Rev. Sharpton has chosen to work more directly with President Obama, which is in contrast to the approach of Tavis Smiley, who held a forum in Chicago that was more critical of the president. Smiley isn't alone in his critique of Obama, as he was joined by Dr. Cornel West, Dr. Michael Eric Dyson, Dr. Julianne Malveaux, Min. Louis Farrakhan and Rev. Jesse Jackson. The conversation came to a head during a heated debate between Sharpton and Smiley on the radio, which led to questions about how black leadership can or should work with the first African American president. Rev. Sharpton feels that his meeting with President Obama last month communicates that the president is supportive of a black agenda.
"To meet about black unemployment is a black agenda unless you feel the black unemployed don't count," Sharpton told theGrio, in reference to his meeting last month with President Obama. "You can't get a blacker agenda to me..."
"[It's] a difference between being in the press box, being in the fancy suites at a football game and being down on the field," said Marc Morial, president of the National Urban League. "And I think where I am, where Rev. Sharpton is, is down on the field helping to move the ball forward [for African-Americans]."
I've thought long and hard about this divide among African American public figures regarding how to manage the work of President Barack Obama. My bias is probably revealed by the fact that I chose not to attend the Smiley forum in Chicago, but I will be on a panel at The Black Leadership forum hosted by Rev. Al Sharpton in New York City between April 14 - 17th. The decision was difficult, given that I have very productive relationships with Rev. Jesse Jackson, Cornel West, Michael Eric Dyson and Julianne Malveaux, but I cannot sign off on Tavis Smiley's determination to undermine the efforts of President Obama. The difficulty of this decision was compounded by the fact that I've written dozens of articles that have been critical of Obama. At the same time, I give him credit where it is due - he is doing a better job than any president in recent history.
It appears that Tavis Smiley simply doesn't want Barack Obama to be president at all. He is a long-time supporter of Hillary Clinton, and was likely cornered by Clinton into leveraging all of his political capital on the chance that she would be able to defeat Obama in the Democratic primary. When Obama emerged victorious, Smiley then had no incentive to do anything other than undermine Obama's power, given that Obama has no use for Tavis Smiley as a liaison to the African American community (Obama makes it clear in his actions that he doesn't support his enemies unless he has to). It is my conclusion that there is almost nothing that President Obama could do (other than resign) that will make Tavis Smiley support him.
But what's also true is that this "good-cop/bad-cop" approach to Obama might be more effective than what we've had thus far. Obama-mania is never good for black America, given that politicians with unconditionally loyal constituents have little incentive to serve the needs of those who love them the most. Vocal critics in the black community keep Obama on edge and force him to prove that he is loyal to black America, thus making him more willing to work with Sharpton, Jealous and Morial. So, at the end of the day, while Smiley and Sharpton may not be the best of friends, they are actually proving to be effective teammates.
With that said, almost none of those who chose to appear at the Smiley forum in Chicago are scheduled to appear with Sharpton in New York. As of today, confirmed guests are Tom Joyner, Roland Martin, Marc Morial, Ben Jealous, Charles Ogletree, Judge Greg Mathis, HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, and yours truly. I am not completely sure what to expect at this forum, but one thing I like is that the focus is going to be on action.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and the author of the new book, "Black American Money." To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 


Comments: (11)
Add a comment
By: Tony on 3/24/2010 4:37PM
Talk, talk, talk and more talk. That's all we ever get from these so-called Black leaders/spokespersons, while our daily lives simply dissipate between their every syllabic utterance. Nothing ever changes for Blacks as a result of all these talks, conferences, forums and shows. SAD!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: UD on 3/24/2010 10:10PM
You are so right. All talk no Corporate throw-downs.
Report This
By: rik on 3/25/2010 3:42PM
The Black Leadership forum hosted by Rev. Al Sharpton in New York City between April 14 - 17th.
lololololol. Who gives a crap. I don't know who da hell appointed you cats to leadership, all you do is talk and profit off the misery of others.
