
My best friend Greg was shot in the head in 1996, nearly the same time the rapper Tupac Shakur was murdered. Greg was a good man and a good father but he was also a black man, which made his murder seem typical. The media didn't find much interest in my friend's death. His story was covered in the back of the newspaper, in print small enough to be a low-budget classified ad.
The same week, a white mother of three in the same city (Louisville) was murdered on her way to a bank in the suburbs. Her murder was, for several days, the lead story on every TV channel, radio station and newspaper. There was a $25,000 reward issued for information leading to a break in the case. The police held regular press conferences announcing that they wouldn't sleep until the killer was found.
The good people of Kentucky were going to protect their damsel in distress at all cost. The entire city had become a group of Nancy Grace clones, obsessing over every nook and cranny of the case, crying for the woman's orphaned children and holding candlelight vigils. None of this was done for my best friend's daughter, since her daddy's death was just not all that intriguing.
My friend Greg was "only" another dead black man. His daughter, Jasmine, was just another fatherless black girl. In the eyes of the media, her suffering was not as important as that of the little angels from the suburbs who'd tragically lost their mother.
I thought about Greg when reading about the case of Bonnie Sweeten, the Philadelphia woman who claimed she and her daughter were abducted by two black men. Turns out that she wasn't abducted at all: she'd taken a trip to Disney World.
The Bonnie Sweeten debacle reminds us of the case of Charles Stuart in 1990. Stuart, a Boston resident, murdered his pregnant wife and said that a black man was the perpetrator. For weeks, black men were victims of tremendous persecution on the part of local police They were strip searched, taken into custody and humiliated in front of their families. That story was also fabricated.

Photo: AP
Sweeten's sweet little lie makes us ask the following questions:
1) Why is the public so quick to believe it when black men are blamed for violent crimes? Black males are six times more likely to be incarcerated when arrested, even when they commit the same crimes as whites. In the cases of those men who are innocent, one only wonders if the justice system is also swayed by the very same stereotypes that made the public believe that two black men kidnapped Sweeten and her daughter.
"Ever since Susan Smith, it has been fashionable for white women accused of crimes to blame it on black men," says Dr. Christopher Metzler, author of 'The Construction and Re-articulation of Race'. "We hardly live in a post-racial society."
2) Why does the media zoom in on such cases more frequently than when black families are victimized? There are a shocking number of child murders taking place in Chicago right now, but the murders are receiving very little national media attention. If these children were not black, chances are that the media would be all over this epidemic. Does the blonde damsel in distress always get more attention than she deserves?
"Despite her mental illness, Sweeten had a clear understanding of two key components to a national tragedy: distressed white woman and violent black assailants," says Dr. Marc Lamont Hill, a Columbia University professor. "The public's deep interest in rescuing white women in distress stands in sharp contrast to the black women, like Latoya Figueroa from Philadelphia, whose abductions go unnoticed."
3) Perhaps we should not go overboard in our discussion of the racism inherent in this case? One must give law enforcement credit for doing a thorough enough investigation to determine that this woman was lying. Had this been another part of the country, say, the same location as the cases of Jamie and Gladys Scott, justice may not have been served. Although there is much work to do, not every police officer wants to incarcerate all black men.
The bottom line is this: It's clear that Sweeten needs psychiatric help. She is currently under investigation for allegedly stealing $300,000 from her former employer, and she hardly represents the typical white female. But we must become conscious of the fact that America overreacts when someone hurts a white woman and underreacts when the victim happens to be black. To think that this perceptive bias is not related to 400 years of racial conditioning would be silly. Nancy Grace and the rest of us must keep in mind that a black life is just as valuable as a white one, and perpetrators come in all ethnicities.
Michael Vick Update
A security guard wearing a shirt with the word "Support" and a photo of suspended NFL player Michael Vick moves traffic cones in front of Vick's home in Hampton, Va., Thursday, May 21, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and arrived home Thursday morning. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
A caravan of vehicles escorting the van carrying suspended NFL player Michael Vick arrives at his home in Hampton, Va., Thursday, May 21, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
A van carrying suspended NFL player Michael Vick arrives at his home in Hampton, Va., Thursday, May 21, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Neighbors linger in front of the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick in Hampton, Va., Thursday, May 21, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and is due back at his home in Virginia for home confinement. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Members of the media stand in front of the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick in Newport News, Va., Wednesday, May 20, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and is due back at his home in Virginia for home confinement. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Members of the media stand in front of the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick in Newport News, Va., Wednesday, May 20, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and is due back at his home in Virginia for home confinement. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
A private property sign is posted at the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick in Newport News, Va., Wednesday, May 20, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and is due back at his home in Virginia for home confinement. The suspended quarterback served 19 months in prison on the dogfighting conviction that capped one of the most astonishing falls in sports history, one that stole his wealth and popularity. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
The media is camped out at the entrance to the home of former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick in Newport News, Va., Wednesday, May 20, 2009. Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and is due back at his home in Virginia for home confinement. The suspended quarterback served 19 months in prison on dogfighting conviction. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Nineteen month old London Vick points to an unidentified man, right, as she arrives at the home of her father, former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick, in Newport News, Va., Wednesday, May 20, 2009. Michael Vick was released from prison early Wednesday and is due back at his home in Virginia for home confinement. The suspended quarterback served 19 months in prison on dogfighting conviction. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
AP
Former Indianapolis Colts coach Tony Dungy speaks at a workshop for ex-offenders seeking jobs, in Indianapolis on Wednesday, May 13, 2009. Dungy is busier than ever, even though he's no longer coaching the Colts. In the past few weeks, he has met with former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick at a federal penitentiary in Leavenworth, Kan., been involved with an education project in St. Louis and attended a Fellowship of Christian Athletes function for flood relief in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)
AP
Dr Boyce Watkins is a Distinguished Scholar Affiliate at The Barbara Jordan Institute for Policy Research at Texas Southern University. He is also the author of 'What if George Bush were a Black Man?' For more information, please visit www.BoyceWatkins.com. To get Dr. Boyce commentary delivered directly to your email, please click here.


