There's bad news for the 20 states suing the federal government over the legality of the health care reform law.
A federal judge upheld the authority of the federal government to require everyone to have health insurance. Sitting in Detroit, Judge George Caram Steeh said the government has the authority to require everyone to be covered by health insurance by 2014.
That's a major blow to the 20 states who are are suing the federal government because they say the law, which requires individuals to have health insurance, is an attempt by the government to overreach its authority.
Steeh said that requiring everyone to have insurance would "lower the overall cost of insurance by requiring participation."
"Without the minimum coverage provision, there would be an incentive for some individuals to wait to purchase health insurance until they needed care, knowing that insurance would be available at all times," the judge said. "As a result, the most costly individuals would be in the insurance system and the least costly would be outside it," Steeh said. "In turn, this would aggravate current problems with cost-shifting and lead to even higher premiums."
The ruling, though non-binding, bodes well for efforts of the Obama Administration to provide all American citizens with health coverage.
It's something that you think everyone in one of the richest countries in the history of the world would have, especially given the cost to taxpayers to fund a broken health care system that sees many poor people using the emergency room as a primary care clinic.
"The court found that the minimum coverage provision of the statute was a reasonable means for Congress to take in reforming our health care system," Justice Department spokeswoman Tracy Schmaler told the AP. "The department will continue to vigorously defend this law in ongoing litigation."
It's also ironic how several of the 20 states suing the federal government over the unconstitutionality of health care reform are already partaking of money provided by the law.
Arizona, Idaho, Indiana, Louisiana, Michigan, Nebraska and Nevada are receiving money provided under the new law to cover the health care costs of retired state employees while also opposing the law. Six of the states are headed by Republican governors.
The rhetoric surrounding health care has been unfairly turned into a debate about freedoms. It seems that common sense is being tossed out while the well-being of our fellow citizens is being discarded.
It's especially outrageous that one of the plaintiffs in the Detroit suit is the Thomas More Law Center, a national Christian public interest law firm. One would think Christians would be interested in providing as many people as possible with decent health care.
Richard Thompson, president and chief counsel of the group, told the Detroit Free Press that he will challenge the judge's order.
"ObamaCare is one of the most oppressive measures in the history of our nation," Thompson said in a statement. "And it was passed by Congress, despite overwhelming opposition of the American people. It was not about reforming health care, but government seizure of unprecedented power over our lives."
Being able to go to the doctor and not going bankrupt because you've become ill is oppressive? The cost of Americans not having health insurance is simply too great. It is the government who ends up shouldering the costs of those who do not have insurance anyway.
"Almost every single learned scholar who has a reputation in constitutional law knows that this law is constitutional by virtue of the commerce clause, which was decided in the 1930s that the federal government has jurisdiction over economic matters that cross state lines and are significant to the national economy," John Freeman, Michigan director of Health Care for America Now, a national coalition of individuals and organizations working to reform health care, told the Detroit Free Press. "It is obviously clear, with health care representing one fourth of the economy, that this is going to meet that standard."
A Florida judge has allowed the 20 state lawsuit challenge to health care reform to go forward. A ruling on whether to dismiss the case is expected next week, but I have a feeling this will end up at the Supreme Court.
28-Sep-10 - Trying to get various black public figures to speak out for or against Bishop Eddie Long has been harder than getting 4-year-olds to go to the dentist. No one is talking, but everyone is paying attention.
27-Sep-10 - Jessica Moore, 19, was hanging out at an off-campus frat party Saturday, when a man who was angry about not getting in to the party, came back with a gun and started shooting. Moore was shot in the head.
23-Sep-10 - Some really "interesting" pictures of Bishop Eddie Long, which were allegedly sent by Long to one of his "spiritual sons," were made public last week.
22-Sep-10 - According to federal authorities, Jesse Jackson Jr. not only tried to buy President Barack Obama's former Senate seat from Rod Blagojevich, but he also had a fundraiser pay for two airline trips for a blond mistress.
17-Sep-10 - James Jones was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct and disturbing a school function for protecting his disabled young daughter from heartless bullies.
16-Sep-10 - Vancouver police confirmed that Bethany Storro lied about a black woman throwing acid on her face. Storro actually threw the acid on herself.
"ObamaCare is one of the most oppressive measures in the history of our nation," Thompson said in a statement. "And it was passed by Congress, despite overwhelming opposition of the American people. It was not about reforming health care, but government seizure of unprecedented power over our lives."
Correction Mr. Thompson, the most oppressive measures in our countries history was slavery, the Japanese internment camps.
Health care was badly needed, since the days of roosvelt health care should have been passed, no two parties had any excuse, if they passed social security way back then health care should have been passed in the days of roosvelt, but america wanted the good times to role, with almost 50 million americans without health care this could not be allowed to continue, americans if they check in their heart of hearts know that this could not be allowed to continue, do you hear the people of Boston complaining about their health care that they have? no so what is good for boston is good for the rest of america, watch the movie John Q to remind you what it was like and if you can recongise a few americans talking about health care back then.
