
On Monday, death row inmate Troy Davis and his NAACP team gained a big win, when the Supreme Court ruled to grant Davis, who has been incarcerated for almost 20 years, a final hearing to prove his innocence and escape execution for allegedly killing off-duty police officer Mark McPhail. NAACP President and CEO Benjamin Jealous explains why Davis' evidentiary hearing is historic and how you can make an impact in the justice system.
How long has the NAACP been involved with the Troy Davis case?
Benjamin Jealous: In Georgia, we've been involved for four years. Nationally, we got involved about four months ago, so that's been the history.
According to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, the Supreme Court's "order [is] unlike any it has issued in almost half a century." Were you surprised by the ruling?
Jealous: Oh, very much so. I mean, the lawyers said we had a 1 percent chance at best, and those were the lawyers who were on our side. So we were very surprised. Their decision was correct; it was absolutely what the spirit and the letter of the Constitution compelled the court to do. Our nation never intended for the courts to put people to death based on procedure -- in contradiction to the facts. So what people should be disturbed about is that this is the first time this happened in the past 50 years.
Exonerated by DNA
Byron Halsey
Halsey spent more than two decades in state prison before being exonerated by DNA testing for the brutal rape and murder of two New Jersey children. Now he's filing a federal civil rights suit.
AP / The Star-Ledger
Alton Logan
Logan spent 26 years in prison for fatally shooting a security guard in 1983. In 2007, an attorney for another man who admitted that he had committed the crime came forward with the truth. He was officially declared innocent in April 2009.
AP
Antonio Beaver
He served more than a decade in prison because blood found on an attack victim was not presented in his trial. Once testing proved him not guilty, all charges were dropped in 2007. Unfortunately, he landed back in jailafter crashing his car while drunk.
Innocence Project
Calvin Johnson
DNA from a rape kit did not match Johnson's. He was set free in 1999 after nearly 16 years in prison. He later wrote a book about his ordeal.
John Bazemore / AP
Darryl Hunt
Darryl Hunt was convicted twice of a 1984 North Carolina murder. After DNA results proved his innocence in 1994, it still took 10 years of legal appeals to exonerate him.
Innocence Project
Donte Booker
After serving 15 years on a rape conviction, Booker was exonerated on Feb. 9, 2005, after DNA evidence on the victim's clothing pointed to someone else. In 2007 he was accused of a second rape, of which he was found not guilty by a jury in 2008.
Innocence Project
Floyd Brown
Brown was freed in 2007 after 14 years behind bars. Authorities locked up the mentally disabled man without a trial in 1993 and lost or destroyed key criminal evidence that could have freed him years ago.
Innocence Project
Herman Atkins
Atkins was convicted in 1988 of robbery, rape, forcible oral copulation and for using a handgun. After test results were returned, Atkins was released from prison in February 2000, after spending 12 years in prison. He has since gone to college, married, and dedicated his life to helping those who have been wrongly convicted.
Innocence Project
James Lee Woodard
Woodard spent more time in prison than any other wrongfully convicted inmate in U.S. history -- 27 years. DNA testing in the murder and rape of his girlfriend ultimately overturned his conviction in 2008.
AP
James Waller
In 2006, 23 years after his conviction of rape, DNA from a rape kit that had never been presented was found not to belong to Waller. He was pardoned by Texas governor Rick Perry in 2007.
Innocence Project / AP
Which brings me to my next question, what are your thoughts about Clarence Thomas and Antonin Scalia's stance?
Jealous: It's specious and deeply disturbing, saying that we should execute people based on procedure in contravention of the facts or in a refusal to consider the facts. That logic is evil. There's no other way to describe it. It's a very base logic that contradicts everything that this country is supposed to be about.
How do you feel about the state of the penal system and the large black population affected by it?
Jealous: We have one black man in the White House, and we have a million in prison. Our country is 5 percent of the global population and 25 percent of the global penal population. You can't even begin to solve the social ills that plague this country, the challenges, and the school system and the job market unless you engage the criminal justice crisis in this country. It bankrupts our schools, it depletes our communities of working men, it robs mothers from their children, it forces children into foster care. It's the crisis by which we will all be judged. For every century in this country, there has been a crisis that disproportionately affects black people by which we always judge the people who live in that time. If you lived in the 20th century, the question is what did you do to end Jim Crow? If you lived in the 19th century, the question is what did you do to end slavery? If you lived in the 18th century, the question is what did you do to end the slave trade? And for people living in the next century looking back at this one, they will ask, what did you do to confront, to transform, the reality that this country was the biggest incarcerator and that black people and the black community are being destroyed by that plague?
