I found a couple of scholars willing to speak up on the Ebony Magazine sale and I know a few more. The two I spoke with most recently were Dr. Deborah Stroman, a Professor at The University of North Carolina Chapel Hill. Dr. Stroman is not just a professor, but she is also the owner of LASER - Life After Sports with Effective Results, a company that helps athletes transition into productive lives when their athletic careers are over.
When it comes to the pending sale or potential bankruptcy of Ebony Magazine, Dr. Stroman had this to say:

Business knows one only color – green. Whether one has a history of success or newfound fame, businesses must continue to make a profit. Unfortunately, the announcement recently made by Johnson Publishing Company, Inc. the world's largest African-American-owned and-operated publishing company, reflects the simple fact that long-term financial projections reveal that there is more month left than money.
Dr. Stroman then goes on to highlight the business lessons we can all learn from the experience of Ebony Magazine:
1)Know and stay in tune with your audience. The graying demographic that historically supported Ebony can't be relied upon for financial stability in recessionary times.
2)Embrace technology or get left behind. Experts have clearly articulated the dying of print media over the past decade.
To read more of what Dr. Stroman had to say, please click here.

I also spoke with Dr. Wilmer Leon, an expert on black politics and black history. Here is what he had to say:
During segregation Ebony and Jet magazines were key sources of information for the African American community about the community. With integration, too many of us left our communities, churches, and culture behind in order to assimilate into the dominant culture. With that, for too many, Ebony no longer reflects the community they live in; aspire to live in or a lifestyle that they see as relevant. I have always felt that Ebony needed to incorporate more relevant political/economic/business information, analysis, and content to appeal to the growing African American middle and upper class. Life style and entertainment is great but that needs to be supplemented with the relevant information to maintain that life style. It's a difficult mix to maintain but necessary.
Dr. Leon goes on to make it clear that the sale of Ebony/Jet doesn't mean that they will cease to exist. To read more of what Dr. Leon has to say about the pending sale of Ebony Magazine, please click here.
When it comes to the sale of Ebony Magazine, the bottom line is this: Black scholars should have something to say when our most prestigious institutions are in jeopardy. Even if the management at Ebony Magazine doesn't listen, the public usually will. When I discussed this topic the other day with the Rev. Al Sharpton, there was a general concern among those within the audience about the possible loss of something they deem to be precious. Media is incredibly powerful; it shapes the minds of our youth and directs the attention of adults. By losing control of all major black media, our minds and destinies can be put into the hands of those with ulterior motives. I am not sure we would want that.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Finance Professor at Syracuse University, 2007 Black Speaker of the Year and author of the forthcoming book, "Black American Money." To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here.


Comments: (3)
Add a comment
By: Kenneth Terrell Collins on 10/03/2009 1:11PM
I look at this the as I looked at "Booty Call" vs. "Rosewood". Lines of us were going around the corner to see "Booty Call" but we did not respond to "Rosewood" the same way {when they opened in the theatre]. Too many time WE say we want something but WE do not support it with our monies.Is it possible that Ebony's finacial problems were also a product of US not buying it? If that is the case why are WE complaining when it gets sold, WE were not buying it. These are the times when we pretend we want something when the time to show we wanted it was before now. If wereally cared about EBony so much why did WE let sit on the news stands unbought?
It is up to us to maintain what we say we want to keep.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Joan Gosier on 10/03/2009 4:11PM
This lesson although painful should be studied by ALL groups who rely on mainstream corporate advertising, sponsorships and "green light" approvals for funding to maintain core operations. This should call to attention many organizations that rely on non-black dollars and sense to exist. National Black (fill-in-the-blank) need to really sit down and do 20 year projections using 3 DIFFERENT scenarios. Conventions and extravaganzas need to be evaluated for ROI. 'Cause when the flu is going around...somebody else is definitely gonna get sick.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Djphoenix on 10/03/2009 8:50PM
I usually agree with Dr. Boyce, but I could not disagree more this time. Intellectuals and scholars have nothing to say about the Ebony sale unless they raise or have money to buy it. Ebony has a long history in our community and a compelling legacy. I still subscribe to Ebony, and I would hate to see it go away. I do not for one minute, however, think that I have some say-so in its sale. Ebony Enterprises is not my responsibility. In that I mean that I don't have the responsibility to run it everyday -- to eek out payrolls, taxes, insurance and ad campaigns. The Johnson family does. They should be the ones to make the decision about its future and with no regrets. They have paid their dues. They owe no one anything. I ran a business for a number of years. When I made the decision to end it for personal reasons, I can not believe how many people were critical. They were able to come and go as they pleased and to take from the business at will, but they bore none of the burden of the very real responsibilities and consequences of having a business -- I and my family did. I pray for strength for the Johnson family, and I hope that they make a very successful sale. I also hope that those in our community who really care about Ebony can save and maintain it by purchasing and running it for decades to come, with all of the ups and downs that come with leading and maintaining an institution. This is what the Johnsons have done up to this point, beginning in the past, when our community needed it, and no one else stepped forward and stayed around.
Reply to this Comment | Report This