Let's take it from the top: I fight like hell for black people. I fight against the egregious violations in the criminal justice system, and I believe in Henry Louis Gates, the Harvard University professor recently arrested for disorderly conduct. So, hearing the following words from me is not like hearing them from Juan Williams on Fox News.
But here's the deal: In last night's press conference, President Obama was incorrect to provide such strong and immediate support for the case of Dr. Gates. I'll quickly lay out the reasons why:
1) Obama admitted several times that he didn't know all the facts. If you don't know the facts, then you cannot accuse a police department of "acting stupidly." These words amount to a political nuclear warhead being launched by the most powerful man in the free world. Careers are going to be ruined because of this and people are going to suffer. Before making such a strong statement, our president should ensure that he fully understands the situation.
2) Obama started his statement by saying, "Skip Gates is a friend" and admitted that he might be a bit biased. Bad move. By making such a statement, the president doesn't sound like a man objectively evaluating a situation. He sounds like someone who is backing his Harvard crony. Welcome to class warfare, Mr. President. You've now alienated millions of working-class Americans and thousands of police officers by backing your friend without properly investigating the situation.
3) Dr. Gates has a distinguished record, but so does the officer. Sgt. James Crowley has received strong and unconditional support from the Cambridge Police Officers Union, and he has a stellar record with the police force. This support is significant since the union could have remained silent. Also, you must realize (as Dr. Wilmer Leon states) that the district attorney's office dropped the charges on Dr. Gates, not the police department. That is a very different thing, since the DA is affected by political pressure. To hear more of Dr. Leon's insightful comments, please click here.
4) Showing an ID and proving that you live in a home is not (and should not be) enough to get most officers to stop asking questions. One-third of all female murder victims are killed by an intimate. Many of the assailants are men who break into their own homes to kill their spouse. The officer has an obligation to investigate, to make sure the person is supposed to be in the house, not just that he is a resident.
5) I am not condemning anyone. I am not saying that Henry Louis Gates is a criminal, and I am not saying that the officer is corrupt. I am saying that I want more facts. I want to hear from witnesses. I want to see more evidence showing me that this cop was really being racist and that this was not just a battle of egos. Being a professor at Harvard does not give anyone the right to disrespect a law enforcement officer, but being an officer doesn't give you the right to mistreat a person of color.
The bottom line is this: I am not attacking the president, but he should not have attacked Sgt. Crowley. I am not attacking Henry Louis Gates, but I am not interested in being asked to make a full judgment with half of the necessary information. No one knows what happened in that house, and until there is an investigation, the president should be extremely careful with his words.
If you want to hear it "straight from the Boyce's mouth," please click on the video below:
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a distinguished scholar with the Barbara Jordan Institute for Policy Research at Texas Southern University. To have Dr. Boyce's commentary delivered directly to your e-mail, please click here.



Comments: (133)
Add a comment
By: Rodney on 10/21/2009 11:37PM
Algorham you make an excellent point! Dr. Watkins you understand the episode yet your overall conclusions are inapropriate If you think about your 2nd point. The fact that he prefaced his comments by saying "I'm a friend,..dont have all the facts..etc. " In essence he is saying dont take anything I say about this as a President speaking, ...rather take it as me the person Barak, Normal person with feelings and opinions. Guess this whole thing has more to do with can we accept and deal with the fact that people elected to high office are still people like everybody else and deserve the respect and allowance to differentiate themselves from their job/office from time to time like the rest of us.
Report This
By: Minerva on 8/11/2009 1:10AM
Dr. Boyce is speaking out of both sides of his mouth. Not good. Either your hot or cold, sitting on the middle of the fence does not make for a peaceful solution to a very real problem. Mr. Gates was wrong. Plain and simple. Barack Obama was wrong. Officer Crowley is the one that deserved the apology. All the known facts, including photographs of the incident, as well as witness statements prove that. Of course, you'll never hear that from the mainstream press. Just another reason why the issue of race will never go away. No one's willing to be honest about it!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: James on 8/18/2009 6:10PM
Wow, any comment by Anyone, about Bob Dylan, being NOT Reconised by the Police. He was PROFIDED by the Police--------White guy walking in a neighborhood of minorities at night.
Gee, he went with the Cops.
DIDN"T CRY PROFLYING!!! Never arrested, Go Figure.
Reply to this Comment | Report This