
I gave in to my curiosity. I read all the blogs, the critiques, the reviews, listened to the arguments, resisted the temptation to pick up a copy from the dude at the store around the corner (mostly because of the recent declining quality of New York bootlegging), scraped up $24 in pennies and bought tickets to see Tyler Perry's 'For Colored Girls.'
Seeing the film brought me to one conclusion: Tyler Perry is now one of the greatest black women since Mahalia Jackson.
Now when I say that, I mean it in the same sense that Toni Morrison meant Bill Clinton was the first black president. Her reference was in the context of how the 42nd president was being treated in light of the Monica Lewinsky scandal. "I said he was being treated like a black on the street, already guilty, already a perp," she told Time magazine.
In that same regard, Perry has become one of history's leading black women because of his ability to understand, reflect, attract, manipulate and directly appeal to that singular niche market. And I'll be damned if he ain't good at it, so like an honorary degree, that should earn him an honorary set of bloomers --other than the one he wears when he's playing Madea.
Am I being a smart a** or hater? Not any more than in anything else I've ever written.
My point is there has already been so much written about how Perry is putting down black men, how he's fueling unfounded black female anger at brothers, how there are no positive roles for black men in Hollywood, how we're always vilified on film, and how we're always portrayed as little more than sleaze, or as particular archetypes -- in this case either a date rapist, a homicidal veteran, a serial cheater or the infamous closeted homosexual (the "D.L. boogeyman").
Dude, I'm so over that.
What I want to focus on is this cat's genius. Now as a film, I thought it amounted to little more than dysfunction porn that really bastardized a classic piece of black theater, and reduced the characters to his typical two-dimensional protagonists (victimized black women) and antagonists (destructive black men, with the exception of Hill Harper, who was there to suggest we ain't all bad).
Whatever.
In reality, Perry is doing what Booker T. Washington did a century ago. Not everybody agrees with him. Not everybody even likes him, but you can't knock the hustle. What Washington did was keep people talking.
Then he did something else: He built what is now Tuskegee University through sweat equity and blind faith in the hopes that black folk would build their way out of Jim Crow destitution. Did it get us our 40 Acres and a Mule? Nope. But we did get one of our most storied institutions out of the deal.
Similarly, Perry built his Atlanta studio based on his recognition of what his market is: black women who will literally spend millions of their disposable income to see preachy, bland movies that vaguely reflect their lives. They don't have to be good, they just have to feel like they can relate. And somehow he managed to employ 300 people, mostly black Atlantans, who otherwise would never get a chance in the movie biz.
If you don't like that Kool-Aid, then mix a new flavor, darn it. It's as simple as that.
Now recently, I took a beat-down from a sista who told me that Perry's work in 'For Colored Girls' reflected a black woman's pain. But I've got to question that. Each of the situations in that movie, and in Ntozake Shange's original work, which the film is based on, is not unique to black women.
I'm sorry, but sistas do not have a monopoly on the type of suffering depicted in the movie, just like brothers don't have a monopoly on the offenses perpetuated in it.
When I think of things black women have gone through uniquely, something I can call "a black woman's pain," I think of Betty Shabazz, Assata Shakur, Winnie Mandela, Myrlie Evers, Coretta Scott King, Fannie Lou Hamer, Angela Davis and so many other women who went through what they went through specifically because they were black.
What this work does is show a reaction of women who are black in those particular situations, but in real life they would not necessarily be because they are black, but because they are human.
So let's not walk around blaming Perry for beating up on black men -- I don't. Full disclosure, I've spend hundreds of dollars of my own money on rap music that dragged black women through the mud. In fact, I was the first person I knew of to have a copy of Snoop Dogg's misogynistic 'Doggystyle,' and nobody asked me to apologize, so black women shouldn't have to apologize for forking their money over to Perry.
What we should understand is that all Perry did was make a movie and get paid. That's what he does. And if we want movies to be made that are different than what Perry is offering, all we need to do is show that we will put our money behind alternatives.
Until then, hallelu-yer!!


