
Smith, who is from Elgin, Illinois, was expected to serve a few days in jail for violating his probation on a drug charge. The room was actually a conference room that had been turned into a holding cell temporarily.
The Kane County Sheriff's office announced today that there would be an investigation to find out what happened. They also said that the cell was "not normally used to house inmates when court is not in session."
Smith says that he's pursuing his legal options in the matter, but his case brings us to the larger issue of human rights for those who are incarcerated. While we might be in love with the idea that anyone who is arrested for a crime deserves whatever they get, one must stop and realize how this takes our society down a very slippery slope. Consistent abuses such as beatings by guards, malnutrition or prison rape should not be part of the criminal justice package in America, for it makes us no better than the countries we critique around the world.
The United States incarcerates more of its citizens than any country earth, so most of us are one bad situation away from finding ourselves in a holding cell. While we would fully expect to be punished for violating the law, broader systemic changes are in order to ensure that there is a baseline of decency used when we deal with those who are incarcerated. These are our sisters, brothers, cousins and children, so there must be a limit to our vengeance.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action Resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 

Comments: (12)
Add a comment
By: LeRoy Watermelon Jackson on 1/06/2011 2:02PM
AAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW......QUIT PUSHING DOPE, ROBBING AND KILLING PEOPLE
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: westfall on 1/06/2011 2:24PM
Ok.....only when you quit being a fool. The man is still a human being. You're probably one of the people outraged about the "Vick dogs," and have no compassion for human life.
Report This
By: SAY WHAT! on 1/08/2011 9:34AM
Bet he'll think twice next time.
Emotional scars! OH PLEASE!
Report This
By: bob on 1/06/2011 4:21PM
Good! Maybe next time he will not violate his parole!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: diesel2k1 on 2/15/2011 2:59AM
youre sick !! just the type of person who would applaud the mistreating of any human being... u disgust me !
Report This
By: jeromequigley on 1/06/2011 5:06PM
Ah another misleading story by the King of smoke and mirrors. Dr W, headline leads one to believe that this person was "KEPT" in this cell handcuffed w/out food or toilet for 18 hours on purpose. I back that up with the his line of "Smith says that he's pursuing his legal options in the matter, but his case brings us to the larger issue of human rights for those who are incarcerated." Why would a situation where a gentleman who was left in a Temporary make shift holding cell "by accident" be an example of not treating some one with his "human rights" in mind?? OH THAT'S RIGHT, BECAUSE NO WHERE DOES DR W TELL THE READERS THAT THE GENTLEMAN WAS LEFT IN THERE BY ACCIDENT!! DUH ME, I FORGOT THAT HE HAD TO MIS-LEAD THE READER TO STAND ON HIS SOAP BOX TO PREACH ABOUT PRISONER ABUSE!! The guy was left in there by accident, no one cuffed him and stuck him in there with the intention of punishing him or making him pay! IT WAS A FREAKING ACCIDENT! Now does that mean it was not a bad experience for the gentleman, well He** no! I am sure it was awful(especially the bathroom part)! That and being cuffed from behind, cuzz lets face it the food and water deal, while not kool at all, is something we have all gone with out for that long before. TO STRESS, NOT THAT IT WAS GOOD OR ANYTHING THAT HE WENT WITH OUT FOOD OR WATER FOR THAT LONG!! But I just can't stand the way Dr W continues to give shifted and false info just so he can back up his own agenda!! The judge apologized to the gentleman who accepted it as sincere. So that should be that. Sorry but there is no way he should be given any lawsuit money for this! that last part is my opinion on any "legal options" Dr W mentions. But Dr W is not getting away with his Lies any more. More and more peepz are exposing him and his lies and hopefully he will be told to leave BV for it!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: westfall on 1/06/2011 5:49PM
Listen up Jerome, no one is saying that it was done intentionally. But when people are getting paid to do a job, and things like this "mistake" happens, then you have to wonder about the compentency of the staff. Incompetence is what fosters lawsuits. Now the parole violater is a victim and rightly so.
Report This
By: andrea on 1/07/2011 11:38AM
Jerome, i agree with you here, and on other comments you have made regarding this Dr Watkins, He is almost always playing the "black victom" card. I understand this site is here for us but no everything has to be this big ol' civil/human rights injustice. Just like he didnt mention he was left on accident. He just wants the readers to get worked up but in reality, it was an accident, and he is a drug user, and drugs have ruined our community. I dont feel bad for someone who has been caught, charged, released on probation restrictions, and then commits the same crime again. Maybe it was an accident or maybe not, but the bottom line is just b/c he is out "brother" dont mean that we have to feel sorry for his mistreatment, what has he added to our community? he is a junkie trying to make a buck off of the justice system so he can blow is on drugs, and he will make that money if people buy into the article above.
Report This
By: jeromequigley on 1/08/2011 12:33PM
@westfall: on the point of no one is saying it was done intentionally. You know it was not, I know it was not and so do others who took time to read about this situation from others sources. HOWEVER, Dr W is very good at leaving bits and pieces out that can lead some one to believe what Dr W wants, with out him actually saying an out right lie! No where did he mention that this was done on accident? But oddly enough at the end of his article he starts going into talkin about "human rights" and "abuse". Which again is true, but that is not what happened here. But by adding those little things and again NOT disclosing that it was an accident. He does try and get the reader to start to think it was done out of malice! I just don't like sneaky agenda's!! Tell it like it is, dig for as much truth as you can get, but do not use a story and twist it to fit your own agenda!! That to me is just LOW!! As for the guy, well of course what happened to him was AWFUL!! I posted that the first time. I have been in the same situation (but for much longer periods of torcher) so I empathize with what he went through. But to say he should get a pay day from it...HE** NO!! If we do than all the kids and adults he sold drugs to and got them hooked should get the money! Let the families of the victims of his actions get paid! The families detroyed, the neighborhoods that had increased crime because he was there, because his clients decided to steal to get their fix!! See what I am sayin? This is out of RESPECT WESTFALL, I have seen your post and know that you are a very smart person who has empathy for all! So this is just a response not a slam in any way!!
@ ANDREA..THANKS FOR HAVING MY BACK!!!
Report This
By: walker on 1/08/2011 2:14PM
people have the wrong concept! people go to prison[ AS punishment ]NOTFOR PUNISHMENT!!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This