If Troy Davis were to go free, how would it affect both the wrongly incarcerated and the justice system?
Jealous: The only thing that is more encouraging to somebody on death row is seeing someone else walk off death row and seeing yourself walk off death row. This case, unfortunately for hundreds, if not thousands, of people in this country serving time is that they're serving time for crimes they didn't commit. And that's just what the mathematics add up to, what the odds add up to. This is a sign of hope. For all of the folks [who are wrongly incarcerated], what this says is that the justice system can work and justice can be done. Even when the lawyers on your side say there's a 1 percent chance, there's still a chance, and you got to push for it.
Stephen Bright, of the Southern Center for Human Rights in Atlanta, said that the shifting of the burden of proof on to Davis is a much more difficult proposition for him to withstand. Do you agree?
Jealous: Well, it's much better than going to the execution chamber. You've got to remember where he starts from. He didn't just start from a presumption of guilt; he really started with being on pace to being executed within two months. And it is a tough place and it is a tough court. I think that we have to celebrate this moment and then we get to focus on the next. Going in to a district court in Georgia is going to a court in Georgia. And going in there with the presumption that you're guilty and you have to prove that you're innocent is a high bar. But at the same time, seven of the nine witnesses have recanted, and six more supporting their side of the story have come forward. So we have great hope that the court will hear and act on the truth. So Stephen's right, but again, the lawyers said we had a 1 percent chance, but now the chance is much better than it was.
Do you think that the justice system will improve with President Barack Obama in office and Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor's appointment?
Jealous: We have a president who knows the South Side of Chicago. We have a justice that knows the South Bronx, and that matters. When President Barack Obama spoke at our convention, he talked about the fact that our country was the biggest incarcerator, and he talked about how even with that status and even if we imprisonment of all the races of people in this country, more than any other country on this planet, we still incarcerate black people five times more than we do whites. So the fact that it's on his mind, and that he's willing to talk about it publicly matters, because that encourages other people to actually pick up the baton and run the race.
How can the public become empowered enough to affect how law is being practiced?
Jealous: People can't stand by. The justice system tends to make people feel powerless. And the reality is there is a connection between the court of public opinion and the court of law. So when people say, "What can I do? I'm not a lawyer, and even if I am, that's not my client," the answer is speak out, encourage someone else speak out, let the court know, the D.A. know, let the Supreme Court know that you are concerned. That this is not what you signed up for as an American.
If you look back three or four months ago, I said to my national staff, "We are going to take everything that we have and put it on this case." The people were outraged in Norway, the people were outraged in Germany, they were outraged California, they were outraged in New York, but we sat down with the D.A. and they said, "We haven't heard from anyone in this community." So we got together with the activists at Amnesty International, and together we put down 12,000 signatures from the local community on his desk, in addition to 55,000 from around the country. And in the process, we sat down with the publisher from the local newspaper, whose reporters have been covering this as a cop killer case for the last 20 years. We walked him through why this case was different, and his newspaper coverage turned 180 degrees. And then, there they are, front-page photographs of petitions being handed to the D.A. staff, and ultimately that message gets to the Supreme Court clerks, and they see us on Bill Maher's show talking about it, and they hear us on Tom Joyner talking about it, and that has an impact. The death row process is a numbing process for everyone involved. The Supreme Court clerks process dozens and dozens of these sorts of appeals every year, and they always say no. And that's what activists have to understand: You can actually influence the Supreme Court. You can get them to pay attention to something that they normally would probably just process away.
Go to the I Am Troy web site to learn how you can help save the lives of those unjustly incarcerated.


Comments: (14)
Add a comment
By: marilyn on 8/20/2009 11:28AM
Now, which one of you is still saying that the NAACP is not relevant?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Brenda Fox on 8/21/2009 9:47AM
It depends on who you ask. Look at those images, read the article and really understand it. Does those pictures tell you the story? Are the pictures shattered by the words?
