
I'm all for showing Black and Latina women who do not fit the traditional stereotype of being beautiful. I also support the rights of artists to be creative and interpretive. The mural at Times Square in New York City, though, misses the mark on both fronts.
Instead of showing the "non-traditional" beauty of Black, Latina and Caribbean women, I see two women on a couch who look like prostitutes. One has on hooker-type boots, with big gold doorknocker earrings and saggy breasts. The other, wearing a purple dress, is bent over and looks like she's "dropping it like it's hot" for a Lil' Wayne video. These images are anything but empowering. They represent the worst stereotypes about Black and Latina women.
"I want to recognize that these women, especially Caribbean women, dress like this and they should be respected in society the same way women with, like, briefcases or cell phones [are]," the artist Sofia Maldonado told My Fox New York.
Unfortunately, she has failed with the two images that I saw."What I want to see is something that motivates me, that makes me want to be more than what I am. When I look at these pictures, do I reaaly want to be this when I grow up?" Carmine Cologne, an engineer, told My Fox NewYork.
Other women agree. New York City Black Professionals and Phenomenal Women Group Inc. have staged a small protest and called for the head of the Times Square Alliance to remove the mural.
Another image of a young girl riding a skateboard doesn't seem as bad but the young lady depicted is fully clothed. Black and Latina women already face the stereotype that they are loud, over-sexualized beings with nothing but attitude and sharp head movements for anyone who even looks at them for too long.
Images that would have broken the stereotype are ones that I see in my Harlem neighborhood every day.
I see women dressed professionally heading to work.
I see women in medical scrubs and white jackets heading to Harlem hospital.
I see home health aides caring for our sick and elderly parents and grandparents.
I see women walking their children to school.
I see a Black woman police officer in a crisp blue uniform.
I see women entrepreneurs who own restaurants, salons and flower shops.
I see a Black woman lawyer with her own small practice.
I see a female token booth clerk.
These women are the backbone of the Black and Latino communities. With too many men shirking their responsibilities as husbands and fathers, Black and Latina women have filled the void.
These are the images I see in my diverse neighborhood. I'm not sure what Maldonado is looking at.


Comments: (144)
Add a comment
By: SUNSHINE on 3/23/2010 5:05PM
This mural is ugly! And we will not accept this as art.. I'm a black latina and this upsets me..
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Jerry Chambers on 3/23/2010 5:15PM
It's people like you who walk through life with their eyes wide shut.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Gary on 3/23/2010 5:16PM
"WHO IN THE HELL IS YOU KIDDING? This is the way Afro-American, Caribbeans, and Latinos women love to dress-up when going to work or out to par-tay.
For example: Let us take a look at all the old and new showa on cable/television. The Game, Girlfriends, My Wife and Kids. (Especially My Wife and Kids the young lady that plays Claire). The producer of the show should have never play as an un-positive character like the one she is playing.
That is: STUCK ON HERSELF. Disagree with me??? Moving on, The Cosby Show had an opinion to itself although, the characters that Bill Cosby and Phylicia Rashad played was a bit over dramatical.
To me, positive women do not have to wear flashy outfits and short skirts. A positive female is the one who looks good in whatever situation she's in.
Still females of this world have a problem when it comes to political arts or world situation. That is called to much pride. And that will kill you in the short run. That person did nothing but drew art on the wall. And people of the earth still cannot withdraw from critizing everything has: hatred, denial, racist, and deflle.
SHAMEFUL!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Kristina Newman-Scott on 3/23/2010 5:17PM
Last summer, I had the pleasure of working with Sofia Maldonado as part of Real Public, four public art projects commissioned by Real Art Ways in Hartford, Connecticut. Sofia created a mural on the façade of the Pelican Tattoo building in the Frog Hollow neighborhood titled Hey Shorty! Tu tienes novio? (Do you have a boyfriend?). The mural’s intent was to portray the rural and floral landscapes of Puerto Rico and Latin America while celebrating the diversity of the women in the community. She thought of this project as a way to revive the female attitude towards life, youth, motherhood, and community recreation.
Frog Hollow is a predominantly Puerto Rican neighborhood. Before creating her mural, Sofia spent over a month in the community meeting with residents and local business people. She invited women from the Lily Nail Salon to adorn the exaggerated nails on her wooden cutouts before they were installed on the Pelican Tattoo building. There was such excitement about her project in the community. Many of the residents and business owners would come outside to watch her as she worked. Her work truly exemplified community spirit. Within this community, the mural’s depiction of women was a non-issue.
