Please let us move on and never speak again of this absurd lawsuit dismissed by the Supreme Court Monday questioning Barack Obama's citizenship.In case you haven't been paying attention to news of the mortgage crisis, the Wall Street meltdown, the collapse of the U.S. auto industry, skyrocketing unemployment, foreign war, global terrorism concerns, we have more serious concerns. ...
The suit, filed by New Jersey gadfly Leo Donofrio, "reasoned" that since Obama had dual nationality at birth - his mother was American and his Kenyan father at the time was a British subject - he cannot possibly be a "natural born citizen," one of the requirements the Constitution lists for eligibility to be president.
To be fair, Donofrio made the same argument against GOP presidential nominee John McCain. But the larger question is why do we need to spend one second of attention on such a spurious argument when our country is facing such peril.
Desperate is the best way to characterize the reasoning behind the lawsuit which somehow managed to get all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court before being tossed in the garbage.
Shouldn't a lower court have done the same thing a long time ago?
The bottom line is that the suit attempted to do what neither Team Clinton could do during the Democratic primaries and what John McCain and the GOP could do during the general election – derail Obama's destiny to lead this country out of its current pathetic state.
Only time will tell whether he is ultimately successful. But it is certain he will get his chance.
The conservative crazies behind this line of argument are trying to use the courts to subvert the people's will expressed at the ballot box on Election Day.
Unfortunately we will all have to deal with this one more time. A Pennsylvania man is pursuing a court challenge to Obama's presidency claiming the president-elect was born in Kenya and not Hawaii as both he and Hawaii officials confirmed.
Hopefully, that will be the last silly challenge we have to stand. So let the stupid tricks end and let Obama have his chance to govern.
If you don't like Obama, that's fine.
Attack his agenda, attack his appointments, attack his ideas.
That's all a fair part of the political game. But attacking his parentage is out of bounds. Remember, few things in life will earn you bruised feelings and perhaps a bruised nose faster than attacking the ancestry of a black man.
+ The Shallow Obama Birth Certificate Challenge
_________________
Paul Shepard blogs the Democrat side of politics for BlackVoices. He has been a journalist for 16 years; on the national urban/minority affairs beat for The Cleveland Plain Dealer and for The AP in Washington, D.C.

Comments: (94)
Add a comment
By: Ted on 12/09/2008 7:08PM
from itooktheredpill.wordpress.com:
The truth is that the Supreme Court did NOT “deny cert” to Leo Donofrio yesterday. The truth is the Supreme Court did NOT “turn down” Donofrio’s case yesterday. The truth is that Leo Donofrio’s case is still “PENDING” at the Supreme Court, and the court only denied the application to stay an election.
...the election that Donofrio had been trying to stay was the November 4th election (he hurriedly filed his case on November 3rd to do so).
So, it is logical that the court would, on December 8th, deny an application to stay an election that already happened on November 4th.
Donofrio’s case is still PENDING.
MONDAY, DECEMBER 8, 2008
ORDERS IN PENDING CASES
08A407 DONOFRIO, LEO C. V. WELLS, NJ SEC. OF STATE
The application for stay addressed to Justice Thomas and referred to the Court is denied.
…
CERTIORARI DENIED
[Note the ABSENCE of Donofrio's case here]
Donofrio’s case is NOT listed under CERTIORARI DENIED.
Everyone should take another look at the order list from the SCOTUS yesterday.
Not only was Donofrio’s case NOT denied certiorari, but a third case (Cort Wrotnowski vs. Susan Bysiewicz, Connecticut Secretary of State) was referred to the Court by Justice Scalia - distributed for conference this coming Friday:
Dec 8 2008 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of December 12, 2008.
Dec 8 2008 Application (08A469) referred to the Court by Justice Scalia.
It sounds like Donofrio may have called this correctly earlier today:
On the chance that SCOTUS was looking at both my case and Cort’s case, I must stress that Cort’s case does not have the same procedural hang up that mine does. It may be that without a decision on the Judicial misconduct allegation correcting the NJ Appellate Division case file, SCOTUS might have been in the position of not being able to hear my case as it would appear that my case was not before them on the proper procedural grounds.