Report This
By: Brenda Fox on 8/20/2009 12:57PM
Agreed. My question is; going back to the 17th century to the present have we made enough progress to claim victory over the said crisis “crisis that disproportionately affects black people by which we always judge the people who live in that time” of the centuries mentioned by Jealous? By contrast, if we haven’t coup d’état those crisis and they have simply been transfixed at a different angle; my next question is will a transformed penal system in the age of advance technological progress, nuclear power, aging earth etc. will do anything to solve inequalities; (centuries old), fair distribution of wealth, fairness in employment, fairness in compensation, fairness in political representation, fairness in economics, fairness in social representation? This sounds like the same old song because these crises are one in the same old catastrophe/ fire that never got put out. You know, we can solve these disasters at the home level by teaching our children first, quit our positions as commodities, consumers without a mission (don’t buy from those where you are not represented, etc.. A transformation can take place in this country starting in a day if you had the courage to control your spending. Your money has power. All of these crises are rooted in intention/ determination to get your money and your labor, and capitalize on your skills…You know what I mean.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: LACAM31 on 8/21/2009 11:15PM
First of all we as black folk have to start sticking toether.help one another.Education is really the key.Just look at what is happening in todays world.believe it or not it is an overwhelming group of white people that don't want us as blck people to progress.This health care reform .If you notice white people hate change.They are always thinking they are going to lose something.And they do not and i say again do not want a black man or women telling them nothing.Of course they would accept a black female before a Brother.They just plain out don't accept our black President.Bipartanship......What's that.Birth certificte.They are going to jail us as long as we as citzen let these crooks in office stay in office.I wish Try well in his outcome.That is if he is innocent.
Report This
By: Brenda Fox on 8/20/2009 2:39PM
Those men and their stories are sad. There’re criminals of all human kind on all podiums of life but in the line-up they are menacing criminals.
Chances are, If these guys were innocent, the time they spent in the prison institution has degraded their good nature. I hope the states are using the taxpayers money to support psychological treatment, education, skill training and family support for those people…
Jealous: Oh, very much so. I mean, the lawyers said we had a 1 percent chance at best, and those were the lawyers who were on our side. So we were very surprised. Their decision was correct; it was absolutely what the spirit and the letter of the Constitution compelled the court to do. Our nation never intended for the courts to put people to death based on procedure -- in contradiction to the facts. So what people should be disturbed about is that this is the first time this happened in the past 50 years.
Jealous: It's specious and deeply disturbing, saying that we should execute people based on procedure in contravention of the facts or in a refusal to consider the facts. That logic is evil. There's no other way to describe it. It's a very base logic that contradicts everything that this country is supposed to be about.
I understand why Jealous don’t want to deface the “letter of the constitution, its an old cry that won’t solve problems, but to say “Their decision was correct; it was absolutely what the spirit and the letter of the Constitution compelled the court to do is ambiguous, for the spirit of the constitution is dichotomous in its own right. Slit spirited…
People, the only transformation in the penal system that is necessary is that all people get equal justice and groups, syndicates, and others are not allowed to change the rules, only all people…If all individuals, families, etc would teach and live by love, morals, political participation, economic and common sense, etc., we could cut that our penal population down to 5 percent of the global penal population…It is simple if you would remove or stop eating subjective allocutions/ misinformation fed to your mind by all of the media sources including some school text books. Read the constitution and decipher…
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kimberly on 8/20/2009 5:46PM
I applaud the NAACP for their continued work and diligence in these types of issues. Yes, they are still relevant. When people finally learn to live together as God intended, and all people are treated fairly and all are shown compasion, we will no longer need groups such as NAACP, Amnesty International, Operation Rainbow PUSH and so on.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: JULIUS EVANS on 8/22/2009 11:07PM
DOES IT APPEAR TO ANYONE ELSE THAT JUDGE THOMAS IS
TRYING VERY HARD TO PROVE TO THE WORLD THAT HE'S NOT BLACK ?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Charles on 8/21/2009 10:06AM
I know a few guys I hope and pray dont ever get out. Maybe the best thing to do is stop Black men from going to jail in the first place.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: CYNTHIA on 8/21/2009 6:57PM
i am a black woman and i really don't nothing about troy davis where were all the supporters when he was given the death penalty also his cancer ridden sister forget the davis family what about the MCPHAIL'S FAMILY.i don't go along to get along
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: martinidemon on 8/21/2009 6:27PM
Instead of complaining why don't we try changing? Jealous keeps talking about the justice system tearing apart black communities....how about black communities are tearing themselves up? When are we as black Americans going to stand up and take the responsibility for what ills our people and fix it? Over half...YES HALF!...of all gun murders last year were black on black! We make up 12.9% of this nation yet black men made up over half the dead citizens killed by OTHER black men in this country. Isn't it obvious that RACISM isn't killing black people but black people killing black people? Its easy to blame the legal system, or the government or the police. It is much harder to face ourselves and work to fix things. High schoo drop outs, single mothers and poverty all pretyt much guarantee a life of poverty, crime or drugs and alcohol. We need to strengthen our families and push for success instead of finding excuses to blame the Man. Jealous gets paid as does the so-called "REV" Sharpton through the chaos in our communities.... They don't want to solve it but keep us in a cycle of dependency where we feel we need others to allegedly 'help us'. We are not children...get up people! Let us face the issues and fix ourselves for our children and the future!
Reply to this Comment | Report This