If you've ever attended college, you've interacted with a professor. If you were lucky, you might have run into a black one. Chances are, you probably never had a black professor in college.
I'd never taken a class from a black professor until I actually became one, since many universities don't hire black scholars very often. When universities actually do hire black scholars, they enjoy getting rid of them after concluding that they are not as qualified as the white faculty members.
Like my respected colleague Dr. Cornel West, I've had battles on this issue with my own school, Syracuse University, which has a horrible history when it comes to hiring black people who don't dribble a basketball. Even Historically Black Colleges and Universities have this problem. Have you ever counted how many black professors there are in the sciences and business schools of HBCUs? The numbers might surprise you. Your kids are not being taught by black professors as much as they might lead you to believe.
What is saddest, however, is not the racism of academia. Even more shocking is the manner by which many intellectuals (black and non-black) are "dumbed down" by the way scholars and professors are trained to think.
Rather than exploring the world and engaging in high-action scholarship, we are trained, like monkeys, to sit inside our man-made bubbles within the ivory tower, focusing on minuscule, insignificant problems. Once these problems are solved, we are told to publish the work in academic journals, which are read by a very small number of people in our tiny little niche. We become like some Baptist ministers who are so caught up with the collection plate that they no longer care about God. Professors are here to share knowledge, and we've lost the desire to educate anyone other than ourselves.
The academic bubble for black scholars is incredibly comfortable and inviting, and as destructive as a crack house next to a day care center. Throughout history, the best way to conquer a people has been to murder the scholars and intellectual leaders. African American scholars have not been killed in body, but in mind and spirit. We are lulled into a sense that "you've made it....you are the chosen negro," which means that you can then leave behind all the problems of blackness in exchange for your comfortable seat in the ivory tower.
If you are well-behaved and perpetuate the white power structure, you get to keep your position. When a black man gets shot by police, that's not your problem. When Hurricane Katrina leaves dead bodies in the street, that's not your problem. When significant black organizations go bankrupt and you have the expertise to save them, that's not your problem. Your focus is on writing that research paper for the academic journal that only 30 people are going to read. After that, you take your vacations to Martha's Vineyard and sip iced tea on the front porch of your summer home. That becomes your mission in life. The same way that Chinese citizens were controlled by Opium exported by the British during the 19th century, the spirit of the African American scholar has been neutralized by the comforts of the academic bubble.
Most black scholars don't come to academia pre-trained to have such a meaningless existence. You must be fully brainwashed to accept your new and impotent reality. Your first two years of doctoral study are spent asking your professors why they are discouraging you from doing meaningful work. They then explain to you that in "the academy, we only do things that are scholarly." Keeping it scholarly becomes the rule of the day, the same way some brothers in the hood choose to "keep it gangsta." This means keeping a firm distance from those people in the "real world" whose opinions don't matter nearly as much as your own because you are educated and they are not.
If you'll notice, most of the members of black academia do not engage in much professional association with people outside the ivory tower, the same way that some churches don't want their members speaking to people with a different perception of God. Interacting with those who think differently becomes a threat to the psychological incubator you've created for yourself, making your ideas vulnerable to alternative points of view. I even recall hearing a prominent black management scholar tell me that my ideas were "dangerous" for young black scholars to hear because they would lead them to think about other career paths. When the suppression of ideas becomes the answer to your problems, that usually means that you, yourself, have become the problem.
In much of academic research, whether your theory actually works in the real world is far less important than whether the so-called leading experts in your field have signed off on it. I would even dare to say that it was the reliance on many of these flawed theories that led to the collapse of our global financial system. People thought that because professors teach finance at Harvard, they actually know how financial markets work. Believe me, I've spent a great deal of time with black scholars in business and management, and I honestly wouldn't trust them to manage a Burger King, let alone the world's financial system. This is not to say that they are not well trained, rather, the lack of real-world experience makes their work incapable of having effective practical implications.
The only logical way to rationalize the decision of black scholars to ignore the masses in exchange for journal outlets is to conclude that they've somehow been convinced that the second audience is of higher quality than the first. Speaking to 10,000 people without a Ph.D. is not considered as important to many black scholars as speaking to 20 people who have a doctorate. What is most tragic about such thinking is that it not only disrespects the humanity of other African Americans, but it also reflects the same kind of elitism that has always served to oppress the black community.
Many of our most brilliant citizens have been taught to think small, selfishly and with great delusion. Our book smarts go through the roof, while our common sense has been left at the door. We live and die, and no one knows or cares that we were here. That's the tragedy of black America, and the most glaring reflection of Carter G. Woodson's 'Miseducation of the Negro.' The only thing worse than being fed psychological poison is to be given an overdose of that poison, which makes us, as black scholars, among the most intellectually handicapped citizens in our nation. Yes, I am part of that group, too, and I am working to outgrow my handicaps every day.
So, if you went to college and wondered why your professor taught you a bunch of things that you never used in your career, it's because he probably doesn't even understand what you do on a day-to-day basis. The truth is that professors don't need to understand what you do, and many of them don't really care. If you've ever wondered why black scholars are never on the forefront of the most significant debates of the day, it's because they would be punished by their superiors for speaking out on black issues. We've had a bubble built for us, our own little heaven. In this heaven, there is no crime, no poverty and no black struggle. There is only wine, cheese, bow ties and ivy. Our most powerful minds are enslaved, and I am not sure what it will take to free them. The intellectual suicide of the black American scholar has become one of the great tragedies of the 21st century.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a finance professor at Syracuse University. He does regular commentary in national media, including CNN, MSNBC, BET and more. To have Dr. Boyce's commentary delivered directly to your e-mail, please click here.



