I have 3 daughters who worship Chis Brown. No, seriously. If Chris Brown were to start a church, they would give all their money to the building fund and serve on every committee. They didn't stop loving Chris after he attacked his former girlfriend, Rihanna. In fact, they are probably happy that Rihanna's out of the way. They didn't stop loving him when he pleaded guilty to felony assault. For right or wrong, Chris Brown is their Barack Obama, and they are willing to endure the ups and downs of their imaginary relationships with him.
As a father, I really don't like it. But since when has a father been able to control the love preferences of his teenage daughters anyway? The more I fight it, the more attractive Chris becomes to them; so I just leave it alone and try to get them to think. Also, I've stated on CNN and elsewhere that I don't hate Chris Brown or necessarily think he's a monster (I honestly don't know him well enough to determine if his actions are indicative of a longer term pattern or not): he is a young man who may need to learn a few hard lessons. How fast he graduates from the "University of Life" is going to be up to him and his ego.
Given that Oprah Winfrey's best friend Gail was one of the first to publicly criticize Chris for his spat with Rihanna, it's ironic that Chris is going to use the Oprah Winfrey success model to get his career back on track. The Oprah Winfrey model is simple: you're going to have haters, but in the mind of the focused celebrity, your haters don't exist. You get up every day, do your job and keep it moving. Eventually, the controversy washes itself away. This model has worked for Oprah for several years, and it is going to work for Chris Brown too.
Then there is the R. Kelly rule: If R. Kelly's career can recover from his misdeeds, there is hope for anyone. I recall seeing Mr. Kelly on BET shortly after being accused of doing the unthinkable to an underage girl. During the interview, Kelly kept saying, "Just focus on my music." These words (which appeared to be coached by someone else) had meaning, because as revolting as R. Kelly's presence might be, he knew that his hypnotic voice would make the world forget about the fact that he had been accused of doing really nasty things with a teenager.
Chris Brown is no R. Kelly, but he will be able to use the R. Kelly rule to his advantage. Whether we are referring to athletes or entertainers, the reality is that "if you win, they forgive all sin." That means that another hit song makes the artist's transgressions blow away in the wind. Another Super Bowl or NBA title makes the world forget about your criminal record. People don't care what their favorite celebs do with their personal lives: they just want a great performance.
Finally, Chris can benefit from the Michael Vick rule: America will never forgive you for hurting a puppy, but it can overlook the fact that you beat the crap out of a black woman. I do not forgive Chris Brown for hitting Rihanna. He and other young men need to realize that there are few excuses for putting your hands on a woman, and if Chris had done this to one of my daughters, he'd be singing high notes for the rest of his life. But the point here is clear: Abuse and violence against black women is largely ignored by the rest of America. What is saddest is that even many black women don't consider it an issue when they judge Chris Brown. Regrettably enough, if the majority of all black women forgive Brown for his behavior, then this gives the rest of the world an excuse for forgiving him too.
I hope that the intoxication of fame and power don't preclude Chris from learning from this experience. Many black celebrities before Brown thought they were too powerful to go down, and found out the hard way that none of us is above the law or greater than our own mortality. Get counseling Chris, try to learn from it, and remember that your hands should only be clenched to hold a microphone, not to hit a woman. I hope our daughters understand that too.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Professor at Syracuse University and author of the forthcoming book, "Black American Money." For more information, please visit www.BoyceWatkins.com. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered directly to your email box, please click here.



Comments: (15)
Add a comment
By: Shania on 6/23/2009 3:52PM
I completely agree famous rich people can get away with anything if they know the formula to success and have the right mentality.All they have to do is keep giving their fans what they like and they'll always be relevant no matter what
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kingdavid on 6/23/2009 4:13PM
We don't know exactly what went down that night between Chris and Rihanna. Has anybody thought that maybe she could have assaulted him and he could have been defending himself. I know what you will say: Did you see the photos of her? Yes. My question: Has anyone reading this ever been assaulted, then, defended yourself, then turned and became the aggressor? I'm not saying my suggestion is correct. I wasn't there. But, there are a number of scenarios as to what may have happened.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Cerisa Pickett on 8/08/2009 12:05AM
That's right no one knows what really went down that night and yes he was wrong for what he did. But does any one even bother to ask what did she do.No they dont they just all jump on him.Thats the media and worl d for you.I still wish him the best in his success in life. Chris keep your head up.
Report This
By: monique on 6/23/2009 11:14PM
Please stop making excuses for this man! Even if she hit him, if he beat her down like that, he should know better. He comes out with no bruises and she comes out messed up. That's crazy.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: roy on 6/24/2009 9:02AM
wow; thats it! she attacked his fist with her face?
or asked him for a kung-fu three piece?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: BRYNE on 6/24/2009 11:52AM
WHO ARE YOU ? WHY SHOULD HE CARE IF YOU FORGIVE HIM OR NOT GET A LIFE AND WATCH HOW YOU THREATEN PEOPLE YOU ARE NO BETTER THAN HINM TO SIT HERE AND JUDGE WITHOUT KNOW THE HOLD STORY THEN TURN AROUND AND ISSUE A WEAK THREAT YOU PROBABLY COULDNT FIGHT A COLD NO ONE WILL EVER KNOW THE TRUE STORY
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: CHERYL on 6/25/2009 10:27AM
I feel that, if U can hit, U can get hit, so word to the wise, do not put out what U donot expect to receive. I have sons and daughters and I taught them that the first rule is do unto others that U would have them do to U. Now when U over do it is a problem as my daughter-in-law found out. I kept warning her about hitting an dslapping my son and that one day she will get hers, and she did. I did not raise my son or any mother raise their son to be a punching bag and if so do not get envolve with them because you will be able to walk all over them and you will loose your respect for them.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: BGeezee on 6/24/2009 4:43PM
Man plan and simple if that was just a regular cat off the streets mof's would of just laughed, but its celeb so everybody want to act like it's there first time seeing things like that go down. who gives a damn nobody was there so no telling what transpired that day she's a entertainer i simply think that's all she did for yaw is entertained pshhh man please let god deal with that and him only!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Will on 6/25/2009 3:42AM
Why as black people we are so quick to throw each other under the bus, listen when Michael Phelps got caught smokeing weed the white community was like ok he made a mistake but hes a kid let it go and let the boy move on, when Mike Vicks did the horrible thing with the dogs America wanted to make an example out of him and yes what he did was wrong but his punishment did not fit the crime and he made a mistake but should his whole life and career be over for a foolish indiscreation, when white kids makes mistakes thier family and the community stands by them and explan thier just kids like the college white kids accused of raping the black girl everyone said lets not judge them untill we have all the evidence but with Chris no one wants to hear his side and yes he admitted to hitting her and yes he should be punished but all of us have made mistakes should we be marked for the rest of our lives for one childish mistake. I'm sure Chris has replayed that night over and over in his head and wished he could take it back but he cant and hopefully he will use this opportunity to talk to other young males and let them know how a mistake that can happen in as little as a minute can affect the rest of your life. But with that said remeber he with no sin cast the first stone...
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: HI AC on 7/06/2009 4:23AM
Dude you seriously ant compare some pot smoking to dog fighting they may be dogs but there still living creatures and yes dogs cry when there in pain I agree that blacks get the short end of the stick i dont judge others but i think you hve to be a pretty cruel astard to fiht animals for no reason i could even understand if that was his only form of income to feed his family but the guy is rich, the way white people get away with this kind of stuff is they fly off to some third world country and fight tigers Siberian ones too
Report This