MSNBC analyst Chris Matthews, apparently in celebration of the fact that he believes we now have a "post-racial America," felt the need to congratulate President Barack Obama on his State of the Union Address by proudly claiming that he "forgot Obama was black for an hour."
The comments were made shortly after the State of the Union Address ended last night.
I am not sure where Chris Matthews was coming from with these comments. To some extent, his remarks were shocking, and I wasn't exactly sure why they shocked me until I'd had a chance to sleep on it. During my rest, I realized that Chris Matthews' words were hurtful and irritating because they represent the kind of paternalistic racism that might come from liberals in an historically racist society. With his words, Matthews was practically applauding Obama for rising above his blackness, as if merely mentioning the words, "I am a black man," would have completely ruined Obama's brilliant speech. No one asked Matthews what he thought about the fact that the president was black, so Matthews going out of his way to mention Obama's blackness is a reminder that Matthews himself was focused on the fact that he was listening to a black man.
It's odd and interesting that in a so-called "post-racial society," the way to applaud the fact that you didn't notice something is to mention the very thing that you're claiming to not have noticed. If Matthews had been truly unaware that he was listening to a black man, he would have spent his time commenting on Obama's policies rather than the color of his skin. To be relieved that President Obama did not force you to notice that he is black is a subtle reminder of the implicit threat of putting blackness on the table for even one second during political conversation.
A note to other liberals like Chris Matthews: Please stop saying that a post-racial America means that blackness disappears. While I can't speak for everyone, I can personally say that I don't want the beauty of blackness to go away. Instead, I would rather have blackness be respected. Also, the easiest way to bring the racial roaches out of the closet is to keep declaring your nation to be "post-racial." America is nowhere near being post-racial and nor would we want to be. What's most interesting is that not only are we driving to the wrong racial destination, we don't even know how to get there. By constantly forcing all Americans to forget about race, we are only asking them repress the obvious from their collective psyches.
Chris Matthews attempts to clarify his comments here:
"I grew up in a country that was driven apart by race right until the '60s. You couldn't have a black member of the U.S. Cabinet. There were no black cabinet members in the Kennedy administration. It has been such a big part of our life.... To see a president of the United States who is African Amercan, I was thinking tonight, this isn't even an issue tonight. How far we've come in just a year.... President Obama has done something wonderful. I thing he's taken us beyond black and white in our politics...and I'm loving it."
Personally, I argue that a post-racial America is not one where blackness is expected to disappear in an ambiguous melting pot of watered down assimilation. It is one where the president can say, "I am proud to be a black man," and not have white people run for the door.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 


Comments: (2176)
Add a comment
By: JMH on 2/02/2010 9:32AM
Why FedEx needs a UNION!!!
GO to YouTube, search word: FedEx Inhumane Treatment.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YnbcCV2KI4
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: it'scallledswag on 2/02/2010 7:54PM
come-on cris mr.obama is bl.& white,surly you get it,why could not u just say it.."that man is bad"you tryed didn't come out right,just say it he's got Swag,unlike you have ever seen,cause none of them white dudes did, at least not in the open.thanks chris your gettin there,a-man-with-a-heart(sometime).
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Majaris on 2/03/2010 8:39AM
All this talk about racism is bull...think about it this way...if every human being on earth had the same pigment color, make it red. then each would have some other point of disagreement, of being too tall, or too short or too fat, or stupid, or too red...it is human nature; it means everyone can and will live together and can function as human beings, but no one will ever be free of human character traits...what I find ludicris, to quote mike tyson, lol...is that people are so fake to taut political correctness over truth of a persons qualities and more evidently appauling is the darker whites also referred to the blacks or browns or whatever you like,,constantly taut commentary of color, between themselves and also directed at the lighter shades also knw as whites and white dudes as above...people can accept each other for who and what they are, is color really that significant, I think its the least of everything, and other than a scapgoat bull. I can be black or maybe white, take a guess if you are so obsessed...but one thing I know from research the origins of things, I never owned a slave of any color, but interesting fact is that before anyone reached the coasts of africa, the local populous, natives were all of a darker complexion, and in their disputes and battles, they would enslave each other...so ask yourself what was the basis of it? Obviously not color, and if you study human history...every group of every color has been a salve to another at some time, with no color impact...a product of dysfunctional human nature...so for me if someone calls me a junglebuny or a cracker, whatever man, I applaud your free speach, and I dont need a crutch. And I dont care, you take it from the source. And the idea of racist thought exists in all communities of every color and shape and form. So lets get over it. And as far as Barack Obama, I voted for him, not to prove a point, and not because he was black or white, but he was a good speaker...unfortunately it seems that was his only ability so far, and I am disappointed, by his lack of anything else. If you disagree, then review him with a blindfold on, and remove your personal ideas and prejudices first, and you will realize that talk is cheap and there is nothing more than an empty suit. Hopefully the next holder of the office can bring hope and change that he believes in himself, for the country and not just himself.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: AJ2010 on 2/04/2010 12:56PM
Wow this site is totally taken over by obviously racist, Republican trolls who are trying to exploit this gaffe as "proof" that Republicans aren't racist, "Liberals", as they put it, are. Really? Whatever happened to "content of their character"? It's one thing to acknowledge differences but I think the idea of post-racial is actually that we don't divide and discriminate based on race, that we judge based on content of character. We are far from post-racial that is for sure. But if any of you think the Republicans are anywhere near for civil rights and aren't fit to be tied over their threatened white privilege, you really need to step back and look at that assumption. What is the unemployment rate of minorities? Who was equating the poor with stray animals? The problem is we're dividing based on race when the majority of Americans are poor and ruled by the few, white elites who don't want us to join up and rise up against them. They want to keep taking our money, owning the means of production, and keep the poor as slaves for years to come. We've allowed them to destroy all the social organizations that actually spoke for us and now they continue to divide us with distractions over words. Do you accept others of a different skin color? If so, don't worry about it keep living. If you look at someone and prejudge them based on their skin color, you have some inner work to do to fix that. You can't legislate people's hearts and when the old people of this generation die and our children grow up it will be much better, problem is both sides of the aisle "black and white" clown on each other all the time with stereotypes that we pass on to our kids. Just as "being black" is bad so is "being white", as if education is a bad thing although education is the biggest weapon against poverty. Get beyond the words and start looking at actions, who controls your destiny? What group are you really a part of? I know I'm poor and I'd rather link up with other poor people of all colors to fight back against the plutocracy that has taken over this country.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: butchcrews on 2/07/2010 1:01AM
If you study history you'll find that the plutocracy has always ruled, using using one gimmick or another to divide and conquer the ignorant. Since nature allows only two percent of any given population at any given time to possess creative abilty, then only two percent will ever be at the top. One may cry all they will, however, it will always be futile, for this is Nature's decree. This law applies to the entire spectrum of life forms. To affect opposition to this axiom requires the ability to deanthropomorphicize the axiom. As long as it is a human being attempting this endeavor, it will be analogous to one attempting to walk while stepping on it's own feet.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: butchcrews on 2/11/2010 12:47AM
When we refer to the ruling class, the entire globe must be a part of this equation. Remember, the U.N., the Bildebergers and the Trilateral Commission control this ball of dirt and water we call Earth. This group of people consist of 1/1000% of the Earth's population. They pass directives to the 2% who we see allegedly, in possession of wealth. The group at the top, ( the Bildebergers ) are a MULTITUDE of races, representative of the entire global population.
Reply to this Comment | Report This