Tavis smiley has a point. He refuses to wait, and has the nerve to demand action.
Report This
By: VL on 4/02/2010 11:46AM
Tony is absolutely correct.
Criticisms are launched at the President but not one of these "talking heads" has offered a single workable solution. Correct me if I am wrong.
My challenge to each is to develop solutions; stop feeding egos and the push to remain in the limelight as someone who is indispensable for the continued existence and success of Black America and Planet Earth. Egos and self-importance are not helping the Black community.
A major solution is to WORK and SPEND TIME with young people so they stay in school and EARN, at least, a high school diploma. Find a way to help them improve their academic/intellectual lot even as too many attend incredibly dysfunctional schools. Dropouts will not make substantive contributions even if the economy ballooned this moment to the greatest heights imaginable and remained there.
Another solution is REAL work (roll up your CARING sleeves) to reduce drugs and violence, both of which are ultra-pervasive in all communities, most especially the Black community. Move into those communities. Make your positive presence known.
The bottom line is that these incessant "bell clappers" should go into the Black community to WORK rather than continuing to seek national notoriety as the Black Leaders as if we are so stupid that we actually need what they have to offer. Remember the President's work on the Southside of Chicago when he could have elected to work in almost any of the country's most prestigious law firms based on HIS achievements.
They should take solutions-based talk and plans to corporate America for funds to help Black America, rather continuing to engage in this stale non-productive non-constructive rhetoric. Help community activists and organizers get grant and other funding to carry out their solutions-based work. But, of course, that does not bring the level of prestige that is sought so intensely.
Mr. Obama is President of the entire United States of America with all of its warts, infestations, good points, bad points, silly and ignorant people, people who are doing more work than talk and vice versa -- the whole lot. The talking heads should try walking in the President’s moccasins for one nanosecond considering all that he inherited and all the stuff that has surfaced since he arrived at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. Not ONE of the “talkers” could have accomplished as much, certainly not more, in a one-year period given all the opposition he has faced. Fortunately Mr. Obama is acting on his “talk.”
Another bottom line is that everyone needs to put her/his brain and brawn to the grindstone and bury the egos and rhetoric. Be part of the solution and not the ever-mounting problem. Talk is real cheap and is extremely worthless when misdirected.
Report This
By: PECKER on 3/24/2010 9:40PM
There shouldn't be anything abt black unemployment. It's just unemployment in general. Everyone needs help in this critical time. All we hear is help "black america"...we need to help other races too! Blacks aren't the only ppl that need help. Where's the help for everyone else?!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Lil on 3/27/2010 6:22PM
There shoud be talk about Black unemployment since Blacks are at the bottom of the heap--the last hired and the first fired. Whites and other people with less pigment don't need to complain bcause they are given privilege in a white racist world culture. It is possible that the unemployment count does not even include Black people. Statistics are designed to lie.
Report This
By: lefiest on 3/27/2010 11:38AM
Testing
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: LAZARO JAVIER GARCIA on 3/28/2010 12:58AM
Your Comment:
I support 100% President Obama. The old mentality of Rev. Jesse Jackson and even Rev. Al Sharpton that we need a black agenda it is very dangerous for President Obama, because he is dealing with all
kind of people and the fact that we have today racism in America, the fact that we have intelectual prejudice in America, the fact that still some white people in America they are not open to believe in what it mean integration, the fact that some Afro American people they are
embracing racism, for me as Latino, that it is totally wrong.
I don't care what kind of tools some white people racists are ussing every day to force me to believe that racism it is ok. For me Racism, and Prejudice, it is not OK.
I never going to use the same tools that the racists people were ussing here in the past, present or future. I think that it is the legacy of
Rev. Martin Luther King and President Obama. Live believing today that we can open another University in California for the Afro American people because some white people there they are racists, it is go back to the mentality that racism is wining again in our society when what we need to do it is fight back with dialoge and keep strong position that we are not racists, and we never going to support racism against white people or other racial group even if the minority people become majority in America. The African American community in the past for me they were the champions in that position, even today, but also look like the Afro Americans civil leaders they are not happy, with the sucess of many Afro American people Mayors, County Officials,polices officers, state employers or with the first year of President Obama as President.
