
In the ongoing saga of Detroit's dysfunction comes Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy's (pictured above) bright idea to jail parents in Detroit for up to three days for repeatedly missing parent-teacher conferences.
Worthy's argument is that parents who are not accountable for their children are part of the problem with elevated truancy, dropout rates and a recent rash of violent crimes involving teens:
"I have seen that younger and younger children are committing more violent acts, and we need to look at different approaches," Worthy told reporters. "I know we need to try something different. We should not have to legislate this, but what we have been doing is not working."
Worthy is drafting a proposal for the legislation and hopes to present it to county commissioners in August to persuade them to approve an ordinance.
So if you have a single parent who is working and unable to attend a conference, then that parent should be jailed, which would leave the child completely alone? Are you jailing a parent who's a deadbeat? Or is it just the primary caregiver? What about someone with 10 kids and 10 different schools? What about kids who just have bad parents? Will meeting with a teacher make them better parents? My parents didn't make every conference for my sister and I, and I haven't made every conference for my children. We all did well or are doing well in school. Is any of this logical?
Under Worthy's plan, Wayne County parents would be required to pick a time and day to attend one parent-teacher conference a year. If that conference is missed, the school would send out a letter to set up another within 14 days. If the second is missed, parents get a letter about sanctions, which could include up to three days in jail.
Worthy's office penalizes parents and guardians for school truancy, but by the time prosecutors get involved, large chunks of classroom time have already been missed. Hundreds of cases are reviewed each year, but only 50 or so result in prosecution. Educational neglect is a misdemeanor that carries up to 90 days in jail and a fine for parents. Older students could end up in juvenile court.
This proposal is unlikely to quickly become an ordinance because it would probably be challenged in court. For example, civil libertarians say it may be outside the law. Even some teachers, who often spend several hours waiting for parents who don't show up for the conferences, are skeptical.
If Worthy is looking for parent involvement, Hyde Leadership Academy, a charter school in Washington, D.C., seems to have found a good middle ground. It requires parents to attend Saturday workshops once a month, where they discuss issues in a group setting with their children. They also attend a three-day weekend retreat in the state of Maine, where they participate in more intensive workshops. If the parents do not participate, students will not be allowed to continue to attend the school, which is a high-achieving institution. Parents are informed of these requirements for participation when being interviewed for the school.
The success of this school is not just isolated to academic achievement: Students and parents have grown closer, discussed and worked through issues they weren't able to on their own and learned from other parents and students. Teachers are also criticized or rewarded in a public forum.
Maybe Worthy should do some research on tactics that have worked in other districts with Detroit's demographics. Detroit really doesn't need any more people in jail. I mean, really.


Comments: (54)
Add a comment
By: Reign on 7/08/2010 5:20PM
Really? I mean is that the only solution this woman could come up with? Jail? Really? I'm sure she's frustrated and need more parent involvement, but like the article suggested, why not travel the country and take a look at the MANY programs that are working and try it in her area. We're really embracing the slave mentality when an African American woman thinking putting parents in jail is an option...jails are NO PLACE for anyone, unless you've committed a heinous crime like enslaving people, killing people, etc. Geez!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Donna on 7/11/2010 2:02PM
There are dead-beat mama's as well as dead-beat papa's. Bottom line, if they don't show some concern for their children, their children will eventually be shooting people and commiting crimes, and don't fool yourselves, mom's who work do communicate to their children's teachers, not those lazy ass welfare receiptients who are teaching them to bring in the loot ending up in the cemetaries at age 10!
Report This
By: Keep(n) it Real on 7/11/2010 11:19PM
Bless you one could not have said it better, I mean come on now!!! It is obvious that Ms. Worthy has the Willie Lynch syndrome and a crab in the bucket mentality. Give a Black Woman just a little piece of authority and watch what she does with it. Let's just hope she doesn't miss any of her children's parent conference meetings if her schedule ever becomes fuller than what it appears to be now and she'll eat her own words and sit in jail too.
Report This
By: kieraht on 7/07/2010 12:41PM
Boy am I glad that Detroit's biggest problem is non-attendance to PTA meetings! Put those criminal parents in jail for 3 days and let the children sort themselves out for the duration. Or better yet - put the kids in foster care! Apparently Detroit has got funds to put all these families on the city dime! Detroit - the richest, least crime-ridden city in the nation!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: A. Wilson on 7/07/2010 1:40PM
It seems to me that Ms. Worthy could care less about the truancy rate, she is just trying to make a name for herself. People don't care about going to jail, she can't tell that by the rate of people incarcerated in her city? Putting parents in jail is not going to keep the children from committing crimes!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: gmann on 7/11/2010 9:51PM
Wilson, you are ether part of the solution or you are part of the problem! At least she's trying something, The oak wood accross the noggin of the parents won't work but it should because most of these parents could not care a damn about their kids schooling. These kids are our most natural resources she is talking about. It's always easy to put the blame on the school system but these type of parents is very good at passing the buck when their child fails. We all have to agree that something has to be done and it is a proven that parents who care about their children's schooling and who puts in the "time" for their kids welfare, these are the kids who dividends pay off down the line with college degrees. It's understanding that a lot of kids in brought up in single parent house holds but hell if not but once a year! a parent should care enough to invest some little time in their child school work or whether they are passing or failing, for sure they will have to make time having to go to court trying to keep them out of prison! It amazes me that some of these kids can't spell properly but they can memorize all the verses and lyrics to rap songs
Report This
By: gmann on 7/11/2010 10:17PM
A.Wilson, Yes i know that i didn't put the "i" in either, for i know some will think i misspelled the word with ether. never said i was a good typist. Maybe i should take my old azz back to school for typing! Because for sure the kids is who will be lucky enough to become adults they will rue the days that they didn't take their education seriously but think nothing of doing the same their parents done to them by not caring and putting their kids through the same events they now find themselves in
Report This
By: paul on 7/07/2010 6:28PM
It's not fair to compare tactics of a charter school to those of a public school. Charter schools are optional and the parents are involved enough to enrole their kids in the first place.
Public schools have to deal with kids who's parents can't help with homework even if they wanted to. Parents who try to sell their babies to buy crack. Kids without parents, who don't know where they'll be sleeping or if they'll eat.
Ms. Wilson is correct in blaming the parents for their kids' behavior. Somehow they need to be held accountable. I don't think jail is going to do anything but make them bitter, and cost the city money. I think tying it to their welfare checks would get their attention. No PTA meetings, no free money. You want to make babies, you better plan on educating them.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: paul on 7/07/2010 4:27PM
Worthy, Wilson, whatever.
Report This
By: Jam on 7/13/2010 12:13PM
Amen. The parents definitely need to be made accountable for there children.
Report This