The ousting of Gen. Stanley McChrystal (pictured), the commander of the U.S. Force in Afghanistan, has raised eyebrows today. What has got people talking isn't so much McChrystal's resignation, but the president's seemingly bullish and no-nonsense approach to the matter. President Barack Obama is often accused of being too soft on hard issues.
Not this time, though.
On Tuesday, President Obama said that McChrystal, whose candid remarks about the administration and its approach to war, which appear in an interview with Rolling Stone magazine, had displayed "poor judgment" and that he would speak to the general before making any decisions. It was already clear at that point, however, that McChrystal's position was on the line.
Several White House officials, including Press Secretary Robert Gates, had publicly rebuked the commander for his comments. In it, McChrystal reportedly said that he had been "disappointed" after his first meeting with the president, and that he had found it hard to sell the idea that more troops were needed: "I found that time painful," said McChrystal, before adding that "[he] was selling an unsellable position."
The president pointed out that the resignation was not a personal or policy-related issue but rather in the interest of national security.
I contend that getting rid of McChrystal was better for the president's image than anything else.
The war in Afghanistan is a sensitive topic for President Obama. Having inherited it from his predecessor, George W. Bush, he was expected to withdraw troops almost immediately as he had pledged during his campaign. Instead, troops have since been added, and more money has been spent fighting in a war that many consider unwinnable.
It's a war that Obama cannot afford -- either literally or figuratively -- to lose. McChrystal's comments caused a firestorm that was not good for the administration, and had Obama kept McChrystal, he would have looked weak.
It is telling, as well as troubling, that the man responsible for the military command does not believe that the president is on the right track with his war strategy. Although he would be unlikely to say more at this point for risk of further damaging his career, we should ask the general to explain more about his perspective.
This incident reminds me of the war in Iraq, when people like Hans Blix, former chief weapons inspector of the United Nations, publicly stated that there were no weapons of mass destruction. His voice, too, was silenced, and he turned out to be right.
If McChrystal does feel as strongly as he appeared to in the Rolling Stone article, he should probably have not held that position in the first place. He would also have done better to have discussed his views with the president in private first. Using the megaphone of the media to do that was indeed a poor judgment call. Gen. David Petraeus, now McChrystal's replacement, may indeed be a better fit.
We should not entirely dismiss McChrystal's views, though, because they underscores wider issues in the war strategy that should be taken seriously. I just hope that Afghanistan will not turn out to be another Iraq.
16-June-10 - I know I'm supposed to be all outraged about the Seattle cop punching the teen in her face because I'm black and stuff like that, HOWEVER, I don't know whether it's because I'm a jaded '80s baby tired of young people's lack of respect for authority or I'm just insensitive, but I think the girls in this video absolutely deserve what they got.
16-June-10 - I know I'm supposed to be all outraged about the Seattle cop punching the teen in her face because I'm black and stuff like that, HOWEVER, I don't know whether it's because I'm a jaded '80s baby tired of young people's lack of respect for authority or I'm just insensitive, but I think the girls in this video absolutely deserve what they got.
15-June-10 - Jarretta Hamilton is angry and unemployed. The 39-year-old teacher was fired last April because she had sex before marriage and wound up pregnant. Now she has broken her silence and has gone public.
12-June-10 - I am not quite sure what to make of the ruffled YouTube video that is now scouring the web out of Paterson, New Jersey, where an officer inexplicably grabs a man, turns him around and puts pepper spray in to his eyes twice.
11-June-10 - Indianapolis Police Chief Paul Ciesielski called for the firing of a white officer who's been charged with repeatedly striking a 15-year-old biracial boy in the face during an arrest. The attacks allegedly occurred after the boy had been subdued by other officers.