Comments: (197)
Add a comment
By: BPhilly on 5/28/2009 11:17AM
It's ridiculous that it's 2009 and this lie still works. We live in Philly and knew this was a lie immediately. My husband and I gave eachother a knowing look when the "abduction" was announced. We explained this to our sons using Susan Smith, Charles Stuart, and Rosewood as examples before it was even publicized that this liar & thief was in Disney. Centuries of this crap, then they say "why are you so defensive?" Thank you Dr. Watkins on behalf or our race and especially our men.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: ljcave on 5/28/2009 7:28PM
The minute the "two black men in a cadillac" was mentioned on the news,we also knew this was another lie. I hope she is punished severely, but now the media should make an example of her racism. This needs to stay on the front pages for a long time!!
Report This
By: LINDA on 5/30/2009 3:16PM
BPPHILLY AFTER READING YOURE COMMENT YOU ARE SO RIGHT.THIS LADY IS JUST LIKE THE SUSAN SMITH STORY THE CRAZY WHITE BITCH.WHO LIED AND SAID A BLACK MAN KID NAPPED HER 2 SON'S.SHE WAS THE CRAZY WHITE BITCH WHO DROWED THEM IN THE LAKE.BY LOOKING HEM IN HER CAR AND PUSHING THE CAR IN THE LAKE.
Report This
By: Cheryl F. on 5/31/2009 7:28AM
I thank Dr. Watkins also for bringing this situation to light and not letting it get shoved under the rug. It is very impressive to me how two mentally ill women, not in their right minds as we would say, yet having the presence of mind to know how racist their own race was towards Blacks and having chosen to put the blame on Black men, to take suspicion completely off of self. Now you know, the roots of racism have to go mighty deep for the mentally ill to remember them.
Report This
By: sprofc on 6/01/2009 9:47AM
I also live in the Philly area and like you as soon as I heard the story I said BS (excuse the words...I'm still angry) what upset me was people in this area(and on my job) believed the story was true...either they are dumb or racist ...maybe both ? Channel 3,6,or 10 ten never questioned the story they just reported it as is.I'm upset Rick Williams,and the other minority reporters didn't have a special report/story regarding this subject matter !
Sorry to bother you,have a nice day.
Report This
By: John Daniels jr on 6/01/2009 11:59PM
thank you for your comment! the outcome of this will be interesting i'm sure, if this was a reverse role? we would be slammed!! and don't forget about the brother(policeman) that was killed point blank, what if it would of been a black cop that gunned down a white person??? wake up!!! black people!!!
Report This
By: Ms. Unique on 5/28/2009 11:51AM
HERE WE GO AGAIN! Why is it all the time when the majority of white people and other races act so innocent and are these so-called victims have to blame the BLACK MAN! That is RACIST! There is a long ass list of cases just like this. This makes me sick to my stomach! I live in Pittsburgh PA and this is not the first time something like this has happened before. We had that crazy ass girl that was part of the McCain Campaign that said some black man had carved a letter on her face and was LYING HER ASS off. That was like minutes away from where I live and I couldn't believe that? That particular incident, the cops could have been at a more serious crime than that FAKE CRIME she made up? I am just so sick of people just throwing the black man in the mix and making not just them but ALL BLACK PEOPLE look bad. This woman and people like her should be PUNISHED. She better watch. Just like the boy who called wolf, her ass could be in danger one day or her daughter God forbid, and no will be there to help them. These people are SICK!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Bonnie on 5/28/2009 12:26PM
Why???? Have you checked out the jails lately? It's the BLACKS that cause the most problems in society. Lets go back to the Rodney King trial....ok lets see....... some poor white man is driving along and a bunch of blacks pull him out of the car and beat the crap out of him...not to mention you don;t see white people LOOTING! Call it racist if you wnat I call it reality!
Report This
By: Bernice on 5/28/2009 12:30PM
Well stated, Dr. Watkins!!
God's blessings to you and yours!
Report This
By: Jblknyc on 5/30/2009 5:49AM
This reply is to Bonnie's comment (not Ms. Unique's comment). Bonnie, you sound like a dayum fool comparing this woman's made-up story to what happened to that "poor white man" during the L.A. riots. Are you saying it's OK that she lied about being abducted by black men because of what happened to that white guy during the L.A. riots? If you are, then, I guess it would be OK for me to lie about being abducted by white men because some white men dragged James Byrd to death (a black man) in Texas. What happened to that white dude in L.A. was sad but, it was real. IT REALLY HAPPENED! What this white chick said happened to her, NEVER HAPPENED! How dare you think that it's OK that she LIED because of something that REALLY happened to a white guy in L.A. You idiot.
Report This