I did file a direct appeal under the proper NJ Court rules, but the lower Court judge refused to acknowledge that and if his fraudulent docketing was used by SCOTUS they would have a solid procedural basis to throw mine out.
Friday could turn out to be a very, very big news day.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Eagle1 on 12/09/2008 8:15PM
December 7, 2008 at 00:06:48 Permalink
To President-elect Barack Obama - From Citizen Berryhill
Diary Entry by Vivian Berryhill
Excerpt:
Dear Mr. President-elect Obama,
With out a doubt, your history making ascension to the highest office in the land has brought, and continues to bring, unexplainable pride to millions of people of color, not just in America... but around the globe. People are rooting for you, as they want you to be a good President.
But on the other hand... there are also millions of others who do not like you, respect you, or want to see you confirmed as the 44th President of these United States. Please understand that for some in that category, it's personal. But there are many, who have not accepted your position, operating out of fear because there remain 'questions' about your life that have not been thoroughly answered.
I am writing this open letter to you today on behalf of both sides. Mr. President-elect, surely you know that there is a 'tempest in the teapot' brewing regarding the vault version of your birth certificate. And, only you, Sir, can bring closure to this issue...
...Mr. President-elect, surely you know that there is a 'tempest in the teapot' brewing regarding the vault version of your birth certificate. And, only you, Sir, can bring closure to this issue. Mr. Obama, show your birth certificate for the sake of all the people who supported and voted for you... and, also to quiet (once, and for all) the skeptics, naysayers, and people who deem your Presidency 'illegitmate'
READ ENTIRE ARTICLE LINK: http://www.opednews.com/maxwrite/diarypage.php?did=11061
Vivian Berryhill, founder of a national service organization, is a renown speaker and travels extensively throughout the United States and abroad. She has addressed audiences in Thailand, Nigeria, Honduras, Peru, Chile, and has traveled to Kenya, Uganda, Camaroon, Zambia, Rawanda, France and the U.K.
She was selected as one of the premier partners for Walden Media's internationally acclaimed movie: Amazing Grace, http://amazinggracemovie.com/_pdf/ag_faithguide_uk.pdf and the worldwide movement Amazing Change, www.theamazingchange.com/music2.html, lending her voice and talent, along with Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Right Reverend Patrick O'Donoghue, and other notable world leaders, to end modern day slavery.
Mrs. Berryhill, a 2007 Jefferson Public Service Award winner, also received the prestigious Presidential Service Award in 2006. She is married to Rev. C.L. Berryhill, Jr.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Tyrone on 12/09/2008 8:51PM
Brother Shepard,
DIRECT AND TO THE POINT.
THANK YOU
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Greg Jones on 12/09/2008 10:08PM
OBAMA TALK RADIO....Hi Warriors. When you get a chance please listen to this week's edition of 'Nothing But The Truth with Greg Jones'. Topics: Obama's Weekly Address...Michael Moore speaks out re: auto bailout...a look back at the Bush Regime...Michelle's Family: from Slavery to the White House...and much more Obama Talk. NBTT airs LIVE ! every Sunday night 8pm (est) Join Us ! Listen/Call-In LIVE ! To listen to this week's show just click below:
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/stations/HeadingLeft/The-Greg-Jones-Show/2008/12/08/Nothing-But-The-Truth-with-Greg-Jones
or visit:
http://www.Blacks4Barack.org
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Jessie on 12/09/2008 10:39PM
"In case you haven't been paying attention to news of the mortgage crisis, the Wall Street meltdown, the collapse of the U.S. auto industry, skyrocketing unemployment, foreign war, global terrorism concerns, we have more serious concerns. ..."
"But the larger question is why do we need to spend one second of attention on such a spurious argument when our country is facing such peril" Yet it's quite alright to spend time on Obama's dog selection and what Michelle will wear and Obama's mother in law in the whitehouse. Oh puhleeze! Would'nt it be a quite simple thing for Obama to clear up as he should have when it first became an issue.
"The conservative crazies behind this line of argument are trying to use the courts to subvert the people's will expressed at the ballot box on Election Day."
