
Citing the Arizona Immigration law, President Barack Obama has called on Congress to begin negotiations on an overhaul of the nation's broken immigration system.
With a rugged year of legislation already under their belt, including health care reform and financial overhaul, it looks like Congress does not have the "appetite" to move forward with immigration reform, Obama said.
After the Arizona law, though, it's clear that something must be done.
"Make no mistake, our immigration system is broken, and after so many years in which Washington has failed to meet its responsibilities, Americans are right to be frustrated. ... But the answer isn't to undermine fundamental principles that define us as a nation," Obama said during a Cinco de Mayo celebration at the White House.
As usual, politics is also involved in the decision to not work on a desperately needed change to our immigration system.
The AP writes:
There also may not be enough time left on the legislative calendar to take up a contentious issue with midterm elections looming in November, but by making the commitment Obama may at least be able to tell Hispanic groups he tried. Obama acknowledged immigration reform would be difficult to achieve and would require bipartisan support - something that's lacking in the Senate right now. And he made no commitment to finishing the process this year. But he said it was the only way to deal with the nation's immigration problems.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid drafted legislation last week that calls for tougher federal immigration enforcement and a tightening of border security before undocumented immigrants would be allowed to become legal U.S. residents. The only Republican interested in working on the bill, Sen. Lindsey Graham, though, said moving forward this year is not an option. And with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi reasonably calling for the Senate to take the lead on a tough piece of legislation for once, it doesn't look like reform will be on the agenda this year.
Congress should at least begin to work behind closed doors on the issue. Democrats and Republicans should work out the framework of the legislation, so that they can move forward quickly next year. This bill is as important as energy reform and financial regulation, so it should be given the same priority.
By doing nothing, Congress is encouraging other states to act as Arizona did and pass illegal laws that violate the liberties that so many have fought for in this country. The Arizona law will lead to racial profiling and the violation of people's basic rights. And Latinos, the main targets of the law, will not be the only people affected. Pick up a friend from work or look too "immigrant," whatever that means, and you could find yourself being questioned by police.
The law not only makes Arizona look bad but reflects poorly on our entire country on the international stage. "Comprehensive reform - that's how we're going to solve this problem," Obama said.


Comments: (10)
Add a comment
By: Maggie on 5/06/2010 3:36PM
I must disagree with the President. I don't think that this law makes Arizona look bad, quite the contrary, I think that Arizona is the only state in this country to tackle the Illegal immigration problem. People in Arizona are being murdered by illegal drug dealers, their homes are being vandalized by illegals trying to cross the border and are hungry or thirsty. The people of Arizona need to do whatever will protect them. The federal government has failed in that regard. Good for Arizona, I think all states should adopt this law.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: rbk84 on 5/06/2010 6:11PM
How stupid can people be. Look this whole focuss on illegals is just a smoke screen for the up comming elctions. This non issue has laid dormant in america for over a hundred years. If you want to legislate immigration, than lets talk about people who have a real impact on the economy and who are taking jobs away from americans who are here legally. How many middle class jobs are given to immigrants who are recruited by corporations, to fill jobs americans can fill. How many engineering jobs are given to foreiners with work visas by coporations. Some guy comming accross the border to clean someones toilet, or work in their fields or babysit their children has no affect on your life whatsoever. If they commit a crime then they are sent to jail just like the rest of us. Considering the amount of crimes we blacks commit in our own community we should'nt be so fast as to condemn any other poor racial group thats trying to make a living off of america. White people will use this as a wedge issue to keep the poorer races apart and at each others throat. The black middle class will accept the lie that immigration reform is a priorty, and sit by as black issues are put on the back burner. And when all is said and done cheap labor will prevail, because thats what keeps america business profitable. You think some kid from compton,harlem chicago or some urban setting is going to hightail it to arizona to work inthe fields, or do the crap jobs these people do for a living. You think some poor white person will do these jobs. Get real. If they wanted to do these jobs they would be hired. You think these business owners are going to increase their wages to draw people into the fields. Come on. You know damn well they won't. The economy is bad and you think these corporations are going to do the right thing now because of some racist law meant to be used as a wedge issue during an election cycle. Please. After the nov elections and how congress will be comprised, will determine any kind of b.s. reform on this issue. I'll bet you there will be corporate clauses to ensure cheap labor will still be allowed in some form to keep mexicans comming to work for crap wadges. Also with the millions of illegal immigrants already here, and the goods these people buy in our mom and pop stores because you wont find these people living in well to do areas,and the local sales taxes allocated to their spending. Who will make up the difference. Will your taxes go up. Sure anyone can point to expenses these people cost the regular tax payer, but its a small amount if you replace their jobs with legal workers. You don't think these corporations will find a way to put the extra expense on us. Think politicians are crooked now, let anykind of reform happen. You haven't seen anything yet. Black people seem to be glad that this is an issue, sort of glad the spotlights on another ethnic group than ours. Thats foolish and dangerous, because if we make the divide between hispanics and us wider, than we all are doomed. No chance of real change can occur because we lack the real power for it to happen. Blacks were not the only ones who voted for Obama. Hispanics overwhelmingly voted for him to. If you take away the hispanic votes in that election,there is no way Obama is president. Just the facts. Whites are afraid of the combinding power of the people of color in this country. We must build on that fear to get things done for future generations. If it means standing up for each other than so be it. Don't buy into this notion that Hispanics are our enemies. That was perpetuated by whites. Its no wonder in prisons accross this country, guards try to pit hispanics against blacks for fear of uprisings..