For that reason President Obama hate to talk about that agenda for the black communitty and I understand why, because for him integration it is much more important that a black agenda.
I like to know what the Afro American leaders are doing helping new refugees from all over the world. I like to know what the Afro American community it is doing helping the Latino and Hispanic speaking people in America think rigth about illegal immigration as politician.
For me it is nothing wrong help the Latino people, political leaders, think right about illegal immigration, if the illegal workers they are taking the job of the Afro American people not educated or Latino people legal here that they do not speak english yet, as many people first generation legal here.
I like to know why the president can not address the issue of illegal immigration in the right way, keeping the focus in the job that many leaders
of Labor and Industry at the State Government they are suppose to be doing in each State. Why they are not open to make a contract for the illegal workers. You going to found that the problem it is that many government agencies and states representatives at the state level in USA they are supporting slavery. They do not like any right for the workers, all the rights it is for the employers.
So, can you imagen a company doing a contract for illegal people?
Well, why not? Hershey Chocolate is doing that since long time ago. They bring people here from many different countries to work here legal and seasonal. I don't know why a Restaurant or any other company in USA can not do that.
We need to work together as nation and if some people are forcing racism in the black community as tool to fix the present, for me it is a serious mistake. The most serious issue here today in America it is not racial, it is push together the political system with the city government,county officials to follow up what the president it is doing in the White Houses, because, could be a yoke, but even President Bush was sending the message to the white community working in the government and to each government agencies, that he it was not supporting racism when General Collin Power was secretary of State and Condolice Rice close friend of president Bush with very good quimio for both be husband and wife. So, I like to know more what Rev. Jesse Jackson and Rev. Al Sharton are doing about, Integration. That can make real change in America even when the State of Pennsylvania we know they live today in 1950 and this it is the state that I am living today. Very complicated state. We have some conservative now that they are trying to become Hero saving the nation of a Liberal president Afro, when they are Germany descendents. Idiots, socialists, traitors of USA in WWII and that is the second generation still in power today in Pennsylvania but frankly I don't like to be like those people, being me poor or rich. NEVER! NEVER!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Charlotte Henry on 3/30/2010 1:14AM
03/30/10
The President is a fine citizen, one of the nicest persons in the world for change. I cannot find my Obama for President pin, I wanted to wear it to show my support, when the Health Care Bill was passed. I still nwear my cap, despite the stares I receive in Oklahoma.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Blacks4Barack on 3/31/2010 10:27AM
SHARPTON VS. Tavis Smiley Over
President's Handling of Black Agenda.
Only One Problem:
WHAT Black Agenda ?
By: Greg Jones
National Director
Blacks4Barack
Recently, a major riff occurred on national radio between Rev. Al Sharpton and Tavis Smiley after Tavis basically accused The Rev. of not enticing The President to address The Black Agenda while in a meeting at The White House recently. They argued back and forth on-air for nearly 20 minutes over how each of them feel President Obama should respond to The Black Agenda. Although the back and forth made for interesting radio, both sides of the argument are absolutely mute for one simple reason: there is no Black Agenda !
Don't get me wrong. We all know there is a long list of issues and needs of Black America that have gone unaddressed for far too long, from unemployment, education discrimination, criminal injustice and much more. But before any of these important issues can truly generate the attention necessary to solve these problems, it is of vital importance that we first realize that a list of needs is not the same as an AGENDA, which is defined as a specific set of goals or a plan.