Seems some of the suits have been filed by DEMOCRATS.
Ugh what spin......
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Curt on 12/09/2008 11:24PM
In regards to this issue, I've read the legal brief submitted to the Philly courts, challenging the citzenship of Mr. Obama. Incedentally, the attorney who is challenging his citezenship is a life-long and active member of the Democrat Party. But regardless of whether or not this challenge is racially motivated or not is immaterial. What is important is having a President which does meet the requirements specified under the constitution, where there is no shadow of doubt concerning divided loyalties to any government or nation outside of our own. Having said that, the soultion is simple... supply the evidence of proof so we can all get down to the buiseness of meeting the serious challenges facing our nation.
On the other hand, if it can be proved that Mr. Obama was not actually eligible to run for and hold the office of the President, then what??!! Good Lord what a mess that would be! I don't even know what would happen then.
I could say more, but I won't. The end.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: talo on 12/10/2008 12:30AM
idiots. idiots!!!!!!!!!!! people are homeless, loosing their jobs and security.The nation is in crisis and all you people still think about is what his personal life. Theres a reason why its his personal life dummies. what he chooses to do with his life is his life.The man is allowed his private space.I voted for him.He's smart and would turn the country around. Lets support him and stop this pety stuff geee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: lakesha on 12/10/2008 7:16AM
Are you people serious about challenging Obama's birthplace. Give me a freaking break! People that have never been homeless before or homeless with their families. Crime rate and unemployment is higher than it has ever been. Can we please worry about fixing the real issue's in america. Please!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: flowerchild629 on 12/10/2008 7:44AM
you people are stupid..who cares what his citizenship is... you people are trying to do everything to get this man out of office...its such a shame the only reason you want him out is because he is black....everyone knows whites have a problem with following the orders of a black person... your have problems...i am sure it came from your parents which they have/had problem too... pure hatred
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: MITA on 12/10/2008 7:49AM
OBAMA IS THE PRESIDENT ELECT...YOU STUPID, JEALOUS, ENVIOUS, RETARDS....GIVE IT A BREAK...ARE YOU PEOPLE THAT DUMB...TO ACTUALLY THINK THAT SOMEONE RUNNING FOR PRESIDENT IS NOT GOING TO GO THROUGH A BACK GROUND CHECK....AND ESPECIALLY BEING A BLACK MAN?...YOU PEOPLE ARE A BUNCH OF ENVIOUS RETARDS TO KEEP BRINGING THIS UP....AND THE REASON THE WHOLE WORLD KNOWS THAT THIS IS A BUNCH OF BULLSH-T....WHY DIDN'T MCCAIN AND PALIN TALK ABOUT THIS DURING THEIR CAMPAIGN?...THEY SPENT....COUNTLESS HOURS TALKING ABOUT SOCIALISM.....BILL AYERS....REV. WRIGHT AND OF COURSE JOE THE PLUMBER...
IF THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE THING WAS AN ACTUAL ISSUE....O'REILLY AND THAT OTHER FOOL....HANITY....ON FOX WOULD HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT IT DAYS INTO THE ELECTION BUT GUESS WHAT THEY DIDN'T TALK ABOUT IT....BECAUSE IT WAS THEN AS IT IS NOW....A MADE UP ISSUE. THE REPUBLICANS WERE DESPERATE TO WIN THIS ELECTION AND WOULD HAVE DONE EVERYTHING IN THEIR POWER TO DO SO....IF THIS WAS A REAL ISSUE...THEY WOULD HAVE USED IT TO WIN THE ELECTION....THERE ARE A BUNCH OF JEALOUS RETARDS WHO ARE UPSET THAT OBAMA WILL BE THE NEXT PRESIDENT...SO THEY MAKE UP THIS STUPID LIE....NONE OF THE MAJOR NEWS SHOWS ARE EVEN TALKING ABOUT THIS...BECAUSE THIS IS MADE UP BULL CRAP....AND AOL..SHOULD STOP REPORTING THIS...BECAUSE IT'S BULL CRAP AT IT'S BEST!!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This