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: redwhiteblue BLACK on 5/07/2010 1:49PM
You are very wrong about the immigration law. Arizona has become the kidnap capital of the U.S. Blacks are pitted against Hispanis because Hispanics don't like Blacks, never have never will. My nephew could not get a job in Chula Vista, California because he did not speak Spanish!! Is this fair??This is America and you should not be forced to learn Spanish. I have traveled all over the world and most countries speak English even in Mexico you can find someone who speaks English. In Mexico you have to have proper documents to travel into the country and if you are there illegally, you will spend 6 months in jail before being Deported. As an American you have no rights in any country other than the rights of that country, why should America be different. Hispanics did not put Obama in office Liberal Whites put Obama in office. Illegal immigration has been a problem for a long time even in the Bush years. Making all illegal immigrants legal will not allow them to vote for at least 5 years because it takes that long for them to become citizens. If all illegals are made legal that doesn't mean just the Mexicans but ALL illegals from the Middle East, Europe, Africa, China and some of these could be the bad guys who want to destroy America. Arizona is right to protect themselves. If you go to Mexico or any other country you have to carry your passport with you and can be asked at any time to produce your passport by any law enforcement officer. Don't fool yourself, this is not about Obama it is about keeping America safe. We as Americans have to pay for ALL ILLEGALS health care and most are on the Welfare role. You should get real, Not everything is about Obama's re-election as president.
Report This
By: Michael Lofton on 5/07/2010 6:24PM
"Black men face the triple whammy of horrible educational systems, massive unemployment and excessive incarceration in America's prisons. In fact, our country incarcerates 5.8 times more black men than South Africa did during apartheid. With unemployment rates of 19 percent to 20 percent, the truth is that we have to find a better way to get things done. Mathis is part of the solution to these issues". by Boyce Watkins, PhD, Judge Greg Mathis Speaks on Black Men
In addition to all of the above, the reality that our own elected Black leaders, Black lawyers, and/or others in position of influence, show contempt for the U.S. Constitution, the rule of law, etc., etc., activity that increases the odds that truly innocent Black men, women, and/or their siblings, have property taken from them without just cause through the atrocities of "bad government in the inner-city", are jailed and/or fined without valid evidence, have their families broken up without just cause, end up being displaced by criminal illegal/undocumented immigrants in jobs that require proof of citizenship, have a stellar reputation ruined that negatively impacts the legal/lawful right to work by the atrocities of government, etc., etc., etc.
.....Mind you undocumented immigrants appeal daily to President Barack Obama, and First Lady Michelle Obama, for the sole purpose of providing U.S. citizenship for millions of criminal/illegal undocumented evidence.
Quite naturally President Obama is more interested in winning the votes of the illegal immigration advocates, than serving U.S. citizens....
.....while kicking to the curb petitions for redress for the blatant atrocities of government, petitions to reduce unemployment in the Black community, etc., causes that truly have merit, and take precedence over providing amnesty for millions of illegal immigrants, who have no business being on U.S. soil in the first place.
