
Fisk has referred to the repossession as "nothing less than a theft of the art from Fisk." The school also argues that taking the art collection may cause the university to shut down forever.
The idea came about after Chancellor Ellen Hobbs Lyle rejected the university's proposal to sell a 50 percent holding in the art collection in order to raise funds. The school has been struggling financially and was finding ways to pay bills. The collection was going to be shown for half the year in Arkansas, and the school would receive $30 million in return.
The school has mentioned that maintaining the art collection was prohibitively expensive and that it couldn't afford to keep it up. Since the school says it can't afford to maintain the collection, the state is trying to take possession of the art in exchange for paying the cost of the upkeep. The goal is to keep the collection in the city of Nashville for the entire year.
The attorney general's plan says that the collection would be returned to Fisk once it has demonstrated that it can afford to keep it. Fisk President Hazel O'Leary has protested the plan publicly:
"Nashville has a simple choice to make, and that is whether it is better to keep the art in Nashville full time and have Fisk close or keep the art in Nashville half the time and have Fisk survive," she said. "The state of Tennessee and Metropolitan Nashville have decided that the art is more important than Fisk."
I am in complete agreement with O'Leary about the state's unjust decision to confiscate one of the most valuable assets of a struggling university. Taking this art collection from Fisk is similar to the paternalistic notion of a black mother having her child taken by the state because she cannot afford to feed him. Rather than helping Fisk afford the cost of taking care of the art collection, the state is adding insult to injury by attempting to take the collection for itself. I can't imagine the same thing happening to the University of Tennessee.
The problems for Fisk go back to a fundamental survival issue for many Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). The economic problems have never gone away, much of them due to the legacy of racism and financial exclusion exhibited by our nation over the past 400 years. Many predominantly white universities have endowments that are in the billions, while HBCUs struggle to pay the light bills. This financial disparity is not because of a differential in our commitment to education. It's because for hundreds of years, our wealth was stolen from us and given to somebody else. Taking the art collection away from Fisk at this critical time is nothing more than a continuation of the same racist legacy that created the inequality in the first place. The state of Tennessee should be ashamed. You don't deal with the effects of inequality by creating more of it.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce's commentary delivered to your e-mail, please click here. 

Comments: (5)
Add a comment
By: rik on 9/13/2010 3:25PM
So the 850 million the government is giving HBC's is is not enough. Now the government has to help them keep an art collection, "THEY CANT AFFORD".
Dont you get tired of begging for handouts all the damn time.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: A. on 9/14/2010 2:39PM
@rik,Remember, this Collection was donated to the University. The Collection has obvious value.If the state of Tennessee really saw the value of the Collection to the University, the state would do the right thing.
Report This
By: cgth2015 on 9/14/2010 3:41PM
Fisk isn't asking for a handout stupid....Fisk developed a plan that would bring in 30 million of dollars to the school each year. They will allow their art collection to be displayed in a musmuem in Arkansas for six months each year.
The problem is that the greedy State of Tennessee wants the courts to take the art collection away from Fisk and give it to them...
This is a complete violation for the schools right...The state of tennessee steals everything they can get away with.....Just look at the lottery money that was supposed to be used as scholarship money...They use it to fund the state schools....
Report This
By: slick on 9/14/2010 7:01PM
prohibitively expensive and that "it couldn't afford to keep it up"
So the state maintains it, and returns it when Fisk can pay it's light bill.
Report This
By: Dianne on 9/14/2010 7:00PM
Dr. Boyce Watkins. Georgia O'Keeffe was born in Wisconsin; so, was I. I had a good friend there, Attorney Lloyd Barbee who passed away some time back. He had a daughter who also went into the practice of Law; at the time of his funeral, she returned to Hawaii but I don't have the faintest idea of her address.
The reason that I bring it up is because this was an outright gift to Fisk by Georgia O'Keeffe, not to the State of Tennessee. I am fully aware that there are persons in Wisconsin known as patrons of the arts but also known now to have done everything contrary, to Attorney Barbee's endeavors in ending segregation of the school system,by their own endeavors to keep children "separate but equal". That was the means to continue without question the non-hiring of non-whites in the company from which they inherited their wealth to further invest in Art.
So, I certainly would not like the O'Keeffe bequest to Fisk somehow to end up in their hands as well.
I wish we knew exactly the address of Ms.Barbee (who may be married and have a different name?)because this matter requires legal advice quickly before a dreadful mistake is made and the bequest fall into the hands of those for whom it was not intended.
Why I am interested? My late husband, who died in the decade after Attorney Barbee,with whom he had been a colleague in local political matters,particularly during the Johnson administration and thereafter, as a younger person had been a member of the Fisk Jubilee Singers.
Reply to this Comment | Report This