Fact: Despite The President being bi-racial, he, our lovely First Lady and their two beautiful daughters have always, and will always be Black, which means there is no way The President is not aware of the needs and issues of Black America. Some of my brothers and sisters feel that since he is Black and knows our problems, that on day one he should have just run into The White House and created a bunch of new laws which answered all our Black needs or at least most. NEWSFLASH ! It doesn't work that way. And the constant cries that Obama should be doing this or Obama should be doing that for Black People simply exemplifies the fact that since we have never been in a position of truly having a listening ear in The White House, we don't know how to use it.
ALL true change is accomplished through the same method...the legislative process. We can march, we can cry out, we can shout, demand, complain, hold C-SPAN forums and march some more, as we have for the past 40 plus years. And at times all of that has had it's place and can actually be effective. But those tactics simply draw attention to the needs; it takes a well orchestrated, outlined and organized AGENDA or PLAN to actually get results through legislation....to SOLVE the needs by law.
Now that we have a true ear, in my opinion for the first time ever, it is time to literally write out The Black Agenda. Although we would love to see all of our problems solved instantly we can't just hand The President a list of a bunch of our needs . First, we MUST bring together our Black Scholars like Charles Ogletree, Cornell West, Rev. Al, Lani Guinier, Marc Morial, Julianne Malveaux, Ben Jealous and others. I intentionally did not say Black Leaders since we're the only group in America brain-washed to believe that we can only achieve if we are lead like lost sheep, a tactic designed to keep us waiting complacently for the 'chosen one'. Then there should be a PRIVATE forum-a think tank-in which the minds unite to create a priority list of Black needs, literally numbered first, second, third and so on. Next, on the same piece of paper, each need should be accompanied with a proposed solution, i.e. what we want. Next step, a strategic 'political game plan' should be devised to present each issue in concrete, outlined form to The President beginning with issue #1. It is at this time that Black media would then coordinate and focus attention on that specific issue to create a rally cry amongst We The People for the necessary Change.
In many cases, it will be necessary to recruit a member(s) of the Congressional Black Caucus or some other political figure(s) to physically write-out/draft and propose the legislation designed to address the particular issue, which will then be followed by the necessary steps to get the 'need' to The President's desk for his consideration. THAT'S AN AGENDA that The President can actually address. THIS is the process by which many other groups achieve the Change that they fight for. From women's rights, labor laws, gay rights, even civil rights...they were all accomplished through the legislative process.
And if our scholars are not certain of exactly how to package our Agenda in the proper form for true legislative consideration, then I recommend that we include in the meeting people from the various groups who have successfully achieved legislative change to ask them simply...how did you do it ? It's time to truly get ORGANIZED. Our needs must be presented in a form that can be placed on The President's desk. THAT'S an actual Agenda !
Lastly, we must stop thinking that since we have a Black President that now he can do all of these wonderful things just for us Black Folks. That's just as silly sounding as it would be if Bush had said he's going to start doing certain things just for Whites. Can you imagine ? So as our scholars formulate The Black Agenda they must package the proposed remedy in a strategic enough manner that would allow The President to sign-on in agreement, while not appearing to exclude others. (and yes I'm aware that certain issues are exclusive to Black America but the point is they must be presented or packaged in a very strategic manner)
So instead of The Rev. and Tavis arguing over whether or not The President is addressing The Black Agenda-which actually doesn't even exist-it's time to take a pause for the causes, compile the list of participating scholars, create the think-tank to formulate the strategy, put it in concrete, outlined, prioritized, legislative form...then work in Unity toward, not just voicing the needs but presenting the
TRUE Black Agenda.
And by the way...Yes We Can...
if we do it right.
Also: Read an excellent article by Angela Glover Blackwell which discusses the multitude of policies President Obama has implemented in his first 14 months which DO, as she states "From where I sit–with more than three decades of experience working to make public policies more fair and inclusive of all people–the past year has seen tremendous investment in the African-American community right along the lines we laid out four years ago."
Click Here to Read:
" A Black Agenda Some Choose NOT To See "
Visit: http://www.B4Bmorenews.blogspot.com for original post
Reply to this Comment | Report This