
Jon Stewart has thumped with the folks over at Fox News before, both on "The Daily Show" and on occasion, to their faces. (Last week, Stewart went on "Fox News Sunday with Chris Wallace" and mockingly, but pointedly, went in on the conservative-leaning network.)
Now Bernie Goldberg, a frequent contributor to the network, has fired back at Stewart in a FoxNews.com blogpost titled "Is Jon Stewart Racist?" In it, Goldberg argues that liberals and conservatives are held to different standards when it comes to issues of race, and when criticizing black politicians in particular. Goldberg accused Jon Stewart of impersonating Herman Cain, the Republican presidential candidate, in an "exaggerated 'Amos & Andy' 'black voice.'"
"But why isn't Jon Stewart a bigot, when Limbaugh and Hannity and O'Reilly would be tagged as racists if they had done the very same thing?" Goldberg asks. "That's easy. Because Jon Stewart is a liberal and liberals aren't racists. Only conservatives are."
Here's video that has Goldberg so incensed. (The Cain bit starts at the 1:50 mark.)
Cain has said that Stewart doesn't like him because he's a black conservative, and that he's often mocked for his political leanings. "I have been called "Uncle Tom," "sell out," "Oreo," "shameless," he said at a recent campaign event. "So the fact that he wants to mock me because I happen to be a black conservative, in the words of my grandfather, "I does not care. I does not care."
Alex Alvarez has been watching this whole kerfuffle, and laments what he sees as the cynical way charges of racism are employed in American politics. "In the long term, it serves only to reduce matters of race and ethnicity to trump cards held, at the ready, in the back pockets of pundits and politicians on either side of the aisle, to be pulled out whenever it suits either side," he writes.
To spiral off Alvarez's point, Incidents like this --- hurling allegations of racism at an ideological opponent, and then the obligatory hand-wringing over whether that person or their behavior was in fact, racist --- reaffirm the idea that being called a racist is worse than actually experiencing racism. Goldberg isn't so much concerned with discrimination so much as he's mad that he feels that his fellow conservatives get a bad rap for perpetuating it.
This brouhaha also speaks to how Cain has made his blackness a major part of to his pitch to be president. (In 2008, Obama resorted to dogwhistling to black people, but his campaign assiduously avoided talking too explicitly or too long about race.) Cain is pitching himself as a familiar type --- the aggrieved conservative dogged by the media --- but with a racialized twist. Maybe it's because he needs to find some way to differentiate himself from a field of Republican candidates that's ideologically more or less the same. But part of it is because Republicans, like Goldberg, are clamoring for cover from charges of being the party of racists (see: the selection of Michael Steele as head of the Republican National Committee).
And who better to do that for them than an actual black man? Even if he's just a fringe candidate with no shot of winning anything?


Comments: (30)
Add a comment
By: bryan.lipscomb on 6/30/2011 7:05AM
This is just another of numerous examples of Fox News and their croonies having egg on their faces. Like one person explained in an earlier post, Jon Stewart did a special segment of him impersonating about 30 separate public figures on his show last night from the past years and they were every famous or known person that the media covers. Some were minorities, but most were white, so for bernie goldberg to call jon stewart a racist for impersonating herman cain, is like calling Fox news fair and balanced...its totally off base and untrue. jon stewart is a comedian and is funny. the last clip of impersonations was that of michael bloomberg with the gay voice. that was hilarious to top off his point that herman cain wasn't the first and won't be the last person that jon stewart will impersonate. The Fox is running on one leg as usual folks, keep sticking it to them jon.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Ronin on 6/30/2011 11:34AM
test
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: krr on 7/02/2011 8:43AM
OMG! Stew is funny! That piece is not racist. If folks paid attention and got the joke, he's making fun of Cain saying he would shorten the length of bills so that people wouldn't have to read so much. Once again, Republican's and Pea Party idiots are grasping for political straws to protect their token minority candidates that I guarantee you that they won't even vote for. The Republicans would rather see Cain as their butler than as a true candidate.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: S T on 7/02/2011 7:22PM
Anyone who doesn't believe Jon Stewart is a racist is living in La La Land where only white blacks are allowed to live next to the fat cat white folks.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Dean on 7/03/2011 2:58PM
From Florida,who is Herman Cain?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Judy on 7/05/2011 7:56PM
America cannot stand that moon bat nut Jon Stewart. We agree with FOX news. Fox news is always right because of their researsh and non bias stand on the issues effecting the citizens of America. In God we Trust.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Judy on 7/06/2011 6:49PM
We agree with the FOX NEWS Channel on this issue. Their research is always the best. Jon Stewart is indeed a racist against white citizens playing up some politicaly correct garbage again. He should be removed from TV. In God We Trust.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Meanchick on 7/07/2011 12:25AM
I know the difference between a comedian and a political analyst. I do not like Cain because he is divisive. His whole 'Obama is not black enough' attitude sickens me. I only hear him making statements about Obama and about race, but not about Healthcare, The Economy, The Defecit,
The War(s), Unemployment and Education.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: zjohn on 7/07/2011 12:38AM
I would like to point out some of the primary supporters of Hermain Cain. Cain frequently hosted for Neal Boortz and Sean Hannity of WSB AM Radio. Hermain Cain recites verbatium all of the positions put forth by The Heritage Foundation as expoused by Boortz and Hannity. Neither Boortz nor Hannity subbed for Cain during my listening of these AM Radio [sic] Programs..
It is critical to fully understand the proposed candidates mindsets in order to determine if their [sic] leadership is what your neighbors will hug you for.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: -k- on 7/07/2011 5:49PM
I think the reason why Fox is hitting this so hard is because, unlike most of what they try to throw at him, they know they're not making this one up. I love TDS, but I saw that episode when it originally aired, and I cringed. I also saw last week's "this can't be wrong, I do voices for everybody!" montage, and to me it was another step in the wrong direction. Stewart is smart enough to recognize that it's a disingenuous argument that relies on a total suspension of awareness of the social and historical context in which he 'did' Cain. Great, he does a lot of voices, and he's not the greatest at them-he's the first to admit it-but he took it to a place that it shouldn't have gone, and I wish he'd just acknowledge that rather than digging himself deeper.
Reply to this Comment | Report This