Marc Morial, Al Sharpton: Obama Should Be Held to Same Standard as Other Presidents

The Rev. Al Sharpton and Urban League President Marc Morial did an interview with TheGrio recently about the state of black America, and how to contextualize the presidency of Barack Obama. One of the broad debates within the African American community relates to whether or not the president should have an exclusive agenda for black Americans, or if policies related to African Americans should be included in systemic advocacy for everyone. Obama regularly mentions work being done for the poor and those in urban America, but he rarely discusses black people in his comments.

Rev. Sharpton has chosen to work more directly with President Obama, which is in contrast to the approach of Tavis Smiley, who held a forum in Chicago that was more critical of the president. Smiley isn't alone in his critique of Obama, as he was joined by Dr. Cornel West, Dr. Michael Eric Dyson, Dr. Julianne Malveaux, Min. Louis Farrakhan and Rev. Jesse Jackson. The conversation came to a head during a heated debate between Sharpton and Smiley on the radio, which led to questions about how black leadership can or should work with the first African American president. Rev. Sharpton feels that his meeting with President Obama last month communicates that the president is supportive of a black agenda.

"To meet about black unemployment is a black agenda unless you feel the black unemployed don't count," Sharpton told theGrio, in reference to his meeting last month with President Obama. "You can't get a blacker agenda to me..."

"[It's] a difference between being in the press box, being in the fancy suites at a football game and being down on the field," said Marc Morial, president of the National Urban League. "And I think where I am, where Rev. Sharpton is, is down on the field helping to move the ball forward [for African-Americans]."

I've thought long and hard about this divide among African American public figures regarding how to manage the work of President Barack Obama. My bias is probably revealed by the fact that I chose not to attend the Smiley forum in Chicago, but I will be on a panel at The Black Leadership forum hosted by Rev. Al Sharpton in New York City between April 14 - 17th. The decision was difficult, given that I have very productive relationships with Rev. Jesse Jackson, Cornel West, Michael Eric Dyson and Julianne Malveaux, but I cannot sign off on Tavis Smiley's determination to undermine the efforts of President Obama. The difficulty of this decision was compounded by the fact that I've written dozens of articles that have been critical of Obama. At the same time, I give him credit where it is due - he is doing a better job than any president in recent history.

It appears that Tavis Smiley simply doesn't want Barack Obama to be president at all. He is a long-time supporter of Hillary Clinton, and was likely cornered by Clinton into leveraging all of his political capital on the chance that she would be able to defeat Obama in the Democratic primary. When Obama emerged victorious, Smiley then had no incentive to do anything other than undermine Obama's power, given that Obama has no use for Tavis Smiley as a liaison to the African American community (Obama makes it clear in his actions that he doesn't support his enemies unless he has to). It is my conclusion that there is almost nothing that President Obama could do (other than resign) that will make Tavis Smiley support him.

But what's also true is that this "good-cop/bad-cop" approach to Obama might be more effective than what we've had thus far. Obama-mania is never good for black America, given that politicians with unconditionally loyal constituents have little incentive to serve the needs of those who love them the most. Vocal critics in the black community keep Obama on edge and force him to prove that he is loyal to black America, thus making him more willing to work with Sharpton, Jealous and Morial. So, at the end of the day, while Smiley and Sharpton may not be the best of friends, they are actually proving to be effective teammates.

With that said, almost none of those who chose to appear at the Smiley forum in Chicago are scheduled to appear with Sharpton in New York. As of today, confirmed guests are Tom Joyner, Roland Martin, Marc Morial, Ben Jealous, Charles Ogletree, Judge Greg Mathis, HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, and yours truly. I am not completely sure what to expect at this forum, but one thing I like is that the focus is going to be on action.







Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and the author of the new book, "Black American Money." To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here.

Comments: (11)

Add a comment

Page 1 of 2

Most Commented Articles

Daily Drama

The Best Clips From TV's Hottest Shows


More Daily Drama >>

Find a Message Board

Discover conversations on everyone from Barack to Beyonce. There are nearly 50 forums, so click on a category below and find the right one for you.