Comments: (27)
Add a comment
By: Kathy on 8/11/2009 10:40AM
Are you looking for sympathy? I'm sorry but none here.
You don't seem to have any for your fellow black colleagues. Wasn't it just last week that you were on CNN trashing Dr. Gates in favor of some stupid racist cop?
Now that it's convenient you think Black folks should rally behind "your" struggle? Forget!
Are still at Syracuse? How wise is it to be trashing them. Do you still want a paycheck?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Kathy on 8/11/2009 10:45AM
Are you looking for sympathy? I'm sorry but none here.
You don't seem to have any for your fellow black colleagues. Wasn't it just last week that you were on CNN trashing Dr. Gates in favor of some stupid racist cop?
Now that it's convenient you think Black folks should rally behind "your" struggle? Forget it!
Are still at Syracuse? How wise is it to be trashing them. Do you still want a paycheck?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: mAnShe goHArd on 8/11/2009 11:07AM
At the beginning of the Gates scandal I would have agreed with you. I was watching Dr. Boyce on CNN like "he really is trippin". But really Dr. Boyce just wanted the facts before he took a side. This article describes Gates to a T. Before his scandal of being arrested he could care less about real issues in the Black community and eventually will go back to his intellectual suicide. So I feel like you can say the same thing about Dr. Gates wanting instant sympathy.
Report This
By: Kathy on 8/11/2009 11:40AM
Dr. Gates did not want sympathy, he wanted objectivity. Listen to his side of the story.
Boyce on the other hand said he wanted all the facts, but has already concluded Gates was rich, elitist, & was saying "you don't know who you messing with." How did he know that, from the cop's report? Please!
To him the cop's words were conclusive & accurate, but Gates needed more investigation. Why didn't he extend the same benefit of the doubt to Gates?
So what if Gates is elitist, & rich & all that, he worked for it. Why does that warrant an arrest? Boyce of all people should know that! He has walked in his shoes!
No sympathy at all here!
Report This
By: triciagirl on 8/11/2009 2:07PM
If Syracuse fires him for speaking out, then that means that they don't believe in academic freedom.
Report This
By: um yeah on 8/11/2009 10:57AM
This was a nice read Dr Watkins, revealing what Black scholars experience. I was fortunate enough to have a Black professor but she wasn't jaded like these you write about.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: tangilct on 8/11/2009 11:19AM
I feel that I must correct you on one point - that the situation at our HBCU's with black professors is not how you described. I may not be able to speak for EVERY HBCU, but as a recent (within the past 2 years) graduate of Howard University's School of Business, we have an abundance of black professors of many different personalities, backgrounds, and schools of thought. From one professor that preached assimilation into the white business world to another that had us read "$40 Million Slaves," I received a wealth of knowledge from these academics who spent more time leading discussions about the tragedy of Hurricane Katrina than writing books. Professors who were willing to spend an hour talking to you in their office while you argued your grade on a paper and then change lesson plans to fit the interests of the class. And this was just in the Business School.
I will admit that in the mathematics department and technology, there were more foreign teachers than African American ones (Arab, Carribbean, and African), but in my classes that challenged me to think critically, debate, and write, I had more than enough black professors to relate to, especially coming from a school system where I can count on one hand all the black teachers I had from K-12.
If one does not like their academic lot in the majority arena, I suggest building back up our once proud and strong HBCU's so that they can become the research institutions and top ranked universities they were meant to be. Obviously, we have the talent, but the lure of money and prestige at majority schools tend to outweigh the grassroot struggle of making our own colleges better.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kce on 8/11/2009 11:57AM
Powerful!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Tara on 8/11/2009 12:07PM
Now it all makes sense. Boyce has a bias against people like Gates. Prejudice is not always racial you know. What happened; they won't let you in at the country club?
Go ahead Boyce, have some cheese & wine, we'll be alright! With advocates like you, who needs the Boston PD?
Don't you understand today it's Gates, t'row it's you?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: rdl on 8/11/2009 12:23PM
Evolutionary forces have shaped each of us , if we are trying to grasp a complex subject , the first step is give it intellectual relevants. That is Dr.Boyce as a professor , you must acknowledge the breathe and scope of a subject before reducing it to some inferior mental element. You tell me, how can you grasp what it was like to have been a slave.Nonetheless, it is even harder to grasp how a dominant group could have enslaved black peoples for a period of 400 years, that is incomprehensible. Having history as a guide we can say these people who denied our black ancestors their inalienable rights to be free were less than human themselves. We as black people will continue to be treated subordinated as long as professionals like you feel helplessness. Yes, there is enough blame to go around why we are so weak, just look at our parents childhoods developmentally it had to have been horrifying and their parents even worst. Yet, many of them are decesed and it is indeed left up to this generation to carry on the torch of humanity, we must be heard.
Tell the weak black,you are somebody. Tell the oppressor, " I am black and I am proud". Yes, I belive we can do it all alone, without the black elite of our generation, despite the black rogue elements that war against the black middle class and the certain assasinations of our up and coming class of black leaders,by black assasins, of whom I consider myself. Life is not what I have come to know but that which I dare to live, be it as it is a subjugated black man I defy my oppressor and I dare to live as a free man. Lets all live as a free people. Don Snow
Reply to this Comment | Report This