I have always had a tremendous amount of respect for Tavis Smiley. There are few men in America with a greater commitment to the advancement of black people, and Tavis has been consistent when it comes to showing a great deal of focus on the issues that matter. I have critiqued Tavis in the past, and I have praised him. But that's my job as a scholar - to not see anything as completely good or bad. I am sure that my words are what kept me from being invited to the State of the Black Union Conference, but I have always been OK with that.
Smiley recently announced the end of his annual "State of the Black Union" event, and this saddened me. The SOBU was one of the most impactful gatherings of African-American minds in our nation's history. It inspired the nation and created openings for activism that didn't exist in other venues. Although I was never pleased by the presence of questionable entities like Wells Fargo, I still felt that the forum benefited our community.
In this video, which you can watch by clicking here, Tavis Smiley is surprisingly candid when providing explanations for his decision to end the State of the Black Union. He cites the growth in the blogosphere as well as an increase in the number of black syndicated radio shows. He then discusses that he is going to be doing some PBS specials in the near future. He even goes as far as describing the fact that his beard has a few extra gray hairs and that he's not getting any younger. The candor in the video is refreshing, and I respect him for putting it out.
The things that Tavis didn't mention were likely just as relevant: The difficulty of obtaining corporate sponsors during a recession and getting those sponsors to commit to someone who has lost some degree of popularity among the African-American community. Tavis' attacks on Barack Obama last year did not leave his career unscathed, as the entire black community (which I noticed from e-mails I received from supporters of our Your Black World Coalition) seemed to become angry that Tavis was not "drinking the Obama Kool-aid."
My conversations with friends have led me to conclude that in his critiques of the president, Tavis Smiley was on the "wrong side of right": He has been vindicated to some degree, given that Obama's black popularity has declined. But his close affiliations with Hillary Clinton led others to have a tremendous amount of skepticism regarding the nature and origin of the attacks. In other words, some wondered if Tavis, a man who plays hard in political circles, was angry about not being the next Barack Obama.
Either way, Tavis will remain a player in critical black social commentary. His connections with the State Department, through Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, are likely giving him the White House access he deserves, so I expect Tavis to remain relevant for many decades to come.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 


Comments: (16)
Add a comment
By: Marvice on 1/09/2010 5:48AM
Well, I didn't think much ever came from those meetings anyway. It's hard to move a movement if the people won't move. To come together and talk about the same ole thing year after year is frustrating to say the least. Sad to say but when the Blacks lost Martin Luther, we lost the drive and everything else we needed.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Everet on 1/09/2010 11:47AM
Sorry to hear that SOBU will not be continuing in that dialogue around issues that affect people of color deserve and require conversation. While I am reluctant but forced by the truth of Marvice's observations about the ineffectiveness of forum's like SOBU, Million Man March, Million Women's March, and the like to give way to "big ticket change", there are positive products that are perhaps less tangible. I remember the gleam in my Dad's eye and other brothers in the church as they prepared to leave for the Million Man March. We were drawn closer together as Father and son in ways which Marvice's stance (and not his alone) may deem valueless. I was treated to the pride, the love, the unity, the strength and a host of stories of my people through my Father's eye that I had never heard. They were tough to hear yet endearing and enriching because they came from him. I am thankful for that gleam in his eye as he celebrates his 79th birthday on this past January 8th. Our movement forward did not end with our nation's loss of Rev. Dr. ML King, but the product of his work continues to enhance who we are today and every tomorrow. We have not lost our drive, many of us have simply turned our attention to other things, bought in to the "me-first" element of capitalism, integrated more heavily into the majority society, etc. The future of a people are never bound in the fortune of one man, not even the angelic Dr. King. Our future is in the hands of every person who has a stake; me and you. But all the best to Tavis in whatever he does...love and respect him..the best to our people and all people in 2010
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: pam45 on 1/09/2010 12:23PM
