MSNBC analyst Chris Matthews, apparently in celebration of the fact that he believes we now have a "post-racial America," felt the need to congratulate President Barack Obama on his State of the Union Address by proudly claiming that he "forgot Obama was black for an hour."
The comments were made shortly after the State of the Union Address ended last night.
I am not sure where Chris Matthews was coming from with these comments. To some extent, his remarks were shocking, and I wasn't exactly sure why they shocked me until I'd had a chance to sleep on it. During my rest, I realized that Chris Matthews' words were hurtful and irritating because they represent the kind of paternalistic racism that might come from liberals in an historically racist society. With his words, Matthews was practically applauding Obama for rising above his blackness, as if merely mentioning the words, "I am a black man," would have completely ruined Obama's brilliant speech. No one asked Matthews what he thought about the fact that the president was black, so Matthews going out of his way to mention Obama's blackness is a reminder that Matthews himself was focused on the fact that he was listening to a black man.
It's odd and interesting that in a so-called "post-racial society," the way to applaud the fact that you didn't notice something is to mention the very thing that you're claiming to not have noticed. If Matthews had been truly unaware that he was listening to a black man, he would have spent his time commenting on Obama's policies rather than the color of his skin. To be relieved that President Obama did not force you to notice that he is black is a subtle reminder of the implicit threat of putting blackness on the table for even one second during political conversation.
A note to other liberals like Chris Matthews: Please stop saying that a post-racial America means that blackness disappears. While I can't speak for everyone, I can personally say that I don't want the beauty of blackness to go away. Instead, I would rather have blackness be respected. Also, the easiest way to bring the racial roaches out of the closet is to keep declaring your nation to be "post-racial." America is nowhere near being post-racial and nor would we want to be. What's most interesting is that not only are we driving to the wrong racial destination, we don't even know how to get there. By constantly forcing all Americans to forget about race, we are only asking them repress the obvious from their collective psyches.
Chris Matthews attempts to clarify his comments here:
"I grew up in a country that was driven apart by race right until the '60s. You couldn't have a black member of the U.S. Cabinet. There were no black cabinet members in the Kennedy administration. It has been such a big part of our life.... To see a president of the United States who is African Amercan, I was thinking tonight, this isn't even an issue tonight. How far we've come in just a year.... President Obama has done something wonderful. I thing he's taken us beyond black and white in our politics...and I'm loving it."
Personally, I argue that a post-racial America is not one where blackness is expected to disappear in an ambiguous melting pot of watered down assimilation. It is one where the president can say, "I am proud to be a black man," and not have white people run for the door.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 


Comments: (2176)
Add a comment
By: alk on 1/28/2010 9:09PM
JUST AS VENEZUELAN CHAVEZ HE IS NOW CRITICIZING THE JUDICIAL POWER DESICIONS INSTEAD OF RESPECT IT ...AS ANY OTHER COMMUNIST HE GETS MAD IF HAVE COMPETENCY, NOW THAT NOT ONLY THE GOVERNMENT HAVE AL THE POWER AND THE BILLIONS TO SUBMIT OUR COUNTRY INTO HIS ABSOLUTE CONTROL...
Report This
By: Carolyn Martinez on 1/28/2010 9:47PM
I was married to a "black" man from the Dominican Republic for 39 years until his death. We have 4 children. I am "white" so to speak, but actually it will be HEAVEN when NO ONE notices "black" or White or Yellow or any color that separates us. There is no true BLACK or WHITE so forget about it and get on with reality and life. That means he saw a man without any color just an intelligent person. Why do we insist on underlining our differences, what good does that really do?
Report This
By: Nick Neanderthal on 1/28/2010 9:34PM
Matthews is a total fool.
It is always the "liberals" who are obsessed about race, because they project their racism onto anyone who does not think like they do. That would be folks who believe in the Constitution instead of ruling by emotion, and being always obsessed with race as CM apparently is.
That Matthews works in what is jokingly called journalism speaks much about how low this business has sunk.
Report This
By: rick on 1/28/2010 10:27PM
what an idiotic comment. the senator has laid out his agenda on a routine basis for the past 30 years. you need to clean out the wax in your ears. he never said i have a secret idea, what he said was all the things that i have been advocating since being in the senate are not being followed with the leadership currently.
you are blinded by the talking points of the irresponsible press who are emplyees of the democratic party. you might as well join the Nazi or ba'ath party!
Report This
By: Harrison on 1/28/2010 9:30PM
"I have many friends for whom, when someone comments on the color of their skin, I have to stop and think, and then realize, yeah, I guess he is [whatever color the skin]."
If that's the case then it's not because you are "color-blind" or whatever, you're just slow or losing your memory/mind. You know your black friend is black and your white friend is white, or they really aren't your friend. That being true doesn't make you a racist however, it's just something to identify the person by (like "hey you know Chris the short, bald, white guy, or my friend Steve the fat, black guy with a buzz cut, or even Jill the tall brunette with olive skin) and something they wouldn't mind. So cut the crap, you don't have to stop and think about the color of your friends skin because its just another way we can describe someone and remember them by. If it's true then I would never want you as key witness in any trial ever.
Report This
By: john on 1/28/2010 9:35PM
As I should than be able to say that I am a proud white man.....black entertainment television as well as white entertainment television
Report This
By: Michael on 1/28/2010 9:55PM
What?
Report This
By: Ronald Anderson on 1/28/2010 10:08PM
because he is still a member of the Senate And his oppinion still matters, He is by the way still represents the people
Report This
By: mat on 1/28/2010 9:59PM
Obama, Pelosy and Reid are either in complete denial or they just simply don't care about the American people that they are supposedly serving. Obama continues to blame the Bush administration, his ego won't let him reflect on his mistakes and he continues to make irresponsible, naive and senseless decisions that are taking our country in the wrong direction. I hope that we don't sink too much during his remaining 3 years. Hopefully the people who voted for him last time, will make a better choice next time.
Report This
By: Justin on 1/28/2010 10:18PM
Couldn't you find anything else to write about? He meant Obama is not a president defined by his color. It was a compliment, and intelligent people know what he meant. I know you did too.
If you over-think anything it can become racist. By bringing this up, you are just inciting anger among people who are sick and tired of being on the defensive because of idiots like you. Most of the white media lives in fear of Al Sharpton and the rest of the oversensitive black leadership. It is stunting dialogue that this country is in desperate need of.
Matthews is an intellectual and frequently struggles to express his thoughts articulately. He is far from racist. There are plenty of actual racists on television. Do your job and write about them!
Report This