citizens should know they live in a dangerous area also correct?!!! This is America and everyone deserves the same respect, rights and freedoms regardless of how much money they have, what words they use when they speak and how they look.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: new orleanian on 9/03/2008 1:02AM
To the author of this article,of course they would say
crime spiked,but as a responsible writer you should
found sources with creditials before you made judgement.Look it up crime was bad in Houston before
Katrina and it will remain high until they truly find the source and stop blaming New Orleanians.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: new orleanian on 9/03/2008 1:20AM
To the author of this article,i'm glad you did a lil research and not take it for granted that New Orleanians is the reason crime spiked in Houston...smh@that...come on before Katrina do you really think Houston of all places was crime free????
Reply to this Comment | Report This