Comments: (21)
Add a comment
By: Brady on 11/23/2010 2:20PM
I agree, personally Ive never liked any of his stuff, but Ive got no problem with those that do, or that Mr Perry puts out his product. No problem there.
However I do have a problem with those who suppose, that others like myself are required to run to the theaters and support Perry becuase he is black, regardless of what i think of the product. Im not going to do that.
Other than that, good luck to Mr. Perry
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Jenifer Daniels on 11/23/2010 2:43PM
love it! my sentiments exactly
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Kicia on 11/23/2010 2:38PM
Unless you have been a women in pain especially a black women in pain then maybe you can comment. For Color Girls opened a lot of realities for women who have hidden secrets, roots on unresolved family issues, been raped or even had a back door abortion. I think what Tyler does in his movies is leaving the crowd thinking, praying and talking. And yes, white women have these issues also, but they tell, sisters don't tell, they hold until they explode. As the suthor of this piece on Tyler, you should maybe poll women, especially black women to get there feelings. I left the movie sad, but also reflected on my past and what has happened you me, you may be setting next to a young lady who has been raped and not even know it, I have heard of babies in areas whp have been killed by a parent, we see ladies given there bodies away everyday, what part of Tyler don't you understand as a human!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: clarke on 11/23/2010 3:37PM
WHY DON'T YOU GO TO A DAMN THERAPIST. DO WE REALLY HAVE TO KEEP TALKING ABOUT HIS MAN AND HIS CRAPPY ASS MOVIES? DAMN LET IT GO AND GET SOME PROFESSIONAL HELP PLEASE.
Report This
By: djkut on 11/23/2010 3:59PM
I think right now, we need to be educated this is not a "Woman thou Art Loose " or " I am Woman hear me Roar Rally". Eventhough in our community we have some issues that we need to work on.
We have to start incorporating more positive movies from beginning to end. There is a difference between a struggle than a straight up lynching of certain types of black folks in some of Tyler's movies.
More women will fight for the plight of Tyler Perry movies than the future of all blacks and we have to stop arguring over sexism issues so much , but lets keep it real.
Tyler base is for mostly Black Women, Women looking for Jesus to find them a Man, Women who fought through issues, and Women with alot Mary J Blige, Fantasia, and Keshia Cole stuff going on....LOL.LOL
Report This
By: sedata on 11/23/2010 3:00PM
did this clown madison grey just compare tyler perry fruity a** to booker t washington. black voices he should be fired for that
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Gee on 11/26/2010 11:43AM
Sedata who said that Mr Perry is fruity....how do you know that Booker T was not fruity?
Report This
By: LaShelle Howard on 11/23/2010 3:41PM
I agree that the pain depicted in this movie is not monopolized by black women but that is the genius of this movie. It does not matter your color if you are a women and have experienced pain then you can relate. I think Tyler did an excellent job and I think he is more than a man in a women's suit. He is a brother opening doors for folks. Some may not agree with the doors he's opening but he makes a venue for black folk to express themselves and that's a hell of alot more than a lot of folks are doing. I wish him tons of blessings
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: bondskg on 11/23/2010 3:55PM
Why are we our own worst critics? I just don't get why there is so much negativity from our own people towards others who look like us who are trying to tell a story or experience. When will we ever unite as a people and support our businesses and those like Tyler Perry who at least are keeping black culture alive and well when white hollywood continues to dis us....but we keep giving them our ticket money...and chastize Tyler's films each time they come out. Go figure?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: clarke on 11/23/2010 5:22PM
IT'S REAL SIMPLE TO UNDERSTAND. BECAUSE THEY ARE CRAPPY MOVIES. I DONT CARE IF EVERY BLACK PERSON THATS ACTS IS IN THE DAMN MOVIE I AM NOT PAYING, SITTING AND WATCHING A BAD MOVIE JUST BECAUSE A BLACK PERSON MADE IT AND BLACK PEOPLE ARE IN IT. IT JUST AINT GONNA HAPPEN. HIS MOVIES DO NOT MEET MY STANDARDS FOR WHAT
I CONSIDER ENTERTAINMENT. MADEA BE DAMNED.
Report This