
Since stepping down from her role as America's sweetheart on NBC's "Today Show" to make history as the first female anchor of "CBS Evening News," media mainstay Katie Couric has had a tumultuous time.
From charges of plagiarism and incompetence to being named Keith Olbermann's "Worst Person in the World" to being the catalyst behind the "Evening News" worst ratings in history, Couric's image as a media darling has more than frayed at the edges.
This past weekend, Couric commented about the "seething hatred" many Americans have toward Muslim Americans:
"Maybe we need a Muslim version of 'The Cosby Show'... I know that sounds crazy, I know that sounds crazy," said Couric. "But 'The Cosby Show' did so much to change attitudes about African Americans in this country, and I think sometimes people are afraid of things they don't understand."Islamophobia in this country most recently stems from the 9/11 attacks and has manifested into atrocious hate crimes (up 70 percent in the years following the bombing of the World Trade Center) against Muslims, discriminatory legislation such as the Patriot Act and the fervent opposition to the mosque near Ground Zero.
Katie Couric's statement reeks of well-intentioned ignorance and arrogance.
In essence, Couric is saying that to diminish discrimination against and hatred of Muslims, we must show them in a light that is non-threatening to Americans. A safe, feel good, family dramedy-similar to Canada's "Little Mosque on the Prairie," which only skims the surface of real life issues such as drinking and overeating.
At the time the "Cosby Show" was running, it was the 1980s. The decade of AIDS, the crack-cocaine epidemic, the Cold War and hip-hop as an emerging voice to convey the societal issues that were rampant in our communities ... and the "Cosby Show" avoided these issues like the plague.
I would be the first to say that there are ample negative depictions of African Americans, and Dr. Bill Cosby filled a need in mainstream culture absent for too long: a glimpse at a successful black family.
The focus on education and cultural awareness was a much-needed breath of fresh air in the midst of the usual stereotypical images prevalent on television, and the show's necessity and positive influence should not be denied.
However, I will also be the first to say that he missed an optimal opportunity to address the issues in our communities he claims to champion so passionately.
And therein lies the crux of the matter, Katie.
Muslim Americans are not a threat. Radical Muslims are the threat. Catholic organizations, such as Opus Dei and their protection of pedophiles within the church are the threat. Political zealots, such as Timothy McVeigh, are threats.
A Muslim "Cosby Show" would perhaps serve the purpose of entertainment and self-identification for those followers of Islam who only see themselves portrayed negatively in the media, and that goal is not without merit. However, Muslims do not need a white-washed sitcom to sooth the bigoted fears of those who choose to paint them all with the same terrorist brush, and to say they do, or to suggest such a show would promote religious tolerance in this country is either extremely naïve or extremely offensive.
I would like to see a show that depicts a Muslim family in Iraq suffering through this country's invasion, watching soldiers rape their women and children, blow up civilians and stamp out their governmental system - all on the whim of one president.
Or maybe a show that follows a Muslim family in America as they get disproportionately searched in airports and profiled at public events - all while trying to succeed in a country where they are labeled terrorists.
I'm sure it would be a hit.
You say people fear what they don't understand, Katie. Well, understand this:
Until you have a better grasp of the complexities of religion and living as a minority in this country, whether due to religion or ethnicity, maybe you should avoid conversations of depth all together.
After all, that's what the "Cosby Show" did.



Comments: (15)
Add a comment
By: Scott on 1/03/2011 3:14PM
Actually katie, That seething hatred is for you...
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kieraht on 1/03/2011 4:37PM
I see her comments in a completely different way. Muslim Americans are portrayed as angry, militant Blacks, scared and simple convenience shops owners, or terrorists. Can we see something besides those archetypes in the media?
Certainly The Cosby Show wasn't everybody's story, but it did make me wonder if it could be my story? My life was definitely more Cosby Show than Good Times. Why assume that everybody is having the experience?
Everything you watch on TV is an ad or promotion - promoting a product, a service, a lifestyle, or culture. Why not promote a different image of Muslims? There is a reason why we don't. We don't want non-Muslims relating to Muslims because who would be our boogey man then.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Marlene Franklin on 1/04/2011 11:18AM
Whites would be the new boogy man/woman, and rightly so.
Report This
By: Rasheed on 1/03/2011 7:14PM
"Muslim Americans are not a threat. Radical Muslims are the threat. Catholic organizations, such as Opus Dei and their protection of pedophiles within the church are the threat. Religious zealots, such as Timothy McVeigh, are threats." I don't know anything about the author but the authors above quoted premise adds more to the anti-Islam attacks. "Radicals"is a equal to "terrorist" in the history of the black movement anyone with strong feeling opposing injustice were labeled "radical or militant" so as to dismiss them, most radical Muslims are not terrorists. I would have not problem with a "Cosby" type show but don't think it should be a platform for my views. The writer should carry that mantle and not just the obvious injustices occuring in the US, but the support of Israel's occupation and brutal repression of Palestine,attacks on Lebanon, and the US continued occupation of Iraq and interference in Iran.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Marlene Franklin on 1/04/2011 11:26AM
I guess whenever a person of color fights back, they are called terrorist radicals. When whites fight back they are called patriots.
Report This
By: Tina on 1/03/2011 8:19PM
Once again BV needs to fact-check its writers. Timothy McVeigh was an atheist and not a religious zealot. He committed his terrorism in reaction to Waco. That is documented out of his own mouth. But you and other writers continue to lie when the truth is out there on 60 Minutes. Also, recently in the news, there was a report about how the vast majority of accusations against priests are false. Please stop adding to the miseducation of the masses.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: black conservative on 1/03/2011 10:02PM
Katie can play the Mother,maybe the ratings will be better than her evening news show,which are the lowest of all Networks............
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: renee on 1/03/2011 10:30PM
shes an idiot.....
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Hafsa on 1/04/2011 3:43AM
I really couldn't have said it better myself. A funny little sitcom alone will not put Muslims in a better light, anyone who thinks so is undermining the intelligence of the public. I do think however, something different needs to be done in the media though; for too long Muslims are victimised in the media in the most disgusting way and it's deemed to be okay because 'they're only Muslims, who cares' but if there is something out there in the media that provides a platform to what REAL Muslims are like, then I think it'll help. The best thing to do is to look at other oppressed peoples in the past such as Jews and African Americans; sure they're still discriminated against but, not as much as in the past and Muslims need to see what those people did to get themselves as regular people in the society.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kbroome1969 on 1/04/2011 9:50AM
who wants to watch that kind of crap... its bad enough that NBC has some wacked out show called OUTSOURCED....on.. and to me thats making fun of american jobs thats been lost... to overseas....another reason why NBC sucks
Reply to this Comment | Report This