If you're like me, when you receive gift cards, you're likely to stow them away in your wallet, where they stay largely forgotten until those occasional times when cash flow gets tight. When I finally use one, I rarely remember who gave it to me.If you're like Baltimore Mayor Sheila Dixon, you use those suckers right away. That's what they're meant for, right?
Not so fast, say prosecutors in Dixon's criminal theft trial, which got under way on Nov. 13. They accuse the city's first female mayor of spending about 60 gift cards, worth roughly $1,500, on herself, when they were intended for needy families at Christmastime.
The question comes down to whether you believe the mayor is enough of a scrooge to deliberately steal groceries from the mouths of hungry residents -- yes, Giant (a grocery chain) gift cards are among those in question -- or if, like many of us, she simply failed to keep her gift cards straight.
"When you steal, you've committed a theft," state prosecutor Robert Rohrbaugh said in opening arguments. "When you steal, and you're a public servant, and you steal from the needy, it's unspeakable."
All Mixed Up in Love
Dixon's defense is that she mixed up the gift cards, which were donated by developer Patrick Turner, with ones that had been donated by her married ex-boyfriend, Ronald H. Lipscomb, to use as she pleased. Prosecutors must prove she intentionally stole the cards from needy families, say her attorneys.Lipscomb is expected to testify that his gift cards were indeed intended for the needy, and not his beloved, contrary to what the mayor's defense claims. (Lipscomb has since returned to his wife and is presumably showering her with groceries now.)
The gift cards, which were also from big-box chains such as Best Buy, Circuit City and Old Navy, were allegedly used by Dixon over a four-year period. A raid of her home turned up a $400 Xbox 360 game system, a $269 Samsung camcorder and an unopened DVD of the movie 'Four Brothers,' among other items. All the items are connected to store receipts and gift cards.
Everyone's Doing It
On Nov. 14, a number of city employees testified that it was common practice for holiday gift cards to come across their desks, too. According to the Baltimore Sun, the mayor's current boyfriend, housing department division chief Edward Anthony, told the court that he frequently receives retail gift cards that he then loses track of. During cross-examination by defense attorney Melissa Phinn, Anthony said, "Being a single man, I don't have the best organization. ... I have a lot of gift cards laying around." He also acknowledged that a gift card traced to Lipscomb was used in conjunction with his own Giant discount card.
Despite the controversy surrounding the trial, Dixon still appears to have a number of supporters. Community organizations and business groups, such as the Maryland Minority Contractors Association Inc., have reportedly packed the courtroom where the trial is taking place. They say she's been an effective mayor, and some of them suggest that a trial over such a small amount of money (we're not talking $90,000 cash stashed in the freezer, William Jefferson–style) is a racially or politically motivated attempt to take a good sister down.
Meanwhile, the mayor seems to be holding up reasonably well under the stress of the trial, notwithstanding (see the video above) the occasional flare-up. Trial testimony resumed today.
______________
Sheryl Huggins Salomon is contributing editor of Black Voices, where she writes about politics and society. She is co-editor of the 'Nia Guide for Black Women' series of self-improvement books and the former publisher of Shade magazine. Follow her on Twitter or contact her at BVCEditor@aol.com.


Comments: (15)
Add a comment
By: sharronda on 12/05/2009 10:03PM
I live in Baltimore Md. they are cutting jobs services and stealing the money. She did that sh*t. I think her and her whole administration needs to go. They cut jos and services( which I am sure lots of states are doing) Then they go behing closed doors and give them selves a raise. What kind of stuff is that? When the public finds out now they are going to give them back. But to charity. What is that other than a tax break! She was president of the city council when the schools money went missing. A crook from way back.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Maani on 11/25/2009 11:53PM
The Schools budget system and the City buget system are two completely different entities. The school budget system was a two fault issue. One, declining enrollent which means less revenues coming in; two poor budgetting on the part of the School officials. Nothing to do with the mayor or city council
Report This
By: Inisa on 11/21/2009 4:43PM
The Thinking Room. Created with the Black Intellectual In Mind. A place where you're free to discuss issues that effect you and the black community without the fear of being politically correct. This is a moderated site so PLEASE let's try to respect one another although we may share opposing views.
http://www.TheThinkingRoom.ning.com
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Tennis Player on 11/23/2009 8:16AM
From a human perspective: If she replaced the gift cards, the moment she learned of their source; then no harm, no foul.
From a legal perspective: If she knew of their source and used them; guilty. If she did not know of their source and used them, not guilty.
Generally, if you are a black politician; you should expect to go on trial for something during your political career. Is this because you are being treated differently from your white counterparts? Yes. Is it right? No. How to fix it? Prosecute everyone for clearly illegal behavior. The Alaskan politician comes to mind. When six figures worth of funds were an issue and he was allowed to resign with no legal charges made. When John Q Citizen hears of something like that and then a black politician going on trial (costing a lot of money) for a questionable $1500 transgression......
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: maani on 11/25/2009 11:56PM
Excellent point TP! I just could not understand how they could spend 4 years investigating someone and then take them to trial for $1500 in gift cards! Gift cards, something ain't right...
Even the former police chief stole what like $10k or something... I could understand that but gift cards...
Report This