For Sofia’s mural to evoke such a negative response in a place like New York City where diversity is celebrated is surprising and disappointing. Sofia’s work is not limited by mainstream expectations of positive representations of women, but instead reaches deep into communities to find strong women who DON’T conform to those stereotypes.
I commend the Times Square Alliance for their support of Sofia’s work. Organizations such as these ensure that artists can stay true to their intentions and express their ideas in unexpected, sometimes controversial ways.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Shay on 3/25/2010 8:42PM
I wonder how much you got paid to write this garbage. You know like I know that the mural is trash. Like I said earlier, why do the women have their legs open, why are they bent over, why do they look drunk or hungover. They don't look like women with "a strong spirit". They look used and abused, tired and worn out. These pictures are not role models and they show the worst women in the community. Sofia Maldonado should be ashamed of herself. Sell-Out!
Report This
By: 3 on 3/23/2010 7:42PM
Wether she's latina or not, she's using her creativity to depict images that she sees. I see them too,(tv is mostly the predator) but as a woman I'm not about to promote that as a positive image for ANY woman.
Consider why the media and other enteratinment outlets are persistent in perpetuating these falsehoods. In my opinion, its because it makes white men money, horny,over sex'd boys like to see it, and it's a mechanism to devalue and depreciate people of color. Maldonado is falling right into the trap! Women, have enough things working against us, to have this chick display this negative image. What's she's done has just drawn more negative publicity for women of color. Why couldn't she paint us more regal? Ya know, Queens and Kings in the middle of Times Square.
That would've made a difference. Why not paint pics of gold-digging white women on all fours giving oral to a greedy, old, racist politician, with singles in her G-string...LOL
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kim on 3/23/2010 6:10PM
I don't live in NYC so I haven't personally viewed the mural first hand, but from the pics on all the blogs it seems these women are posing on Dr. Seuss characters. (???) I'm more disturbed of this as I am the stereotypical route the artists took to depict women of color. I hope that she is sincere in her rationale of the mural but its difficult to relate with her elation towards the painting and how she felt it would be a positive image of us (women of color). I wonder why she chose to pair her negative depictions with Dr. Seuss characters, was it to add color (no pun intended) or draw reference to women of color as being inhumane or "strange fruits" to this 'conventional' world of OURS...hmmmm....
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Benita on 3/23/2010 7:13PM
sorry, but recently i made my first trip in a LONG time to upper Amsterdam Avenue and that is ALL i saw, size 14's squeezed into size 7's with totally undeserved attitude stutting down the street in ridiculously inappropriate high heels. And they were headed into the nail salons to have three inch talons painted in neon colors.... all of which i THOUGHT had gone out with the 80's!! this artist (Latina, i might add?) seems to depict what she sees, and yes, i agree with Dante... they look like Brain Surgeons compared to some of the mess you see in rap videos and in Spanish Harlem, etc
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Miss KeKe Smith on 3/23/2010 9:05PM
That mural was nothing but disgusting. As a Black woman, I am shocked and appalled by it. Maybe some Latina and Black women actually DO look like this, but I really do not believe that the artist was trying to convey a positive message. You know how some people throw red paint on real fur coats? Well, I would throw any color paint on that mural just to get it off the wall. Come to think of it that's just what that mural is...Off the Wall.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Michael on 3/24/2010 6:59PM
This is the way the artist decided to paint her painting. This is her artistic expression. I took art both in undergraduate and graduate school. In college I learned that many artists have different ways of expressing what they trying to portray. She has a brownish orange back ground. Those are fall colors. This is laid back time of the year when the weather begins to cool. The woman in the purple dress seems to be extremely tired and the black woman is up but she seems like she has had a long day. Both of the women in these painting are tired. My personal view is this painting means the struggle of Latino woman and African American woman are encountering in every day life. The African American woman is standing at the end of the day but the Latino woman can not stand. She is saying that the African American woman has it better in life than the Latino woman. They both are standing on a couch that is soft. That is not a good foundation. The artist is saying that that there foundation is weak and not on the floor. The green couch means money. They both are struggling to make money in this economy. Someone else can look at the painting and it might mean something else to them.
Remember the Fat Albert Cartoon that is the way that Bill Cosby decided to portray the inner cities African American youths. There is non thing degrading about the painting it’s just how the artist decide to portray the painting.
Reply to this Comment | Report This