If you're like me, when you receive gift cards, you're likely to stow them away in your wallet, where they stay largely forgotten until those occasional times when cash flow gets tight. When I finally use one, I rarely remember who gave it to me.If you're like Baltimore Mayor Sheila Dixon, you use those suckers right away. That's what they're meant for, right?
Not so fast, say prosecutors in Dixon's criminal theft trial, which got under way on Nov. 13. They accuse the city's first female mayor of spending about 60 gift cards, worth roughly $1,500, on herself, when they were intended for needy families at Christmastime.
The question comes down to whether you believe the mayor is enough of a scrooge to deliberately steal groceries from the mouths of hungry residents -- yes, Giant (a grocery chain) gift cards are among those in question -- or if, like many of us, she simply failed to keep her gift cards straight.
"When you steal, you've committed a theft," state prosecutor Robert Rohrbaugh said in opening arguments. "When you steal, and you're a public servant, and you steal from the needy, it's unspeakable."
All Mixed Up in Love
Dixon's defense is that she mixed up the gift cards, which were donated by developer Patrick Turner, with ones that had been donated by her married ex-boyfriend, Ronald H. Lipscomb, to use as she pleased. Prosecutors must prove she intentionally stole the cards from needy families, say her attorneys.Lipscomb is expected to testify that his gift cards were indeed intended for the needy, and not his beloved, contrary to what the mayor's defense claims. (Lipscomb has since returned to his wife and is presumably showering her with groceries now.)
The gift cards, which were also from big-box chains such as Best Buy, Circuit City and Old Navy, were allegedly used by Dixon over a four-year period. A raid of her home turned up a $400 Xbox 360 game system, a $269 Samsung camcorder and an unopened DVD of the movie 'Four Brothers,' among other items. All the items are connected to store receipts and gift cards.
Everyone's Doing It
On Nov. 14, a number of city employees testified that it was common practice for holiday gift cards to come across their desks, too. According to the Baltimore Sun, the mayor's current boyfriend, housing department division chief Edward Anthony, told the court that he frequently receives retail gift cards that he then loses track of. During cross-examination by defense attorney Melissa Phinn, Anthony said, "Being a single man, I don't have the best organization. ... I have a lot of gift cards laying around." He also acknowledged that a gift card traced to Lipscomb was used in conjunction with his own Giant discount card.
Despite the controversy surrounding the trial, Dixon still appears to have a number of supporters. Community organizations and business groups, such as the Maryland Minority Contractors Association Inc., have reportedly packed the courtroom where the trial is taking place. They say she's been an effective mayor, and some of them suggest that a trial over such a small amount of money (we're not talking $90,000 cash stashed in the freezer, William Jefferson–style) is a racially or politically motivated attempt to take a good sister down.
Meanwhile, the mayor seems to be holding up reasonably well under the stress of the trial, notwithstanding (see the video above) the occasional flare-up. Trial testimony resumed today.
______________
Sheryl Huggins Salomon is contributing editor of Black Voices, where she writes about politics and society. She is co-editor of the 'Nia Guide for Black Women' series of self-improvement books and the former publisher of Shade magazine. Follow her on Twitter or contact her at BVCEditor@aol.com.


Comments: (15)
Add a comment
By: paul on 11/16/2009 2:23PM
Who makes Best Buy gift card donations to the poor?
It sounds to me like the ex-husband was "donating" gift cards for Dixon to use so he could write off some of his alimony as a tax deductible donation. If that's the case, they were both stealing from all of us by not paying their fair share to Uncle Sam.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Aaron on 11/19/2009 10:09PM
So you are saying that poor people don't have electronics?
Report This
By: paul on 11/20/2009 9:52AM
No, smarty. I'm saying that electronics don't fall under the category of "basic needs".
There are a lot of things that poor people have that aren't necessarily something that would be donated to help them out.
Report This
By: Tired of Poor ME attitude on 11/17/2009 2:13PM
I am so tired of the apologists for Black politicians. Expect better behavior and jump in when they are corrupt. It doesn't matter what Race they are, if they are crooks slam them in jail.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Kevin on 11/17/2009 9:49AM
First - I am not condoning stealing, particularly stealing from those in need.
But my question is - $1500? Not that to someone is need - to mostly anyone - that isn't a nice amount of money. But come on. Last time I checked there was some businessman who had taken 5 billion dollars, and we still haven't gotten him. Furthermore, let us not pretend for one minute that it isn't common knowledge that this is something that is done by a large number of elected officials and politicians.
Again, I am not saying that it is right. What I am saying is if we are going to actually start making them accountable, then we should make them ALL accountable.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: sharkchops on 11/17/2009 11:55AM
I agree however, Ms. Dixon will also have to be part of that Dragnet since she's a public figure who definitely knows better. I don't understand why blacks think because whites get away with it often that they should also get away with it. Crime is crime no matter who does it. We need to realize that we're under more scrutiny than whites. IN fact, we're under scrutiny 24/7. Every time we walk into a department store to every time a black face shows up on the news on tv. When we do stuff like this, it only confirms suspicions and judgements. And when a high ranking black official does it, it makes people think that even those of us who appear responsible aren't trustworthy. Here in Philly, the city treasurer Corey Kemp got sent to jail for 10 yrs for improprieties concerning his specific job back in '05. Why would you think you wouldn't be watched, especially as a black person? He was involved in money laundering, extortion, welfare fraud, false tax returns as well as accepting bribes and even defrauding his own church. And this was a young black man. Black folks have to realize also that when they get caught doing white collar crimes, the punishment will always be more harsh and severe. They don't want you doing their kind of crimes anyway. They want you to stick to purse-snatching and hitting little old ladies over the head for their S.S. and pension checks. Here's a better idea: Don't do any crime at all.
Report This
By: Ty on 11/18/2009 12:55PM
@Tired of Poor Me....Well said!!
The bottom line is this, if in fact she stole those giftcards, then yes, she should be persecuted because she should have known better and if not let's move on.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: black conservative on 11/17/2009 7:15PM
What she did was arrogant and stupid,and deserves whatever punishment she gets.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Vedia on 11/19/2009 5:36PM
Be kind to those you meet on the way, they are the same ones . you will meet on the way down.Leave Arrogant and stupid home when dealing with the public,you work for them.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Lisa on 11/19/2009 6:02PM
I think the ex-married man who realized it was cheaper to keep his wife became bitter when rejected. He ran back to his wife and to get in her good graces he is thrashing the woman he trully loves. A soap opera at whose expense the tax payers of MD.
Each day the state of MD pay what for this witch hunt when we have white men stealing the country. Please its crazy....
Reply to this Comment | Report This