Critical black social commentary is relevant and we have so many established Black resources within the mainstream. Almost every day there is commentary from Black resources on nationally televised shows on PBS, MSNBC, Fox News and other sources. The commentary is specific about the plight and success of Black Americans as it relates to the economy (jobs), housing and debt, politics, education, sports and the American dream. It was possibly a good thing that Tavis was able to have a national discussion with so many Black experts and produce and agenda for Black communities but the degree of frustration and anger was palpable. The agenda has helped give structure to efforts within those communities that are doing something. The anger and frustration needs to somehow be channeled into positive living experiences within more communities. We must be responsible and teach others to turn the tide of disrupted family life.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Everett on 1/09/2010 12:32PM
Yes, Pam, you've hit the nail on the head. I might add that it would be immensely helpful if politicians of color and their colleagues would stand for the betterment of all people rather than for those interests who promise them extraordinary influence and monetary gain.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Arnetta on 1/09/2010 7:48PM
To continue to outline the Problems without any solutions, we continue to yeild the same results. WE need to learn the truth. They will only teach "Western civilization" which dates back to ~1500 AD because they do not want us to know that
"BLACK MEN AND WOMEN RULED THE WORLD" They inhabited the world and they Ruled it also, until they taught the Europeans to speak, read, write, take a bath and to use a weapon, they had a weapon of their own that is diseases of which they were 99.% effective in their usage. They do not want us to learn that written civilization began in 3200 BC by a Pharaoh name Narmer or Menes from Kemet (Egypt). Please learn the TRUTH. There is a WEB site www.realworldhistoryww.com. The first world civilizations were all black civiliztions. They have the pictures to prove their point. Be not deceived African brothers and sister GOD is on our side. The truth is on its way. Hotep (peace).
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: sammy on 1/11/2010 5:35AM
And now so many of us have dropped out of high school, have no marketable skills, are unable to speak standard english, and not only destroy our own neighborhoods but wreck havoc across the cities and states in which we live.
Let's blame President Obama.
Report This
By: rasfanta on 1/10/2010 4:19PM
I am sorry to hear Tavis will not be doing the State of Black America anymore. I think it is the wrong time for him to do this as we need a forum to expose barak obama and hold him accountable. I did not hate on Tavis when he critized obama. He is right about him and his assessment was on point. I respect Tavis.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: sammy on 1/11/2010 5:28AM
Travis is ending the State of Black ____ fill in the blank because these conferences were a big waste of time.
They accomplished nothing but gave a bunch of blovaters a chance to get together on the WHITE corporate dime. No one who attended these conferences has any solutions or answers. They were not involved in the black communities they were claiming to represent.
White corporate America made Travis a "black leader", a role which he ultimately could not fill. Smiley let himself believe the hype of his corporate sponsors that he was/is the "new black leader". He did their bidding just as he did his jigging on the WHITE teevee shows to criticize the President.
Travis saw himself as the "black leader" who could hold the President accountable. What a laugh from someone who is NOT of any significant stature or qualification to hold anyone accountable, much less President Obama. He, along with some of the so-called scholars/intellectuals, chooses to pimp themselves for THEIR OWN BENEFIT.
Know of any mentoring programs any of them created in the black community? Tutoring programs? Scholorship programs? Job training programs?
Of course not.
The attendees at the State of Black ____ (fill in the blank) couldn't find a black community if a map of a black community outlined in red markers were pasted to their noses.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Thedora Davitt-Cornyn on 1/20/2010 3:14AM
As a Caucasian woman needing to be better informed, I always looked forward to the State of the Black Union programming each year when it was televised live over a period of several days on C-SPAN. That was a great public service, and will be sorely missed (and it didn't require any sponsors, either!).
Now that he will have some spare time, perhaps Tavis Smiley might help to organize that national conversation on race in America which is so needed.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: gotluv4myblackpeople on 2/03/2010 1:34PM
I am sad also to hear that Tavis won't be doing the State of the Black Union anymore. It was a real and very rare chance to see and hear a host of "other" up & coming black leaders - those that may not be getting the attention of media otherwise. And hear what they and those they know are doing to help uplift their folks.
However, I do agree that it mostly was frustrating to watch year after year because it seemed that not much action and followup was accomplished as a result. I believe they tried doing some followup with the books that got published.
But let's face it: most blacks are so busy just trying to survive (i.e. the have-nots) or so consumed with getting all they can get (i.e. the haves), that they don't "have" the desire to organize to uplift the whole community.
"Feeling powerless" comes to mind...
Reply to this Comment | Report This