
Jon Stewart has thumped with the folks over at Fox News before, both on "The Daily Show" and on occasion, to their faces. (Last week, Stewart went on "Fox News Sunday with Chris Wallace" and mockingly, but pointedly, went in on the conservative-leaning network.)
Now Bernie Goldberg, a frequent contributor to the network, has fired back at Stewart in a FoxNews.com blogpost titled "Is Jon Stewart Racist?" In it, Goldberg argues that liberals and conservatives are held to different standards when it comes to issues of race, and when criticizing black politicians in particular. Goldberg accused Jon Stewart of impersonating Herman Cain, the Republican presidential candidate, in an "exaggerated 'Amos & Andy' 'black voice.'"
"But why isn't Jon Stewart a bigot, when Limbaugh and Hannity and O'Reilly would be tagged as racists if they had done the very same thing?" Goldberg asks. "That's easy. Because Jon Stewart is a liberal and liberals aren't racists. Only conservatives are."
Here's video that has Goldberg so incensed. (The Cain bit starts at the 1:50 mark.)
Cain has said that Stewart doesn't like him because he's a black conservative, and that he's often mocked for his political leanings. "I have been called "Uncle Tom," "sell out," "Oreo," "shameless," he said at a recent campaign event. "So the fact that he wants to mock me because I happen to be a black conservative, in the words of my grandfather, "I does not care. I does not care."
Alex Alvarez has been watching this whole kerfuffle, and laments what he sees as the cynical way charges of racism are employed in American politics. "In the long term, it serves only to reduce matters of race and ethnicity to trump cards held, at the ready, in the back pockets of pundits and politicians on either side of the aisle, to be pulled out whenever it suits either side," he writes.
To spiral off Alvarez's point, Incidents like this --- hurling allegations of racism at an ideological opponent, and then the obligatory hand-wringing over whether that person or their behavior was in fact, racist --- reaffirm the idea that being called a racist is worse than actually experiencing racism. Goldberg isn't so much concerned with discrimination so much as he's mad that he feels that his fellow conservatives get a bad rap for perpetuating it.
This brouhaha also speaks to how Cain has made his blackness a major part of to his pitch to be president. (In 2008, Obama resorted to dogwhistling to black people, but his campaign assiduously avoided talking too explicitly or too long about race.) Cain is pitching himself as a familiar type --- the aggrieved conservative dogged by the media --- but with a racialized twist. Maybe it's because he needs to find some way to differentiate himself from a field of Republican candidates that's ideologically more or less the same. But part of it is because Republicans, like Goldberg, are clamoring for cover from charges of being the party of racists (see: the selection of Michael Steele as head of the Republican National Committee).
And who better to do that for them than an actual black man? Even if he's just a fringe candidate with no shot of winning anything?


Comments: (30)
Add a comment
By: mark on 6/29/2011 7:17PM
Your comments are silly on so many fronts i do not even know where to start.
Report This
By: Ronin on 6/30/2011 11:37AM
bobsducky I agree with you, My mother's family of my family are from Panama and they are mixed and my father's side are from the Caribbean and they are also mixed. You are so right, many Black Americans are very racist and do not have any idea of how racist they really are.
For the most part Black Americans don't or will not travel outside the continental United States. I don't know why that is but they should, there is NO excuse for it. I believe if they did , they would come to a new and better understanding of themselves and of the United States.
They need to step out of the United States and look back at it, to see what is truly is. IT IS AN EYE OPENER, better yet... since so many Black Americans like to reference the Bible try this...Step out of this so called Garden of Eden (USA) and take a bite of the Apple (knowledge) and then you will be like a GOD , knowing good from evil.... and that is what "god" (American Society) doesn't want you to see or know.
Enjoy your days... Peoples of African decent
Report This
By: And? on 6/29/2011 3:32PM
@Ron-Look at the way we worship entertainers and sports stars. We don't promote education so whose fault is it white people think we're a joke? Jon Stewart isn't a racist. He's a comic and if black comics (or if Jon were black) told the same jokes we would laugh, make them richer and hand them TV shows. That's how Dave Chapelle got into trouble (I saw him on Oprah). White people were telling his "black" jokes!
Now I do agree with you on what Rhianna, Alicia Keys and Beyonce all have in common and black media is assisting in this destruction? Notice what the so called "black (Soledad, Lemon, Fredericka)" anchors look like on CNN lately but black media hails them as the greatest? Gwen Ifill doesn't have the "look" for CNN but this sista has the brain!
So until you get the black media/community to step up leave Jon Stewart the h@ alone!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Vickiss on 6/29/2011 4:06PM
Stop listening to white people.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Pink on 6/29/2011 6:47PM
Anyone that thinks Jon Stewart is a racist has never seen his show and apparently not familiar with his history. Plus no one is (really) taking Cain's bid for the presidency serious. Too bad he's not taking the money he's wasting on running and parlaying that money into jobs.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: allisine on 6/29/2011 7:25PM
I love Jon Stewart too!I loved your comment.You might as well put Bill Maher in the same category.They both tell it like it is.I like them both for it.
Report This
By: Judy on 6/29/2011 7:00PM
America cant stand that liberal extremisist moon bat John Stewart. Fox is correct about him. They should take that boy off tv. God bless America.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Allisine on 6/29/2011 7:25PM
This is so ironic. This is a case of the pot calling the kettle black.Or matbe an example of an oxymoron,or maybe just moron.as racist as Fox is this is really funny.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: max on 6/30/2011 3:37AM
Goldberg chose to focus on his interpretation of Stewart's mimicking of Cain rather than address Stewarts comment on Cain's appeal to those who cannot read lengthy documents. Cain professed an uneducated approach in a style that mocked Adfrican American speech patterns. Where is the Goldberg outrage at this?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: bplayread on 6/30/2011 1:24AM
The phrase 'dog whistling to black people' is an insult. Is that how other ethic leaders are appealing to their core groups? This is so rude.
Reply to this Comment | Report This