09-June-10 - Gary Coleman's ex-wife, Shannon Price, is up to her post-hubby's-death antics again. As if masterminding the sale of Coleman's pre- and- post-death photos wasn't enough, now the merry widow has managed to get in to Coleman's home and take practically everything that wasn't bolted down! Click Here for the Complete Story
09-June-10 - Todd Bridges, who co-starred with Gary Coleman on the popular sitcom "Diff'rent Strokes,"is livid about both Globe Magazine's and Shannon Price's involvement in Coleman's death photos.
08-June-10 - Desiree Rogers, the former White House social secretary who "left" to seek greener pastures after a major security faux paux occurred under her watch, was recently hired by Johnson Publishing Co., the owners of Jet and Ebony magazines, as a consultant.
07-June-10 - A Seattle writer is angry beyond words, because late last month his 8-year-old child was removed from her honors elementary school class. No, the child did not misbehave. Instead, the little girl was guilty of using a hair moisturizer that allegedly annoyed her Caucasian teacher.
04-June-10 - Alejandra, Jermaine Jackson's ex-wife, is taking her ex-mother-in-law, Katherine, to court to demand financial security for herself and her children.
Frankly I have more respect for a warrior than a politician any day of the week and twice on Sunday. With that said, you can’t have commanders undermining civilian authority.
There must be the appearance of unity within the chain of command, and insubordination cannot be tolerated, period. In basic training, we (service members) learn that from day one. This is why the General had to go.
The President looking weak is a weak and political perspective. His appearance to the world has nothing to do with war, combat and death.
It is an argument one makes who knows nothing about the military. Rather just regurgitating some BS, heard from other sources. In other words this writer is a hack.
Bottom line: The media pressured Obama to allow the white coward to resign with full benefits,and spare the white coward the humiliation of being fired by a blackman
McChystal is a good leader, no matter what color he is EGGTHROWER. I guess EGGTHROWER wants a COMMUNIST BLACK MAN to lead us in war. Your president do not know anything about the MILITARY. Good luck McChrystal, and i would be glad to serve under you.
Let's face it and be brutally honest. Obama doesn't have a clue in how to wage war. He can organize community issues like he did in Chicagoland, but as Commander-in-Chief he lacks the necessary leadership and brains to win. I say listen to the generals who are on the front line, and not some Washington idiot who should never have been elected to the presidency. So, how is this hope-and-change working for all of you now??
Well really no cares what you have to say because he's the President and he got rid of the vermon. If you don't like then go live with the ass that knows he is not to open his mouth against his commander in chief.
For those unfamiliar with the UCMJ Article 88, it reads: "Any commissioned officer who uses contemptuous words against the President, Vice-President, Congress, Secretary of a military dept., Secretary of Transportation or Governor or legislature of any State, Territory, Commonwealth or possession in which he is on duty or present, shall be punished as a court-martial may direct." That is the rule....he broke it. If one makes disparaging remarks about/against his/her boss, in public, do you think that person would still have a job? President Obama is our Commander-in-Chief. Whether you agree with him or not, he deserves the respect of the office he holds.
Richard get over it he's the commander & Chief Respect is very important if a soilder had desrespect McChrystal he would have got the boot so Obama gave his ass the boot plus Petraeus is a better fit.
When you talk stuff about the most powerfulest man in the world, what do think will happen to you. Sounds like McChystal ,{lite], LOL over loaded his a-- with his mouth. Good job Mr.President. Well done.
THANK YOU PJ & To Renee!! Now's the next step. Can ALL the butt-wipe cowards who reported to McChrystal & participated in the interview with disparaging remarks. I'm absolutely SURE Gen. David Petraeus will take care of business!! That entire direct reporting stucture needs to be disbanded & canned!! It's the only way to assure the infestation is removed. Our Service Member deserve to serve under a competent command who demonstrates commitment to get the job done & preserve lives .. not waste time before camera's to put their Commander-In-Chief down in a weak & fake effort to elevate themselves. McChrystal is nothing but a COWARD with his head up his own ass, & I'm proud to see that President Obama demostrated the wisdon to hand it back to him!!
