
As I got older and studied the life of Dr. King, I quickly realized that his life was very different from my own. He accomplished far more at an early age than I did. He had far more respect than I did. He was a better student than I was. How could I ever match up to that?
But it was OK that I couldn't match Dr. King, primarily because it had been confirmed to me in one celebration after another that I couldn't be anything like that man even if I'd wanted to be. He was superhuman, and I was not. So, rather than having the confidence to continue his legacy, I figured that I would just sit back and enjoy the celebration like everyone else. Why try to match up with perfection?
So, years later, after the celebration of the King holiday has become a great American tradition, I've noticed that Dr. King the legend has escaped even further from the grasp of our children. He has been elevated to live among the Greek Gods, as if he walked on water and could turn 'chitlins' into kool-aid. He was clearly, without question, more ethical, intelligent, creative, brave, focused and capable than any of the six billion human beings on earth could ever try to be.
Maybe it's time to take a second to reconsider just how much damage we've done to King's memory by making him into a excessively commercialized, sloppily-quoted deity. First, Dr. King would be furious that we're teaching our children that they are not as capable as he once was. He started his work for it to be continued, not for it to be relegated to the history books. With African Americans lying at the bottom of nearly every socio-economic quality of life measure, there is much work to be done. Dr. King knew he wouldn't get there with us, but he left it to us to finish the struggle. Instead, the closest any of us think we can come to Dr. King is the picture on our living room wall. When one soldier shows bravery in battle, the last thing he wants is for the other soldiers to stand around applauding and singing "Well shall overcome."
Secondly, by pretending that Dr. King was perfect in life, we are making his legacy vulnerable to those who can prove that he made mistakes. For example, there are some who simply wish to pretend that there was no possibility and no reason to even mention the fact that Dr. King was not always faithful to his wife, Coretta. The "don't ask, don't tell" policy that African Americans keep on our religious figures has not only ruined lives, but it makes all of us look silly. It also heightens the impact of the scandal when the truth finally hits the light of day. I had a friend in the south whose 19-year old mother was impregnated by a 45-year old married pastor. The pastor forced my friend's mother to keep the love child secret, which she did for over 20 years. So, my friend grew up watching her "sanctified" daddy walk right past her in public places without even acknowledging her. You think that might have affected her psychologically? Yes, it did.
If Dr. King cheated on his wife, then so be it. Let the historians analyze it the same way they will discuss the life of former President Bill Clinton. But also like Clinton, once the scandals have been processed, they will remember King's positive contributions to society. The world still loves Bill Clinton, even though he slept with Monica. The last thing we need is to try to maintain a flawless and artificially polished image of King, only to watch the world turn him into another Tiger Woods.
When I recently wrote about how African Americans might want to process King's alleged adultery, I got a lot of angry responses from people who felt that the subject shouldn't even be touched. I quickly found out that no matter how respectfully something is brought up, some issues are off limits when it comes to Dr. King or Barack Obama. But by closing our eyes and ears to the truth of who Dr. King really was, we are only further committing ourselves to ignorance and doing King the disservice of putting him on a pedestal on which no man can comfortably survive. If we want to support the memory of Dr. King, we must support it with truth and full acknowledgement that he was human like the rest of us. We must remind one another that not only can we become every bit as great as Dr. King, we should aim to build off his mistakes and exceed him. There is a Dr. King inside all of us, and even if we are less than perfect, we can still do something great for the world.
This is what I'll be teaching my kids on King Day: Dr. King was a great man who made mistakes like everyone else. But in spite of his mistakes, he kept his eye on the prize and did amazing things. My kids must understand that they will fall on their faces, embarrass themselves and find obstacles at every turn. But by maintaing a commitment to their value systems, becoming educated, courageously striving for their goals and pursuing their purpose with passion, they can continue the outstanding work of Dr. King and all the others who died to give them an opportunity. We don't have time to sit and worship anyone, there's too much work to do.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action Resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 

Comments: (49)
Add a comment
By: Ardis Walton on 1/17/2011 1:08PM
This is what Jesus died for. Our sins are now in the sea of forgetfulness. What we do as human beings are a true fact that we were born in sin. What Dr. King did outside of his marriage, was sinful. When we repent of these sins, God put them in the sea of forgetfulness. That is why we don't continue to bring it up. We put our past behind us and move on and do the will of God.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: arriethom1 on 1/17/2011 3:43PM
I don't agree. The author makes a very valid point. Dr King and many other American heros made mistakes or sinned. Why should this be swept under the rug? Talking about historical figures in the true sense of who they are gives them a more human persona. The world will not judge MLK for his indiscretions like they will not judge any other famous historical figure.
