Some call it "bullying," but I call it emotional and physical torture. And it was school centered, emotional torture that claimed the life of 11-year-old Carl Joseph Walker Hoover last Monday. This young boy, who played football, basketball and was a Boy Scout, hanged himself when anti-gay bullying and constant harassment became too much for him to bear.
Carl Joseph Walker Hoover was so overwhelmed by bullying that he committed suicide by hanging himself with an extension cord.Source Advocate.com via nowpublic.com
His mother found his broken little body, living every parent's worst nightmare. [Carl's mother] Sirdeaner Walker, who was active at Carl Joseph's school as a member of the parent teacher organization, was aware that her son was being bullied and experienced repeated frustration at getting the administration to do anything effective about it.
Carl played football, basketball, and was a boy scout -- but that didn't stop other kids from picking on him, his mom said. Students called him gay and made fun of him for the way he dressed.
Sirdeaner Walker said she began phoning his school repeatedly when Carl first told her about the bullying last September, but she says the school was unresponsive.
Carl Joseph Walker Hoover should have been with us this Easter.
Sirdeaner Walker: It was just unbelievable to me. I thought I was in a dream. I thought I was in a nightmare. I couldn't lift him - so all I could do was scream.Source NECN.com
In the days since, Sirdeaner and her close family - have been asking the question why? They say Carl was a great kid who loved sports and was involved in many community organizations and attended church every Sunday. The answer, they believe, can be traced to the cruelty of some of his classmates at the New Leadership charter school in Springfield. Sirdeander Walker: He was being teased at the school - he was being made fun of - he was being bullied. A lot of it surrounded by "you act gay," "are you gay?"
This story hits close to home for me. So far this year, four children have killed themselves to escape bullying - but it is not a new problem.
In grade school, I was emotionally tortured so relentlessly that for two years I could not go out for recess - at all. I was accused by the neighborhood kids of "talking white" and "dressing funny". I had my right cornea split by a boy who punched me, in class, while I was seated doing class work. At eight years old, the constant assaults left me severely depressed and suicidal.
I am thankful I made it through, and that my mother and grandmother scraped together the means to move to a different neighborhood where my life got better. But moving should not have to be the only solution for kids under assault. We adults must teach our children a deeper compassion and if they can't abide by basic rules of human civility then there must be harsh and swift consequences for abusive behavior. Period.


Comments: (335)
Add a comment
By: Rhonda on 5/13/2009 12:31PM
I think that the person who wrote about this young boy being a punk is just trying to get a rise out of everyone. We are just feeding this idiot by responding to it. I am a teacher in a very diverse school and what we need to put our energy into is holding the bullies accountable. We need to have ZERO tolerance for bullying at our school. My job as a teacher and an adult is to challenge any student that makes comments that are considered to be harassment. Too many times, teachers are afraid to stand up to the bullies. Schools have to feel like a safe environment for ALL students.
Ignore the idiot and the idiot's comments.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: autirose on 5/16/2009 4:19PM
I recall George, a male playmate, whatever we did he did. George was the youngest of three siblings, having two beautiful, ultra feminine sisters. No one ever picked on him and I am sure if they had his friends would have "beat them up". He grew into a feminine, "gay" male. I recall his beautiful, flawless skin tone and petite body. My childhood has resulted in my affinity toward our Black Gay Guys. Another, adult, friend had a flamingingly strong gay personality. I recall his goldish hair and red skin tone. I really liked him, he was fun and the oldest brother of my first boyfriend. Their family was very close to ours. Our community was not judgemental. We understood and accepted others: drunks, gays, obese, poor, races, whatever and were taught respect and tolerance. I My Grandmother's sagecious wisdom taught me humbleness, not to be "stuck up". She'd say remember, "You can learn from a wineo on the streets." I learned never to think I knew it all. Judgements can be detrimental and as wise guidance always warns. Judge not. As you judge you shall be judged. The one without sin cast the first stone. No man is perfect, on not one. I love "Noah's Ark". Article states he wasn't gay, but was bullied/judged harshly by schoolmates. I recalled my exposure to gay characters in my childhood.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: me on 5/21/2009 3:29AM
I was teased relentlessly in middle school. Constantly and teachers weren't truly aware of it. The culture is homophobic in general and acutely so in the black community. I believe that hatred shown towards homosexuals is just a tributary of the great river of hatred that drowns the (black) community in general. Black male on black male crime, domestic abuse of women, a sociopath misogynistic hip hop culture. So though I was hated almost to suicide, that negative self-loathing and self-infliction is just one instance in the overall self-destructive bankrupt culture of black America. I would like to sugar-coat it but I can't. And Jesus won't help us, because the church and Media Goes to Jail- big mamma -chittlin circuit morality - COGIC morality is not compassionate nor Progressive.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Elizabeth on 6/11/2009 2:41AM
This is just another case for all those people who don't give a damn. The school might have thought that it would pass but did they not notice how it kept progressing? I don't get how people, especially those who are there to enforce some rules act like they don't see anything. It pisses me off how they turn a blind eye at things, especially relating to these kinds of things. Are they afraid to get involved? Are they afraid of the parents? Are they afraid what others might say for standing up for what is right? Bullshit.
I think that they should of acted the moment it became a constant problem. They're there to help kids through education, but this seemed highly unlikely. I was bullied constantly in middle school too. I dressed like a guy sometimes, but it made me feel comfortable. I hated wearing girl clothes cause it restricted your movements. I was called gay, and many didn't even care. The school didn't do anything about it so i just dealed with it since no one was gonna help me. But to go as far as to get into someone's head, to make them doubt themselves and make them feel like they're doing something wrong. To drive them to the point of killing themselves. The kids and their parents are held responsible. The faculty is held responsible for not hauling ass.
Pisses me off. One more young death that wasn't supposed to happen, happened. I honestly think people these days not give a .... anymore.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Franklin on 12/15/2009 9:57PM
when was the last time anyone anywhere was actually expelled from elementry school or high school for doing anything at all?
Why is it that everyone has a right to graduate with a high school diploma? Why do we end up reading so many stories of kids who felt compelled to take all these different martial arts classes just so he/she could attend school without trembling from fear during algebra class?
Just passing on people to the next level who haven't earned the next level produces this kind of shit; and, worse of all, it completely devalues the worth of a high school diploma. Wanna find out how valuable a high school diploma is? Remember trying to get a job with one, and how difficult that was?
School systems need to go back to their roots. START EXPELLING PEOPLE.
Here's how you deal with these evil malevolent children: Expell them. Stop trying to "feel the bully's pain" and start trying to feel the victim's pain.
Expulsion shouldn't be reserved for the absolute worst children. It should be a common occurence, a penalty applied to children who bully/torture/disrupt other children as they try to learn. Yes, it's a harsh penalty. But it's an earned penalty.
Think about this child who probably had so much to offer the world. Now think about those worthless cowards who hurt this kid for fun whenever they could. Who is more worthy of their high school diploma? Who was the better student? Who had more character?
Yes, I understand about the social pecking order, and I also understand that human beings are naturally cruel and try to wein people out of the social pecking order to further their own causes: access to the alpha group. We all do it. Some more than others, but we are all guilty of a kind of bullying--here and there, in bars, clubs, social gatherings, etc.. It's just a part of the human condition. But this cruel reality shouldn't be a part of an academic learning environment.
Do yourself a favor: wipe your ass with your high school diploma. It's a worthless document that means absolutely nothing, except that you either bullied someone for 4 yrs, took it for 4 yrs, or couldn't take it anymore, like this poor kid.
Reply to this Comment | Report This