Obama care is legal my butt....just another excuse to give ghetto dwellers some more free bennies Thank God this Idiot in the Capitol will be gone in about 2 years,,I hope the USA last that long
I do not understand why the real poor white trash that frequents BV is against any program that will help you out of the trailer park. All the social programs you rail against are predominantly used by white americans. Moreover, the repubs don't want your real poor a$$ for nothing but a vote.
@marcia & jackfreeman, I take it you already have health care? but didn't want the rest of americans to have health care, as usual you want us to do all the work and you step over are backs and say if it wasn't for you (whites) we wouldn't have health care, you can say the same thing that if it wasn't for blacks america wouldn't be the greatest country on the earth, but hay this ship goes down together!
Americans should have had a health care bill passed decades ago-it's a shame that in the richest country in the world-most people have to lose the shirt off of their back in order to pay for health care!
There are people who neglect getting needed medical care or medicine because the cost is too high!
Not everybody lives in low income housing where lights & gas are included and receives medicaid!
some even lost their homes, never mind the shirt of their backs, but i quess white people could afford it huh, those who were demonstrating against it and the veil emails you them against the bill you saw it, they had no solution themselves, they were putting up a brave face but they new they couldn't afford to keep paying the raising price of health, i wounder did they ever watch John Q on dvd, go watch.
Healthcare,just like vaccines are all about population control.Sick healthcare system that keeps people chronically ill,until death sets in.Check out Bill Gates on youtube talking about population control and the methods being used to put this into practice.
Rich folks don't worry about health care because the can flip out their "Platinum (Plus)" credit cards and just like magic-all their medical bills goes away. Bill Gates nor Lady O' has to worry about health insurance ( great for them).
" Shirt off your back" is slang for lose everything-and yes that includes the house ;{
Sadly-those folks who fall into this category-is the middle class Americans!
Comments: (15)
Add a comment
By: girlking on 10/08/2010 3:41PM
"ObamaCare is one of the most oppressive measures in the history of our nation," Thompson said in a statement. "And it was passed by Congress, despite overwhelming opposition of the American people. It was not about reforming health care, but government seizure of unprecedented power over our lives."
Correction Mr. Thompson, the most oppressive measures in our countries history was slavery, the Japanese internment camps.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: alie on 10/09/2010 10:08AM
Health care was badly needed, since the days of roosvelt health care should have been passed, no two parties had any excuse, if they passed social security way back then health care should have been passed in the days of roosvelt, but america wanted the good times to role, with almost 50 million americans without health care this could not be allowed to continue, americans if they check in their heart of hearts know that this could not be allowed to continue, do you hear the people of Boston complaining about their health care that they have? no so what is good for boston is good for the rest of america, watch the movie John Q to remind you what it was like and if you can recongise a few americans talking about health care back then.
Report This
By: marcia on 10/08/2010 4:05PM
Obama care is legal my butt....just another excuse to give ghetto dwellers some more free bennies
Thank God this Idiot in the Capitol will be gone in about 2 years,,I hope the USA last that long
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: clifton ford on 10/11/2010 11:20AM
I do not understand why the real poor white trash that frequents BV is against any program that will help you out of the trailer park. All the social programs you rail against are predominantly used by white americans. Moreover, the repubs don't want your real poor a$$ for nothing but a vote.
Report This
By: jackfreeman0046 on 10/09/2010 10:51AM
2
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: alie on 10/09/2010 1:04PM
@marcia & jackfreeman, I take it you already have health care? but didn't want the rest of americans to have health care, as usual you want us to do all the work and you step over are backs and say if it wasn't for you (whites) we wouldn't have health care, you can say the same thing that if it wasn't for blacks america wouldn't be the greatest country on the earth, but hay this ship goes down together!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: poetrysez on 10/10/2010 9:20AM
Americans should have had a health care bill passed decades ago-it's a shame that in the richest country in the world-most people have to lose the shirt off of their back in order to pay for health care!
There are people who neglect getting needed medical care or medicine because the cost is too high!
Not everybody lives in low income housing where lights & gas are included and receives medicaid!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: alie on 10/10/2010 9:39AM
some even lost their homes, never mind the shirt of their backs, but i quess white people could afford it huh, those who were demonstrating against it and the veil emails you them against the bill you saw it, they had no solution themselves, they were putting up a brave face but they new they couldn't afford to keep paying the raising price of health, i wounder did they ever watch John Q on dvd, go watch.
Report This
By: cocoabear on 10/10/2010 11:28AM
Healthcare,just like vaccines are all about population control.Sick healthcare system that keeps people chronically ill,until death sets in.Check out Bill Gates on youtube talking about population control and the methods being used to put this into practice.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: poetrysez on 10/10/2010 11:24AM
Rich folks don't worry about health care because the can flip out their "Platinum (Plus)" credit cards and just like magic-all their medical bills goes away. Bill Gates nor Lady O' has to worry about health insurance ( great for them).
" Shirt off your back" is slang for lose everything-and yes that includes the house ;{
Sadly-those folks who fall into this category-is the middle class Americans!
Reply to this Comment | Report This