
Many people throughout the world believe that South Africa during apartheid was one of the most racist regimes in the history of the world. In that society, black people were clearly considered to be inferior to whites and were denied equal access to education, medical care and basic public services. Even having sex with a person of another race was considered to be a criminal offense. Apartheid came to an end in 1994, under mounting international opposition, as the world argued that black people in South Africa were being subjected to an inhumane system that should not be tolerated by decent people anywhere. The United States was one of the countries that took the lead on the initiative to disband apartheid, passing the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986, leading to sanctions against South Africa and demanding the release of political prisoner Nelson Mandela.
It turns out that when it comes to our prison systems, though, the United States cannot claim the moral high ground that it once seemed to possess. According to data from the Prison Initiative, America incarcerates 5.8 times more black men per capita than South Africa did during apartheid. To add insult to injury, African Americans are roughly 6 times more likely to go to prison than whites, and black males are nearly 7 times more likely. These numbers are atrocious and an international embarrassment. It is about time that we did something about it.
One has to wonder when America will let go of its commitment to racism and mass incarceration. We brag to the world that we are a free nation, but one has to wonder if this is the case when we incarcerate more of our citizens than any other country in the world. A disproportionate number of those citizens are African American, which has a destabilizing effect on the African-American family.
After the period of incarceration is over, there is an even longer punishment administered to felons, including economic, educational and political disenfranchisement. In many states across America, felons are not allowed to participate in elections, get student loans or find a job. It is the children of these Americans who suffer most from this unjust punishment, and most of this pressure falls on to the African-American community.
The Democracy Restoration Act is a bill being sponsored by Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis) and Rep. John Conyers (D-MI). The act would restore voting rights for ex-convicts in federal elections. This can be an important first step toward helping our nation find a more productive way to engage ex-convicts without putting them in to a position where they feel disconnected from our democracy. Of course the Republicans don't support the act, because many of the felons would be Democrats.
The truth is, though, that allowing felons the right to vote is the right thing to do. In the American Revolution, many screamed "No taxation without representation," so if felons are not allowed to vote, then they should not be required to pay taxes. The political re-engagement of ex-convicts should be followed by other forms of economic and educational engagement to give them incentives to live a productive life. America will be better when Fathers, husbands, Mothers and wives are rehabilitated from their mistakes and able to become productive members of society.
Most Americans don't know that slavery was never fully abolished. Section 1 of the 13th Amendment has a clause that states that slavery is not abolished for those who've been convicted of a crime. Therefore, in the United States, we have a nation which firmly believes that convicted criminals do not have the same rights as the rest of us. While punishing criminals is an important part of any society, the truth is that the punishments in the United States do not always fit the crime. Not only do we over-incarcerate, irresponsibly slapping the label of "criminal" on far too many Americans, we also just "happen" to decide that most of those deserving of this label are black. Our country needs to be better than that, and it's going to take courageous action in order to get there.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and the author of the new book, "Black American Money." To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 


Comments: (48)
Add a comment
By: Shane Laake on 4/04/2010 6:54PM
I'm confused as to whether the author is suggesting we need affirmative action for prisons. A better suggestion would be to hold all felons to personal accountability no matter what their skin color may be. They're leaving their spouses, parents, and most importantly children while they pay the price to society they owe for their crimes--choices they made.
Slaves didn't choose to be slaves, and Nelson Mandela was a political prisoner, not someone who held up a liquor store or sold crack to school kids.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: sara on 4/05/2010 9:42PM
@Shane Laake - you might need a little more elementary reading and comprehension education, until then, do not comment on adult discussions. Your response just misses the point...
Report This
By: Precious Williams on 4/04/2010 6:59PM
Great article. This is absolutely shocking and something I had little awareness of. I intend to read up on it. Thank you.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: David on 4/04/2010 7:49PM
Massachusetts was the first state to abolish slavery (1780), and led the charge to abolish slavery throughout the country.
We sent to Washington the first black man EVER elected to the U.S. Senate by popular vote (Ed Brooke, 1967-1979), overwhelmingly elected a black man to be our governor (Deval Patrick, 2006-present), and overwhelmingly voted for Barack Obama to be President of the United States.
And we did all this with African Americans making up LESS THAN 7% OF OUR POPULATION.
So, blacks are less than 7% of the population of Massachusetts...and blacks commit nearly 70% of the MURDERS in Massachusetts.
Now please tell me, Dr. Watkins, how the hell is Massachusetts RACIST for having more blacks than whites in prison for murder?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Mike on 4/05/2010 2:45PM
David,
It is clear that in MA there are just a bunch of underachieving non-black criminals. I am sure with proper training from the criminal element in prison we can get these slackers to perform as well as their prison compatriots.
Oh yes, FELONS lose their vote, no matter what color they are.
Report This
By: sara on 4/05/2010 9:50PM
@David - who actually controls these statistics? As you stated, if there are only 7% blacks in Massachusetts, and 70% of the murders are committed by blacks, doesn't that strike you as odd. Who are the powers that be that are in charge of reporting these crimes - what color if I may be bold enough to ask you??? Obviously blacks aren't the ones in charge. Regardless of whom you voted into office, it doesn't change the simple facts that the people with the power, will always put out what statistics they deem fit. Lived in Massachusetts many years, very racist...hence why there are only 7% of blacks....food for thought
Report This
By: David on 4/06/2010 4:08PM
sara, that is simply Bull$hit. YOU are the one being biased by claiming that Mass. is racist. compared to what? if you were paying attention you might have noticed that we have a Black Governor and He is the person in the primary seat of power here. there was also a little something you may have heard of called the Underground Railroad. sounds like you need to read a book.
Report This
By: jimydancer on 4/08/2010 1:14PM
Mass is racist if its racist and most know that it is and stats and data as given are used to manipulate reality........if you are a racist that is what you are and the data and stats that you manipulate only hope to cloud the issue...The criminal justice system in this nation is racist and you know that as well as the rest of the nation........and biased and doctored stats are your smoke screen. If you want to make the arguement that there is not a racist CJS in this nation have at it. If not save the stats and data that give you comfort and a hope to change the face of racism as it is........
Report This
By: jamarcus on 4/04/2010 8:11PM
Dr B is just an angry black man who does not believe that Blacks committ a lot of crimes and most of the crimes are against other Blacks. The fairest solution would be across the board have a law called 3 felonies and you are dead which would be color blind and would clean up all communities, think about, their would be less white trash, black trash, asian trash and all other trash since the trash would all be executed.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: blackbear72 on 4/04/2010 8:41PM
Wow jamarcus, I bet you don't have a PHD, but you are 10 times more intelligent then this PHD. What a wonderful country this would be if all the TRASH, of any color, were no longer here! I bet those here will not agree your plan would be color blind, like it truly would be.
This PHD says "So, in the United States, we have a nation which firmly believes that convicted criminals do not have the same rights as the rest of us", like that is a bad thing! He also suggests that CONVICTED FELONS should not have to pay taxes becasue they can not vote! I agree with him, if they have to pay back all the costs they created to convict them and imprison them. Who pays that cost now? Us the taxpayers. How can this guy still teach at Syracuse or write here? Waiting for your insults hwill.
Reply to this Comment | Report This