http://againstallodds.blogtownhall.com/2010/04/16/federal,_state,_county,_and_city_government_are_instituted_for_destruction_and_not_for_the_common_good_when_dealing_with_law_abiding_us_born_black_people!.thtml
http://againstallodds.blogtownhall.com/2010/05/03/disregard_for_mandated_constitutional_protections_is_black_code_law_enforcement!.thtml
http://townhall.com/myblog/createpost.aspx?g=0a2b9dec-ccdf-443f-b1df-66936e1029bb&p=a2ba9c26-1b40-4912-92bb-87755eecf8d6
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: rbk84 on 5/07/2010 7:36PM
First of all if it was white liberals that elected Obama we would have nothing but Democratic Presidents. As for you family member not getting a job because they did'nt speak spanish, was the job advertised as bilingual. I live in california and i have never heard of anyone not getting a job they applied for because they did'nt speak a language. That has to be under the qualifications of the position. If they applied for a bilingual position of course they won't get hired. How many mexicans are turned down for jobs because they don;t speak english. As for other countries teaching english to their people. To me that translates to taking away american jobs that an american citizen could fill. If on one hand you don't like hispanics then you've got real problems. A black person complaining about not being accepted by hispanics is ridiculous for the fact both cultures had things taken away from them by whites. Blacks had their freedom taken away and hispanics had their land taken away. Both of these happened with the governments approval. And in some cases we blacks helped take away the hispanics land with our buffalo soldiers who was doing the white mans bidding to be accepted in his country. So there is enough hatred to go around. Keep doing the white mans work for him and hate hispanics. He will just do as he always have. STAY IN CONTROL OF YOUR IGNORANT ASS.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Michael Lofton on 5/08/2010 6:52PM
http://onetime.blogtownhall.com/2010/05/07/the_city_of_los_angeles,_los_angeles_county_is_a_sanctuary_city_for_criminals,_illegalundocumented_immigrants!.thtml
Los Angeles County is a sanctuary city for criminals, illegal/undocumented immigrants, because the City, County of Los Angeles, and/or other sanctuary jurisdictions show contempt for the Constitututional rights of its law abiding U.S. citizens!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Michael Lofton on 5/08/2010 7:26PM
http://onetime.blogtownhall.com/2010/05/08/leshanor_thomas_andor_other_us_born_blacks_are_learning_a_hard_lesson_that_hispanics,_be_it_in_a_legal_or_illegal_hispanic_immigrant,_are_not_in_his,_her,_or_their_corner,_in_any_regard!.thtml
Leshanor Thomas and/or other U.S. born Blacks are learning a hard lesson that Hispanics, be it in a legal or illegal Hispanic immigrant, are not in his, her, or their corner, in any regard!
http://againstallodds.blogtownhall.com/2010/04/28/comparing_the_plight_of_criminal_illegalundocumented_immigrants__to_the_plight_of_law_abiding_us_born_blacks,_the_extermination_of_jews_during__wwii,_amounts_to_bull_crap!.thtml
.....and Congressional Black Caucus, Reverend Al Sharpton, President Barack ‘the Magic Negro” Obama, and/or other misguided individuals, support amnesty for millions of illegal immigrants!
Black Civil Rights Movement within the U.S., has no connection any Hispanic movement....
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinco_de_Mayo
Cinco de Mayo History: The history Cinco de Mayo is an interesting one because unlike what most people believe, it is NOT the Independence Day for Mexico and more widely celebrated here in the U.S. than over in Mexico. Cinco de Mayo is actually a celebration of the 1862 Mexican victory in the Battle of Puebla over the French. The Mexican Independence Day is actually celebrated on September 16.
*****************************
Esteban Nunez murder trial lyrics: "Gangsta rap made us do it"
.....meaning the influence of “inner-city” Black gang, Gangsta Rap, members made Esteban Nunez and his Hispanic friends commit murder.....
.......top of the line mules run as fast, or faster than top of the line thoroughbred race horses too!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Wilson on 5/09/2010 12:23PM
I don,t agree with President Obama concerning Arizona, I agree with arizona. More laws should be passed like their law, what a huge differents it would make. Illegas have no right here, all they are doing is making things harder for US taxpayers. Wake up!! strange no one can see whats happening.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: skj on 5/19/2010 3:12AM
You all are talking about one particular group of people as illegal immigrants and paiting a picture of a killer, murderer and a thief. Some immigrants came here as students, who tried to work hard, earn a living and send themselves to school while supporting family members at home. They never wanted any thing for free. They have never stolen anything, killed anybody but they are caught up in a situation. They reached a point at which they could not pay their tuition to keep their status as students. They are out of status and cannot go back home because there is nothing to go back to. some of these people are educated and if not yet, they have potential. Their only goal is education and a better life for them and their families. They have in a way contributed to society. To some, the situation is so bad in that they cannot go back home without losing the privilege of comming back, as this is the only place they have know for years to be home where they are able to provide for themselves. I say again these people are not taking away anybody's job, they are not stealing and they are not killing anybody. However , because of fear of being picked up, they now live like criminals , in hiding because they think that nobody will believe their story. I am talking about intelligent, honest, educated but hopeless people. How do you caegorize these and what is their fate?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: RDP on 5/27/2010 9:41PM
skj: I can see where you are coming from but illegal is illegal. True there are some students here on visas that put us as Americans to shame academically. They are the students that live in the books and don't make the parties or clubs or have any form of social life at all. They sometimes allow their student visa to lapse. So should we make provisions for them? I would say no. They have to take the responsibility to manage their own life. Or.... their sponsor should make up the slack. Mind you these same people are the engineers, scientist, and inventors that are keeping us in the race with the rest of the world. So, to your point, they do play a vital role in the long run. As Americans and expecially as Blacks, we need to worry more about our education and goals. We spend way to much money on a public image. That money needs to go back into the community in the form of education for our kids and ourselves. What are the statistics for the number of Blacks with a PhD, Master's, or even a Bachlors? Compare that to the number of people who drive a luxuary car and live in the slums. Or have the latest high price fashions and a GED. We cannot complain about immigration effecting the Black community until we work within our community and clear the filth. Mexicans are the least of our worries.
Report This