
While the skit was certainly funny in its own right, it was built on a very serious set of functional inequities in America's justice system: Black men are more likely to be searched, arrested, convicted and incarcerated for crimes, even when they don't do anything wrong. While we've heard about the cases of the Scott sisters and Kelley Williams-Bolar, there are thousands of other men and women in prison who were guilty of simply being black.
The inequities of the justice system are rooted in the perceptions of juries and citizens, which lead them to believe that black men are less ethical and more criminal than the rest of our society. A nun in Brooklyn, N.Y., used these biased perceptions to her advantage after lying to police about being raped and choked by a black man.
Sister Mary Turcotte of the Apostles of Infinite Love, a sect that has no affiliation with the Catholic Church, went to police to tell her tale in dramatic fashion. Turcotte told police that the man who attacked her was a 6-foot-4 250-pound black man who dragged her and left her in a snowbank with her breasts exposed. Police then released a sketch of the suspect to the public to get help in solving the crime.
"I'm pissed off," said 33-year old Brooklyn resident Reggie Antoine. "It makes me paranoid. It makes women paranoid of us."
This is not the first case of phantom black people being accused of committing heinous crimes: Charles Stuart, in 1990, killed his pregnant wife and then said that a black man did it. Susan Smith killed her two sons in 1995 and said that a black man did it. In 2009, Bonnie Sweeten said that black men kidnapped her, when in reality, she'd actually taken her daughter to Disney World.
There are other cases of black people being falsely accused of crime, but it would take a while to list them all. Perhaps cases like this one will remind us to take a deep and serious look at the state of our criminal justice system. There are thousands of men and women incarcerated for crimes they did not commit, and our society enjoys living under the presumption that every man and woman in the prison industrial complex is somehow evil and unworthy of even the most basic of human rights. The truth is that for every case we uncover where someone has falsely accused a black man of a crime he didn't commit, there are likely several others where the liar got away with the hoax.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce's commentary delivered to your e-mail, please click here. 

Comments: (38)
Add a comment
By: Willie A on 2/03/2011 8:23AM
One more reason for black men and women to STICK TOGETHER AS A PEOPLE!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: SAY WHAT! on 2/03/2011 9:28AM
I'll bet they're mad in the other 49 states too.
Report This
By: dina on 2/03/2011 8:54PM
SAY IT AGAIN, WILLIE!!!
Report This
By: Wyllyemozelle on 2/04/2011 7:50AM
High five to you for your comments. Our lack of unity is destroying us!
Report This
By: Fred on 2/05/2011 10:43AM
I've been falsely accused myself, and I'm as white as toothpaste. The nutcase finally admitted her lies after I went through a year of hell, or else I'd be in prison now. Maybe black and white men should stick together over this prevailing belief that "a woman would never lie about such a thing", because they do. I do realize, however, that black men are victimized by this a lot more often than white men, and they usually wind up convicted. My heart goes out to them.
Report This
By: Kipper on 2/13/2011 11:48PM
And believe me, we whites wish you would! Please leave the white women alone! We know you prefer us and we know you all think we're much better looking. Of course, it seems that the only white women you get are skanky or fat, Still........
Report This
By: BETTY on 2/07/2011 6:50PM
Yes willie ,you are correct!,but some black peoplejust can't get that through their head's.It is very crucial that we as a people stick together in more way's than one!We stuck together more when we had less!
Report This
By: bob on 2/03/2011 8:25AM
Well Boyce when blacks are immune to blaming whites for things that they did not do then you can talk trash, until then why don't you close your pie hole. Twana Brawly ring a bell duke rape case? I could google it and find a lot more if you would like? Halle Berry her husband called her the n word OHHHHHHHHH NOOOOOOO! Bunch of whiners!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: RG on 2/03/2011 9:11AM
Bob,
That was a really good comment (Sarcasm). Did anyone go to jail for the Brawley case? No. The Duke case, you only know what the media gives you. I can tell you are really educated (Another sarcastic comment). Just look at the past 10 years! It seems like blaming the Black man is the "In" thing to do, and the criminal system sees it as an easy way, rather than do a thorough investigation. But I guess, you don't care to do your homework either! BTW, tell Sarah Pailin and the Tea party I said "Hey"
Report This
By: girlking on 2/03/2011 2:27PM
Bob, I can't tell if you're truly naive or just delusional with it comes to race in America. Either way it's sad. This country is wrought with legalized killing of African-American men as well as "let's blame the Black man." And please don't try to lecture us with Black on Black crime, we know it exists just like we know there is white on white crime. The examples that you listed are so far and few between from the number of instances where white people have blamed African-Americans for their crimes. And one of the reasons white people feel for entitled to blame African-Americans is because they - white people - know that people like you will automatically believe the lie just because it comes from a white person. And that's the truly sad part.
Report This