Report This
By: James Ward on 1/17/2011 5:22PM
Hey Boyce, instead of pointing out the obvious concerning Dr. King..why don't you show some real courage and write an article concerning an even bigger "sacred cow" in our black community - The Democratic Party.
Dr. King gave his life fighting on BEHALF of black people - nothing could be more gracious and admirable. He should and will forever hold a special place in our hearts.
The Democratic Party..it sacrificed some lives in respect to us as well (during the Civil War), but the LIVES GIVEN and the BLOOD SHED..was for the purpose of keeping our ancestors ENSLAVED - nothing could be more DESPICABLE and DEPLORABLE. That Party (Democrat) should forever remind us of the depths to which a human soul (full of evil) can sink.
The Democratic Party also gave black Americans the Ku Klux Klan, Black Codes, Jim Crow Laws, and many DEATH THREATS to Dr. King and to other Civil Rights heroes.
Even today, The Democratic Party endorses and supports the heinous practice of ABORTION which is DESTROYING black lives far beyond anything experienced during slavery.
Early Civil Rights Pioneers, like Frederick Douglass, would be spinning in his grave if he saw how blacks practically WORSHIP the Democratic Party today.
Idolatrous WORSHIP of The Democratic Party (the Party of DEATH to our ancestors) by today's blacks...Show some courage, Boyce..and write that article!
Report This
By: Michael on 1/17/2011 2:26PM
(super)Hero worship is for 5 - 10 yo boys. Adults should know better. Good article.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Jen on 1/17/2011 4:23PM
Let Freedom REIGN, let freedom REIGN, Let freedom REIGN!
Thank God Almighty, I am FREE at last!
Happy Martin Luther King Day folks!
Report This
By: Kalynn on 1/17/2011 2:27PM
Stay on topic please, stay on topic!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Lenora on 1/17/2011 2:37PM
Well said. This article reflects my EXACT sentiments on the life and legacy of Dr. King. I wish more people (especially so-called influential African-Americans) would realize that Hero Worship is doing a disservice to the memory of Dr. King and to our future. Thank you!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Charles on 1/17/2011 2:39PM
As you point out, one danger of hero worship is to trivialize the worshiper. A second danger - one easy for us fall prey to - is to trivialize the hero's message. Dr. King would probably be disappointed to hear advice to "pick up trash in the 'hood" or to "plant flowers to make our city more beautiful" as appropriate remembrances of his message against the triple-threat of racism, poverty and militariism.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Andrea Macon on 1/19/2011 2:12AM
I totally disagree with you Dr. Boyce. Unlike Bill Clinton, Dr. King is not around to defend whether or not he had affairs or not. I just have a difficult time speaking about people who are not able to respond to my accusations. So let's keep it moving. Let's just reflect on the good that Dr. King has done, and try to do good ourselves! I also don't know why you think people worship Dr. King, because I certainly do not. I simply admire him, as do others, for the great sacrifices that he made towards civil rights!
Report This
By: Kalynn on 1/17/2011 2:43PM
Some valid points Boyce. I don't agree with you on many things Boyce because you sometimes can be way out there in left field leaving me scratching my head.
Further revelation of this article is the fact that far too often, we as African Americans have difficulty in dealing with truth which keeps us in denial, the main source of our inability to excell beyond our own imagination, we deny the reality of conditions that exist.
If you don't deal with harsh realities of where you are you'll never get to where you want to be.
King did impact change and was a great man, with his own foibles. Hiding truth is destructive. You'll find folks having parties to celebrate MLK and not know the why behind the what of the day. Hero "worship" makes many of the events perfuntory, just another something we do. We must celebrate but not elevate King to a position higher than even Jesus the true anointed one.
Reply to this Comment | Report This