![]()
Troy Dale West (pictured above) had only been sentenced to six months in prison for beating Tasha Hill (pictured below), after they had words while both trying to enter a Cracker Barrel restaurant.
West allegedly punched Hill in the face, kicked her as she fell to the ground and yelled racial epithets."I heard my daughter screaming, 'Mommy! Mommy!"' Hill said. "I was scared. I didn't know why it was happening."
During the trial, West's defense presented Hill as a hothead with a history of violence who spit on West and initiated the encounter. While evidence shows that Hill certainly may need anger counseling, West's brutal attack on this woman is inexcusable. I wonder would he have been as quick to attack a man of similar stature?
Despite the beat-down that he issued to a woman, West pleaded to misdemeanor charges in a plea deal that netted him only six months behind bars; he was facing felony charges and 44 years in jail.
It's even more of an insult that West did not serve the length of his short term. Given the way he beat Hill, isn't anyone concerned that this guy might be easy to set off and that he needs to learn there are serious consequences for unjustified violence?
"Someone that abuses a dog gets more time than West got," Hill's lawyer, Mawuli Mel Davis said.
The sheriff in Clayton County, Georgia, said West received two days of time served credit for every day he painted trailers. He also acknowledged receiving pressure from West's friends to release him early, but said he did not relent.
I don't think we should take his word for it. An independent authority should launch an investigation.
Even more disturbing is that I can't imagine a black man in Georgia getting this sort of break if he had beat a white woman, even a white woman who had spit on him. The scars of racial injustice run deep in the South.
"Where I'm from, Mr. West, it's not good for a man to hit a woman. Also, where I'm from, it's not good to spit on a person. I can only imagine what my response would have been," Judge Geronda V. Carter said during her sentencing.

However, West, who was a foot taller and weighed more than 100 pounds than Hill, could have easily killed her. I would be moved to the point of anger if anyone spit on me, but the right thing for West to do would have been to contact police.
West's release also sends a message to African Americans that the justice system does not look out for us. When you talk to young black men who carry illegal weapons, many of them will say that they feel it is necessary to protect themselves because the system is not going to.
Hill's attitude was no excuse for the beat-down she received in front of her child.
She'll probably proceed with her civil suit, but given some of the evidence presented during the trial, she should also proceed to anger-management counseling. Every hot head needs to remember that they could run in to their match one day.
That said, we need to learn to treat one another how we would want to be treated. Despite the stress of life, work and kids, it's not right to take that stress out on someone else.



Comments: (150)
Add a comment
By: Uriah Jordan on 12/14/2010 9:58AM
Where is that self-hating woman that wrote 8 reasons to date a white man? Now she can add another to the list; he can whup yo' fool ass and be home before you get home from the hospital.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: The Truth on 12/14/2010 12:03PM
Generally it's not "OK" to hit anyone, but it's hard to say what I would have done if someone thought it was "OK" to get all up in my face and deliver a snot rocket.
Report This
By: Government cheese on 12/14/2010 2:27PM
He served his time. At least he did not murder and decapitate 2 people.
Report This
By: JAMES on 12/14/2010 2:28PM
That's why I cannot understand why black women go with white guys and black guys going with white women. Because if a problem arises they are surely see the black person less than a human being they can't help they have been taught from great grandmothers and great grandfather 'blacks are lower than a dog reguardless where they reach in life on this earth. And see how the laws are? they are only meant for black folks not whites. This man will get his soon or later. His never would had thought about doing to a black man from that state and it shows his hate for blacks he would try that sh.... in Mich
Report This
By: White man on 12/14/2010 2:30PM
Someone got pimp slapped!
Report This
By: tiffany on 12/14/2010 4:05PM
she was not dating this guy...so how in the hell did you jump from this to interracial dating? You and the others sound so stupid. Go to your local prison and see how many brothas are in there for violence against women. Stop being so delusional.
Report This
By: dsaqt4life on 12/14/2010 5:23PM
i don't really believe in interracial dating either, uriah, but what does this case have to do with dating white men? they were strangers to one another until this incident.
Report This
By: Eugene on 12/14/2010 10:09PM
Where is that loud mouth Gloria Allred? Where is the National Organization of Women? They are usually the first ones to jump up and down when a woman is wronged by a man. Oh, wait. That is right. This is a black woman so she does not really count in their eyes. This just goes to show that blacks are really seen as three-fifths of a person and based on this case that fraction may be lower.
Report This
By: john on 12/16/2010 9:57PM
Why wasn't this woman charged with assault for spitting. She have had HIV,etc. She got what she deserved. I am a black man.
Report This
By: corneliusflower on 12/14/2010 10:00AM
blacks know the justice system don't work..maybe because we, as blacks, don't work together and take care of each other. If something does not work, then find something that works. Whites and other races are treating us..just as we treat each other.
let a white man beat a black woman where I come from, his arse is over. georgia people are so busy trying to be everything else other than who they truly are.. no wonder. all those blacks there and you telling me, not one black man jumped in and protect this sista. we are much at fault.
we want a system to protect us, but we can't protect each other...no wonder. all we want to do is march up and down the street singing "we shall over come".. HA!
Reply to this Comment | Report This