
I'm all for showing Black and Latina women who do not fit the traditional stereotype of being beautiful. I also support the rights of artists to be creative and interpretive. The mural at Times Square in New York City, though, misses the mark on both fronts.
Instead of showing the "non-traditional" beauty of Black, Latina and Caribbean women, I see two women on a couch who look like prostitutes. One has on hooker-type boots, with big gold doorknocker earrings and saggy breasts. The other, wearing a purple dress, is bent over and looks like she's "dropping it like it's hot" for a Lil' Wayne video. These images are anything but empowering. They represent the worst stereotypes about Black and Latina women.
"I want to recognize that these women, especially Caribbean women, dress like this and they should be respected in society the same way women with, like, briefcases or cell phones [are]," the artist Sofia Maldonado told My Fox New York.
Unfortunately, she has failed with the two images that I saw."What I want to see is something that motivates me, that makes me want to be more than what I am. When I look at these pictures, do I reaaly want to be this when I grow up?" Carmine Cologne, an engineer, told My Fox NewYork.
Other women agree. New York City Black Professionals and Phenomenal Women Group Inc. have staged a small protest and called for the head of the Times Square Alliance to remove the mural.
Another image of a young girl riding a skateboard doesn't seem as bad but the young lady depicted is fully clothed. Black and Latina women already face the stereotype that they are loud, over-sexualized beings with nothing but attitude and sharp head movements for anyone who even looks at them for too long.
Images that would have broken the stereotype are ones that I see in my Harlem neighborhood every day.
I see women dressed professionally heading to work.
I see women in medical scrubs and white jackets heading to Harlem hospital.
I see home health aides caring for our sick and elderly parents and grandparents.
I see women walking their children to school.
I see a Black woman police officer in a crisp blue uniform.
I see women entrepreneurs who own restaurants, salons and flower shops.
I see a Black woman lawyer with her own small practice.
I see a female token booth clerk.
These women are the backbone of the Black and Latino communities. With too many men shirking their responsibilities as husbands and fathers, Black and Latina women have filled the void.
These are the images I see in my diverse neighborhood. I'm not sure what Maldonado is looking at.


Comments: (144)
Add a comment
By: jean on 3/22/2010 11:52AM
Get real lady. You're not trying to depict a strongness of Black Women nor Latina Women, It shows how much disrespect you have for them. You should have placed yourself up there in all those demeaning poses. Some countries would spit on you, stone you, even whip you in public. You may be an up and coming artist but, If I ever where to see your work, you best believe I would not under so circumstances what do ever support a person such as you.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Tom H on 3/24/2010 11:50AM
WAH!Get a life people...
Report This
By: jean on 3/22/2010 11:59AM
Get real lady. You're not trying to depict a strongness of Black Women nor Latina Women, It shows how much disrespect you have for them. You should have placed yourself up there in all those demeaning poses. Some countries would spit on you, stone you, even whip you in public. You may be an up and coming artist but, If I ever were to see your work, you best believe I would not under so circumstances what so ever support a person such as youself and would encourage others to do the same.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: jean on 3/22/2010 8:15PM
Chanel it matters not if she's Latino, Black, Asian, Indian, white ect. the point is this mural really does disrespect women. And as far as I'm concern the dope spoke and condoned the so call joke of this artist. Who is she mad at? Her race or the other race?
Report This
By: focused1 on 3/23/2010 9:01AM
I'm a brutha who grew-up in NY (I'm still here in Brooklyn). I'm 35 now and when I first saw this mural, I had a flashback to 1988. Hooker boots? Big gold earrings? Umm, it is 2010, right? You might have seen a few sisters/mamis walking around, looking like that in the 80's, but not NOW, in 2010. The mural is tacky, disrespectful and, like "E" said, should be painted over.
Report This
By: Melissa on 3/24/2010 11:36AM
I'm sorry... why exactly is that considered a latin woman?... she's white and has blond hair... I think this writer is only seeing what she wants to see... I'm a latina from nyc... and the first thing that i thought when i saw this was not that it was offensive to blacks and hispanics but rather that the artist had no real talent
Report This
By: kermit on 3/25/2010 11:12PM
Perhaps the artist depicted reality as she knows it. Why are you so against her showing her true emotions, and feelings in her work, It's not about you. Her portrayal of her reality is her business. Times square paid for it, they must like it.
Report This
By: E on 3/22/2010 12:11PM
Maybe in the 80's would this mural fly. But in the past 20 years, women's, especially women of color, mentality, economic, and educational status' have risen TREMENDOUSLY! This mural is a past reflection on some black women. But definitely not today's. Please paint over it!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: HI JACK on 3/24/2010 12:29PM
Hey, walk down Times Square and take a good look look around at the people you normally "DON'T SEE"... I'd like to think the artist was trying to shame the low-lifes into cleaning up their acts, but they're either too cracked-up or just plain stupid to see themselves in that mural. (Kinda like ginormous fat chicks in spandex, ya know?)Life goes on for the rest of us, and FOR NOW, so does freedom of expression. I say the mural should stay.
Report This
By: Al on 3/22/2010 1:37PM
This is disturbing, but we need to look in the mirror. We condone these stereotypes in music videos and on the record and support this bull through our pockets and some of us live these stereotypes (or try to) every day. Why would we be offended? We are always offended (We because I am African American) when someone (non black) decides to make note of how we feel, think and what we support for the worst. What, if no one writes a book, makes a racial comment, paints a mural or mocks these values it's all good? We need to have an issue with these stereotypes whether they are exploited or not.
The fact is that the big ear rings, boots along with a bad attitude (which one does not experience by looking at the mural) is real with some black women, though not all. This goes with some white women as well and dropping it like it’s hot applies to all races as well, so why bother being offended?
Reply to this Comment | Report This