I came to the latest release of "The Transformers" looking for what I saw in the first film: Jaw-dropping special effects and a story just interesting enough to hold you over until the next explosion. I didn't go to the film looking for racism or embarrassing minstrel shows. My "racial bias glasses" are designed to weed out harmless, inadvertent racism, which comes with living in a society that spent 400 years thinking that black people were less than human. But when racism is thrown in my face repeatedly in the form of ridiculous and disgusting stereotypes, that's when I start to get mad.
Michael Bay is one of my favorite directors, next to the Hughes Brothers (where are they by the way?). He's damn good at what he does. But on this occasion, Bay simply missed his creative target and I'm not the only one who's noticing.
Meet Skids and Mudflap, two Transformers who may as well have been called Lil Wayne and Random Black Male idiot. One of them actually has a gold grill, and neither of them can read. They are bungling buffoons and cowards with barely an ounce of intelligence. One of them rides around as an Ice cream truck with the words "suck my popsicle" on the side, yelling "get your ice cream bitches" to those who might want to buy from his dirty little truck. They also remind you in every other sentence that you are a "punk ass bitch" and that they want to "bust a cap in your ass."
Now meet Optimus Prime. Optimus is a brave, principled leader who speaks with proper English and stands tall in the face of adversity. He protects the cowardly idiots in spite of the fact that they are too stupid to take care of themselves. I can't say whether Optimus is white or black, but he doesn't talk like Skids and Mudflap. His diction is perfect and he doesn't curse. He would never offer to put a "cap in your ass", and he doesn't seem to have any gold teeth. Even dressed in red, white and blue, he looks and sounds a lot like a Republican. Everyone wants to be Optimus Prime. No one wants to be Skids or Mudflap.
Every time Skids and Mudflap opened their mouths, I sank a little further down in my seat. I could almost stomach it all, until the characters backed away in fear when being asked to read. After watching how Bay used these two to provide much of the comic relief in the film, I wanted to find the screen writers, slap them one by one, and force them to take a class on historical images of blacks in media. Hollywood is home to the most sophisticated technological advancements, the most accurate marketing data, and precise, multi-year script analysis. In the face of all of this research, how could they do something so asinine? What's worse is that they absolutely ruined my favorite film by insulting me. Steven Spielberg, the Executive Producer who will also be responsible for making the Martin Luther King film, should have noticed these problems after viewing the Director's cut. Anyone marketing movies for black dollars should have greater racial sensitivity.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Professor at Syracuse University and author of the forthcoming book, "Black American Money". For more information, please visit www.BoyceWatkins.com. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered directly to your email, please click here.



Comments: (1013)
Add a comment
By: dan on 6/25/2009 6:03PM
thank you dr. boyce for your comment i to will refrain from viewing the new transformers. i agree is racist if you disguise what you really meant to portray when it has absolutely nothing to do with the story line. i don't watch bet either jake. i'm so tired of these racist people i'll be glad when it gets old.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Dlove on 6/25/2009 9:57AM
I seen the movie and all I can see is how he was trying to capture how the kids think today thats all what those figures were doing was playing out what rapper been doing for years what our kids white and black are doing now its a movies based on a kids cartoon remember that,so quick to pull the race card is the word of the day well if so, Let us blacks show our kids how to read and write get in touch with there roots speak like they have sense instead of hanging out on corners go to church, or even a library so they can make movies that we like or Have them rent the movie Bambozzelled by spike lee, And see what we loose by not knowing our selfs.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: amber on 6/26/2009 8:09PM
I agree. All kids of all diversities speak and talk this way. I believe that this movie was simply trying to encapsulate a younger generation. Look at Eminem, he speaks this way, and he is white. And since when are the Transformer bots any certain race?
Report This
By: SMH on 6/26/2009 8:51PM
Dear "JustMe":
Absolutely, you should not take your 8 & 10 year old to this movie. It's rated PG-13 for a reason. The MPAA gave it that rating for "intense sequences of sci-fi action violence, language, some crude and sexual material, and brief drug material." You were even thinking about taking an 8 year old to see that? Shame on you! This has nothing to do with deciding your children should or should not see something that has a couple of minor characters who some feel are racially insulting; it is about you choosing age-appropriate entertaiment for your kids.
Report This
By: jsb on 6/26/2009 9:30PM
Exactly... The Transformers are not of any particular race... Everyone screams and calls the movie racist, because typically that type of behavior is seen in young african americans, but that does not make the transformers black... The people calling this movie racist are the ones who are stereotyping...
Report This
By: Anderson on 6/26/2009 10:21PM
Um why would you take your 8 and 10 year olds it is a PG-13 movie.
Report This
By: Tom on 7/01/2009 6:39PM
Lurn how to speel and uze propar anglish furst...
Report This
By: jeffpreston2000 on 7/24/2009 11:29AM
Are you kidding me? Did she really try to say all that in one sentence? Wow.
Report This
By: kcn9971 on 6/25/2009 9:59AM
First of all Dr. Boyce, If you knew anything about the Transformers, you would know that "JAZZ" was always a Black robot, voiced in the cartoon by Scatman Crothers. He was the most popular and memorable Transformer of the whole series. He tranformed into a Porsche, not a Cadillac or "pimp" mobile. So when Michael Bay used him in the first movie, it was more of a tribute rather than racism. You take one line out of the movie, and turn the whole thing into a conspiracy. Yet you had nothing to say about the movie "Dance Flick" by the Wayans Bros. Which had more negative Black stereotypes than any movie this year!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Jake on 6/25/2009 10:13AM
Great point kcn9971 !!!!!
What about "Dance Flick?" or any Black movie for that matter.
I guess it's okay when Black people do it.
Report This