Comments: (40)
Add a comment
By: rik on 6/23/2010 4:10PM
Frankly I have more respect for a warrior than a politician any day of the week and twice on Sunday. With that said, you can’t have commanders undermining civilian authority.
There must be the appearance of unity within the chain of command, and insubordination cannot be tolerated, period. In basic training, we (service members) learn that from day one. This is why the General had to go.
The President looking weak is a weak and political perspective. His appearance to the world has nothing to do with war, combat and death.
It is an argument one makes who knows nothing about the military. Rather just regurgitating some BS, heard from other sources. In other words this writer is a hack.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: eggthrower2k on 6/23/2010 4:11PM
Bottom line: The media pressured Obama to allow the white coward to resign with full benefits,and spare the white coward the humiliation of being fired by a blackman
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: mswll4 on 6/23/2010 4:47PM
McChystal is a good leader, no matter what color he is EGGTHROWER. I guess EGGTHROWER wants a COMMUNIST BLACK MAN to lead us in war. Your president do not know anything about the MILITARY. Good luck McChrystal, and i would be glad to serve under you.
Report This
By: Richard Riley on 6/23/2010 4:29PM
Let's face it and be brutally honest. Obama doesn't have a clue in how to wage war. He can organize community issues like he did in Chicagoland, but as Commander-in-Chief he lacks the necessary leadership and brains to win. I say listen to the generals who are on the front line, and not some Washington idiot who should never have been elected to the presidency. So, how is this hope-and-change working for all of you now??
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Mimi on 6/23/2010 11:12PM
@SMITTYT
I AGREE WITH YOU 100%. THE WORD IS THAT MCCRYSTAL MIGHT BE THINKING ABOUT RUNNING FOR PRESIDENT IN 2012.
MCCRYSTAL DID WHAT THE REPUBLICANS TOLD HIM TO DO. NOW EVERYONE SEES HIM AS A COWARDLY TRAITOR.
Report This
By: Renee on 6/24/2010 2:28PM
Well really no cares what you have to say because he's the President and he got rid of the vermon. If you don't like then go live with the ass that knows he is not to open his mouth against his commander in chief.
For those unfamiliar with the UCMJ Article 88, it reads: "Any commissioned officer who uses contemptuous words against the President, Vice-President, Congress, Secretary of a military dept., Secretary of Transportation or Governor or legislature of any State, Territory, Commonwealth or possession in which he is on duty or present, shall be punished as a court-martial may direct." That is the rule....he broke it. If one makes disparaging remarks about/against his/her boss, in public, do you think that person would still have a job? President Obama is our Commander-in-Chief. Whether you agree with him or not, he deserves the respect of the office he holds.
Report This
By: Gus on 6/24/2010 10:34PM
Richard get over it he's the commander & Chief Respect is very important if a soilder had desrespect McChrystal he would have got the boot so Obama gave his ass the boot plus Petraeus is a better fit.
Report This
By: pj on 6/23/2010 5:19PM
When you talk stuff about the most powerfulest man in the world, what do think will happen to you.
Sounds like McChystal ,{lite], LOL over loaded his
a-- with his mouth. Good job Mr.President.
Well done.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Pechus on 6/25/2010 3:34AM
THANK YOU PJ & To Renee!! Now's the next step. Can ALL the butt-wipe cowards who reported to McChrystal & participated in the interview with disparaging remarks. I'm absolutely SURE Gen. David Petraeus will take care of business!! That entire direct reporting stucture needs to be disbanded & canned!! It's the only way to assure the infestation is removed. Our Service Member deserve to serve under a competent command who demonstrates commitment to get the job done & preserve lives .. not waste time before camera's to put their Commander-In-Chief down in a weak & fake effort to elevate themselves.
McChrystal is nothing but a COWARD with his head up his own ass, & I'm proud to see that President Obama demostrated the wisdon to hand it back to him!!
Report This
By: ARNEADER on 6/23/2010 6:48PM
YOU TELL'M MR. PRESIDENT!
Reply to this Comment | Report This